3 ms·
Thank you. Well it's simple: we agree that violent encounters are rare. And we presumably agree that it's not the incidence rate but that times the cost of bein
by EGreg 10y ago
Thank you. Well it's simple: we agree that violent encounters are rare. And we presumably agree that it's not the incidence rate but that times the cost of being shot that informs your actions. So the actions can very well be changed by even a 1% chance per encounter of something like that. Would you fly with a 1% chance of death? How would that affect the economy?
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, but what's the real chance per encounter? There's 600-700 thousand sworn officers in the US. Assume they interact with 1 person per day each (they aren't on duty everyday, they probably interact with more people than that on duty days). So it's easily in the ballpark of 200 million encounters each year. There's less than 200 officers killed in the line of duty each year. You are sort of saying that the police are aggressive because they don't want to die. I'm saying that (given the statistics for the US) they shouldn't have much leeway to let that feeling influence their actions.
- EGreg 10y ago1. First of all not all police officers are in the field every day, many have desk jobs. And not every interaction is of the type that could provoke an altercation. Going out to the scene of a fender bender is unlikely to lead to a shooting. In all the above situations you'll find the police quite calm and courteous, not yelling for people to "get in the ground" or "put your hands where I can see em". However, at traffic stops, raids and random unexpected encounters on the street, the situation is different. Now the number is probably closer to 10 million encounters per year than 200 million. So now divide by 200 cops shot a year and you get a 1 in 50,000 chance per encounter. 2. The statistics of a cop being shot are after they have done all the preventative steps of avoidance, pre emptive aggression and assertion of authority. The relevant question would be, what if cops would always enter a situation calmly trying to de escalate the situation, without clear instructions to "get out of the car" or "drop on the floor" and without guns drawn. What would the rate of cop shootings be then? Suppose it goes up to 1 in 5,000. Would you as a cop be ok with such chances? 3. The trade offs are being tested all the time here and there, and the institutions usually react by erring on the side of cop safety every time something happens or could happen. Perception of fear leads to extra training to "take control of the situation" given that anyone could be armed. My point was: now multiply the 5,000 by 100 and we are back to 500,000 which can have huge policy implications and make cops institutionally nicer. That would change the NORM. Which you can see across the board - I made a prediction that amount of ranged weapons per capita in a population is going to be strongly correlated with police brutality.