6 ms·
Behind Carder Kingpin Roman Seleznev’s Record 27 Year Sentence
- abhirag 10y agoThe letter he wrote to the court was an interesting read(https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/04/21/technology/document-Seleznev-Letter.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/04/21/technology/do...), still don't know what to make of it though.
- narag 10y agoThe article mentions that he's the son of a powerful man and that letter starts saying that he was poor. How's that? Also, where did the millions he stole go?
- boomboomsubban 10y agoA legislator from Russia's third largest party likely isn't that powerful, and he definitely would not have been when Roman was a child. Plus, doesn't sound like he was very involved, divorcing his mother and having three other sons in other marriages plus starting a business career.
- rajacombinator 10y agoStill waiting for one wall st exec to be charged for their roles in the crash ...
- ChemicalWarfare 10y agonot sure why he's getting downvoted. even the tip of the iceberg that is known to us warrants all sorts of prosecution.
- Analemma_ 10y agoIf you take this argument to its logical conclusion, we should never convict anybody of any crimes ever.
- csydas 10y agoNot necessarily - wanting even justice to be dispensed isn't the same thing as saying if one person gets away with it everyone should. It's quite a bit meta to the article, but relevant in that both defrauded money from the general public, made a fortune from it, but Seleznev is paying while the others are not. It's a little strange to focus just on Seleznev when we have people who make it a practice to skim money and don't get in trouble for it when they do cost the US public billions.
- igivanov 10y agocan't speak for you but for me the logical conclusion would be bringing them to justice.
- tptacek 10y agoHow? Gut feel? The laws we have today are inadequate to bringing cases, and we have a Constitutional prohibition on ex post facto laws.
- igivanov 10y agoDunno how, IANAL. But I trust that the US government, or the establishment in general, can make anyone's life miserable if there is a political will. Also, have the laws been amended to deal with similar offenses in the future?
- mabbo 10y agoGiven the amount of evidence brought against him, it's very hard to have sympathy. He defrauded literally millions of people. He made a fortune doing so.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoThis guy is a scumbag and a criminal but he defrauded banks and card networks, and those banks and networks attempted to pass that liability onto their customers. It's an important distinction.
- tptacek 10y agoIn what sense? The law does not much care how poorly the banks and card networks secured or underwrote their services; it cares mostly about the person who had the intent to defraud and harm people, and then carried that intent to fruition.
- johansch 10y agoI guess the argument is that if they should get the profit margin, they should also own the losses. I think I agree. (Doesn't change a thing about this guy's criminal responsibility, of course.)
- tyingq 10y agoOnline credit card fraud is paid for by merchant sellers...not banks or credit card companies. The banks and CC companies make money from the fraud, assuming the charge back fees they levy exceed their internal costs. At least in the US.
- ChemicalWarfare 10y agoThis isn't chargeback-type fraud though, also not limited to card-not-present scenarios (the crooks actually print physical "copies" with stolen card info on the magstripe). If someone buys goods/services with a stolen CC and money between the issuing and acquiring banks exchanges hands, unless there's something very specific there that can shift liability towards the merchant - it's not that easy for the banks to demand the funds from the merchant.
- rodionos 10y ago> a group that hacked into restaurants ... and planted malicious software to steal card data from store point-of-sale devices I've started compartmentalizing my spending a few years ago, using different cards for different purposes. For instance using debit cards for the riskiest locales. On several occasions I asked to lower the credit limit to reduce the risk of underwriting the entirety of losses. Also, the sentence is harsh. I don't think sentencing a criminal for more years than he deserves just 'to send a message' is called justice.
- meritt 10y ago> For instance using debit cards for the riskiest locales That seems counter-intuitive to me. If there's going to be a fraudulent charge on my account, I'd rather it be a temporary charge that can be resolved instead of actually taking money from my checking account until the bank decides to refund the fraud. I almost never use my debit card for this exact reason and use credit cards for everything possible.
- nathancahill 10y agoYeah, GP is wrong, I think that's common knowledge.
- scythe 10y ago>the sentence is harsh. EDIT: inaccurate -- see 'tptacek below Sentences in the United States have a de jure length which is longer than the de facto length. Usually a 27-year convict will be eligible for parole after about 9 years. I didn't see anything in the article about denying parole (which is very rare). Considering the number of people Selezny harmed and the fact that he continued to do so after he knew that there were warrants for his arrest, I think that a decade in prison is a reasonable sanction. Also, the extended sentence is not so much "to send a message" as it is in response to his evasion of the authorities. That message was sent a long time ago.
- tptacek 10y agoThere is no parole in the federal system. 27 years will mean almost 27 years (maybe something closer to 23 if everything breaks Seleznev's way in prison).
- conistonwater 10y ago> In chat messages between Seleznev and an associate from 2008, Seleznev stated that he had obtained protection through the law enforcement contacts in the computer crime squad of the FSB. What the hell? That is all kinds of messed up.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoBut sadly not uncommon. If you have a lot of money you can induce people who want or need money to act against their better judgement. It works even better if you have some way of threatening their lifestyle and is standard trade craft for intelligence agencies trying to develop assets.
- pcl 10y agoCached copy: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:7JW-NVLXRAsJ:https://krebsonsecurity.com/2017/04/the-backstory-behind-carder-kingpin-roman-seleznevs-record-27-year-prison-sentence/+&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:7JW-NV...
- sunstone 10y agoHow does jurisdiction work in a case like this? He presumably never set foot in the US so how does the law claim jurisdiction for the crime? If someone uses telephones to defraud US citizens in a similar way, ie remotely, do the same jurisdiction rules apply? How about selling fraudulent goods in the US shipped in from abroad?
- tptacek 10y agoIt's based on where the harm occurs; in this case, there's a clear connection to specific locations in the US. The US doesn't have trials in absentia, so the important issue here is mostly extradition, and that boils down "if you're caught in a country that (a) recognizes the crime you're being charged with in its own jurisdiction, (b) has an extradition treaty with the US, and (c) believes based on the US's extradition filings that the US has a legitimate case, you're going to end up standing trial in the US. This case is a little more complicated in that Interpol appears to have been the controlling authority for extraditing Seleznev from Maldives, but again, the principle is less that of jurisdiction than of the propriety of extradition.
- tptacek 10y agoHere is a weird example of where I'm going to be the one saying this sentence is too long, while lots of HN people will be saying this is finally(!) an example of someone who actually deserves a harsh sentence. Not because Seleznev merits any sympathy. He does not. Moreover, he's part of a class of people who I think deserve the very least amount of empathy in our public policy (people with ability and opportunities who weren't forced by circumstance into crime, but pursued it out of vanity and avarice). Rather, the problem is that 27 years doesn't accomplish anything that 5 years wouldn't. Presuming that the result of this conviction is that the USG can effectively claw back much of the proceeds of the crimes, then 5 years would presumably have the same retributive and deterrent effects. Our sentences are too long across the board.
- bradleyjg 10y ago"Presuming that the result of this conviction is that the USG can effectively claw back much of the proceeds of the crimes, then 5 years would presumably have the same retributive and deterrent effects." I can see a strong argument for same, or close to the same, deterrent effects -- it's a pretty straightforward marginal argument supported in the literature (i.e. the swiftness and sureness of a punishment has more of an influence on deterrence than the severity of the punishment). But I don't see how you can make that argument for retributive effect. The worse the punishment the stronger the retributive effect. In order for the retributive effect to be about the same for five years and 27 years there'd have to be diminishing marginal disutility to offender for additional years of prison. I don't think that's empirically observed -- prisons use the threat of additional time, along with privileges, as a management tool inside prisons. Whether or not we as a society should be satisfied with the disutility of five years worth of prison for this particular crime and whether retribitutivism is an appropriate measure of justice to begin with are different questions.
- tptacek 10y agoThe harm to the government and to financial institutions was acute, but the harm to individuals was (mostly) diffuse. What single victim of Seleznev's would have an argument for suffering beyond (say) 5 years? It's not actually the case that more punishment = more retribution. The concept of retributive justice is that society should mete out a proportionate punishment, rather than see justice miscarried in either direction, or carried out haphazardly by victims themselves.
- ungzd 10y ago> The U.S. Justice Department says the laptop found with him when he was arrested contained more than 1.7 million stolen credit card numbers How it's possible that one of the world's top criminals highly skilled in computer security had these credit card numbers on his own laptop and even unencrypted?
- alasdair_ 10y agoPossibly the same way that the Dread Pirate Roberts (Silk Road) was captured - the FBI simply grabbed him before he could turn off his laptop.
- celticninja 10y agoLikely as he thought he was in a non extradition country so probably didn't think his arrest was likely.
- aidenn0 10y ago1) OpSec is hard 2) When you get away with something for long enough you get a sense of invulnerability 3) OpSec is hard
- WalterBright 10y agoI had a merchant account so I could accept credit cards online. This was fine for years, and then I got a persistent carding attack, about one every minute or so. It happened at night, so my desperate calls to the bank to shut off the account went unanswered. By morning, I had thousands of fake transactions and a whopping bill for it. I refused to pay, because the fraud happened at their end, I did my best to stop it in a timely manner, and their staff didn't answer the phone at night. I did get the charges stopped, but the merchant bank said in the future I'd be held responsible. They could not offer me any solution that they'd stand behind. So I cancelled my account, and switched to other providers that stood behind their security.
- jacquesm 10y agoThe whole 'pass the risk to the merchant' system is broken by design. Everybody that could do something about it passes the buck and the only part that can't do anything about it is held responsible. Merchant contracts are terrible, especially the on-line variety.
- tomsaj 10y agoHE was illegally kidnapped from a country to be brought to the US. Anyone thinks Russia can't do the same live in lalaland.
- wand3r 10y agoSure. 2 points; I subjectively view this crine as much less admirable than a simple bank robbery or Ross ulbricht (less the alleged murder attempts) as this causes individuals direct harm. This is subjective, I think others may agree that identity theft is pretty malicious. Also, yes Russia could kidnap you if you committed enough crimes for them to dub you worth tracking, capturing, negotiating a diplomatic extradition and then trying in court. Its not likely many "regular" people will be carted away from a Bahamian Vaca.