5 ms·
Could a handgun really deter a crowd of 40 to 60 people? Especially if some might be packing heat themselves? Or could just overpower you regardless? There's s
by Apocryphon 10y ago
Could a handgun really deter a crowd of 40 to 60 people? Especially if some might be packing heat themselves? Or could just overpower you regardless?
There's situations where concealed carry could help but I'm not sure if this case is one of them.
- mullen 10y agoCrowds scatter when a gun comes out. No one sticks around to find out if it is real, fake or the holder is actually going use it.
- Apocryphon 10y agoI think the counter is that when the crowd is the aggressor, you don't know if anyone in it has guns of their own. If they see you as a threat then they'd take you out in kind, and there's more of them.
- hackermailman 10y agoSounds better than doing nothing while hoping a mob stops beating your mother because she doesn't have anything to give them. Does any transit have actual security we give them millions per year where I live and there's not a visible cop in sight ever unless they are parked in front of a busy station handing out fines.
- Apocryphon 10y agoIf you're in a situation when the personal safety of you or someone else you're with is directly being compromised with physical assault, you'd better be fighting back with everything you've got, including your bare fists.
- dllthomas 10y ago... maybe? You should be taking the course of action that's most likely to lead to the best outcomes. If it's one-on-60, it's not clear to me that fighting back is that course of action. (I really don't know what is best in that situation.)
- dragonwriter 10y agoInside a BART car, a crowd can't scatter, so you favor the other side of the fight or flight reflex.
- fiter 10y agoI would not take part in an event where I had a >1/60 chance of being killed.
- Apocryphon 10y agoSure, but you're not a reckless teen with an undeveloped sense of self-preservation.
- AcerbicZero 10y agoA train is probably the optimal situation for deterring a large group with only a handgun, assuming you have a chance to draw before they swarm you. Long straight lines, plenty of bodies in a row, ~10-15 rounds, and you could probably cut that 60 number down into the 40's surprisingly quickly. Depends on how crowded the train is in general though.
- jacquesm 10y agoAnd kill a couple of innocent commuters with your ricochets and misses. Or did you think that your ability to tell the 16 year old that wasn't part of it from the 16 year that was when you're in a hurry mowing people down was still functioning? Life isn't a FPS. I hope that if I'm ever in the subway and it's robbed that you are not in the same car, same for any other dirty Harry wannabe's. Better to hand over my wallet and cell phone than to end up with a bullet from a well meaning bystander.
- jimmyk 10y agoIt's estimated that guns are used defensively (not necessarily fired) by private individuals hundreds of thousands of times per year in the US, and yet we don't see an epidemic of innocent bystanders being accidentally shot. Why do you think that might be? Could it be that your characterization of concealed carriers as "dirty Harry wannabe's" is wildly inaccurate?
- jacquesm 10y agoRead that comment again: the guy is seriously considering going on a shooting spree with a train full of commuters and robbers. What do you think the chances are of that working out? Do you think this upstanding citizen and class-A marksman will be able to place '10 to 15 rounds' (his words, not mine) with the precision required not to injure anybody else? http://americablog.com/2013/02/vigilante-walmart-shopper-opens-fire-on-shoplifter-hits-three-cars.html http://americablog.com/2013/02/vigilante-walmart-shopper-ope... http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3252074/Police-looking-vigilante-carjacking-witness-shot-thieves-accidentally-hit-victim-head-fleeing-scene.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3252074/Police-looki... (uk) http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/264755/carjacking-gone-wrong-houston-texas/ http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/264755/carjacking-gone-wrong... http://www.masslive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2015/10/vigilantes_worry_even_gun_inst.html http://www.masslive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2015/10/vigilantes... How many links do you want? Those were much less complex situations. And you think putting all that in a crowded subway car is going to improve matters?
- millermp12 10y agoCA should simply mandate that all taxpayers carry a jar of Vaseline. To make sure the objects of their oppression don't chafe needlessly during their reparations exercises.