4 ms·
I don't do it myself any more (because I don't like having my posts downvoted to the point that nobody replies to them) but I used to be exactly the type of per
by derefr 10y ago
I don't do it myself any more (because I don't like having my posts downvoted to the point that nobody replies to them) but I used to be exactly the type of person you're referring to.
The thing was, I didn't actually have any certainty about anything. I just thought that the best way to talk about an issue was to pick a "side" (often at random), and let other people pick their "side", and then defend your "side" every time it gets rebutted, gradually researching the issue from the perspective of your side in order to best steel-man your own position, while assuming others are doing the same in reaction to your own arguments.
In other words, basically pretending internet comments are a debate club, or a court-room, where you're not seeking truth in an Aumann's-agreement-theorem "both people gradually converge onto the truth" way, but rather an adversarial discovery system where the truth comes out for the audience in the compilation of evidence presented by both sides, whether those sides see it themselves or not.
I don't know, it was fun at the time. Maybe I was a teenager with a lot of testosterone.
- lmm 10y agoI think it works. I mean there's a reason we use this approach for courts and elections, the cases where getting the truth is the most important for society.
- derefr 10y agoSure it works, sometimes; the problem is more that it's a particular social game that people (like my younger self) would decide to just start up in the middle of an otherwise not-debate-oriented discussion, without giving any context to what they were doing. I'd just assert a bald-faced claim of something I knew shit-all about, wait for a rebuttal to show up, and then do quick, angry research in order to parry said rebuttal. Until you see such a thread go four or five levels deep, it's not really clear that that's what's happening, and so you might want to join such a thread as a sane, calm individual, only to have your own argument taken apart "by the seams" in response (e.g. asserting that due to errors in your deduction, you didn't prove your point, even if you may be right) without engaging with its content. Good for lawyering, bad for truth-seeking. If you then are willing to get baited into playing the game in response, honing your own attack to be bulletproof like a lawyer would, then the truth might eventually find its way out. But if you didn't want to play this game, you'll probably just quit when you realize what's happening, maybe with a petulant "you kno what? Screw this." at the guy who just can't seem to get your words through their head (when they never even believed in their chosen position, so there's no convincing to be done.) If you explicitly indicate that you want to play this game, it could be great fun for all parties. But I know from experience that the other side of this—being baited into playing without knowing the game is afoot—is painful, and can burn people out on a forum community.
- Arizhel 10y agoInteresting. Maybe there's a problem because of differing expectations then. I can also see parallels in the legal system, and in differing legal systems: the adversarial system used in English common-law countries is not universal, for instance. Personally, I think the adversarial system is inherently and downright bad and wrong. The idea isn't to get to the actual truth, it's merely to win the argument at all costs. There might be an idea that this efficiently gets to the truth, but I don't think it does at all; this system just finds who's better at arguing. An inquisitorial system I think is superior at getting to the actual truth. See your own comment about "good for lawyering, bad for truth-seeking": I think this is exactly what's wrong with the common-law system. Personally, do like to play devil's advocate a fair amount, but not to the extent where I need to actually win the argument, I just want to make sure all sides are covered and that people aren't missing something major by hopping on a bandwagon or engaging in group-think. There's a big difference between this and just endlessly arguing one side without actual regard to the truth or the merits of the other sides (and there may be many--another problem with this adversarial approach that always assumes only 2 sides). Also related, personally I think formal academic debates are similarly bad and wrong, though not quite as bad as lawyering because at least with academic ones someone's life or welfare is not directly impacted by the contest over who's a better arguer.