3 ms·
These claims by Musk and the FB exec are pretty outlandish. Any type of surgery is very high risk. Brain surgery is incredibly dangerous. There's a reason why s
by djsumdog 10y ago
These claims by Musk and the FB exec are pretty outlandish. Any type of surgery is very high risk. Brain surgery is incredibly dangerous. There's a reason why so few surgeons specialise in it. The article even mentions one of the human trials which used implants was directed at people who were already paralysed.
But all that aside, developing sensor technology that could get accurate measures of brain activity in a non-invasive and non-destructive way would be quite a breakthrough (and really the first step to anything more substantial. Until we invent nano-robots, implants will simply be way too dangerous).
We have no real idea of how the brain works. It's so vastly different from any machine we've ever designed, filled with redundancy and not only electrical signals, but chemical signals that combine to create all kinds of inputs and feedback. Trying to read our stream of consciousness is not an easy task, as it may not be represented in the brain in a way we could recognise with instruments (or even in one discrete location in the brain at all).
Brain research is always amazing, but it also shows just how far humanity is lacking in our own understanding of the world. Advertising/Propaganda, the Stanley Milgram Experiments, conformity experiments all suggest brains may be more deterministic than we care to admit. We have hundreds of thousands of inputs (skin, eyes, internal pain/nerve cells, hearing) and there's no way we could raise twins in a lab and control all those inputs to see if we can get two humans to always do the same thing (ethically).
I wonder if we ever do create machines/AI that have connotative abilities and that can understand self-awareness; if they may end up telling us that they (and in turn us) don't actually have the free well we think we do.
- adrianN 10y agoDon't start the free will discussion, please, the term is basically meaningless. If you try to define it with sufficient precision to make a conversation about the topic possible you get people who disagree with the definition.
- r3bl 10y ago> These claims by Musk and the FB exec are pretty outlandish. Except that those are not claims made by Musk and Zuckerberg. Musk-related, the article says: > He says that within eight to 10 years healthy people could be getting brain implants as new computer interfaces. While in WBW's article Musk's quote is: > I think we are about 8 to 10 years away from this being usable by people with no disability … It is important to note that this depends heavily on regulatory approval timing and how well our devices work on people with disabilities. Notice the second part, which this article totally dismisses. That was his optimistic, "if all goes perfect" claim. From the article: > What makes it even remotely okay that Musk and Facebook are promising the public telepathy within a few short years? ...while Zuckerberg's quote is: > I would be pretty disappointed if in 25 years we hadn’t made some progress towards thinking things to computers.
- komali2 10y ago>free will Minefield. I could point you to an extremely logical, well-founded, rigorous, and ancient argument that free will is nonexistent. Then I can turn around and point you to an equally logical, well-founded, rigorous, and ancient argument that it must exist. I always say, who cares?
- marksc 10y agoSo pessimistic. We don't need to know how brains work to have useful interactions with them, even pulling out pictures and words from neural activity. That sensor breakthrough has already happened- and no dangerous intermediate step was necessary. opnwatr can make 8 million 100micron wide scans 120 times per second with what is basically a slightly modified version of cheap commodity/consumer hardware (using IR LEDs).[1] fMRI is slower and lower resolution and can still be used to extract images from brains in real-time. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=llL62bRsMIs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=llL62bRsMIs