2 ms·
Privacy International sound like obtuse blowhards in this piece. Once you're promiscuously logging unencrypted wifi traffic, it's harder to throw away the poss
by gojomo 16y ago
Privacy International sound like obtuse blowhards in this piece.
Once you're promiscuously logging unencrypted wifi traffic, it's harder to throw away the possibly-sensitive parts of 'payload data' than to just store it all for later. Storing indiscriminately may be careless, but it is easier to code. Also, store-it-all and analyze/carve/blind-it-later is far more in keeping with MapReduce/BigTable/etc data-mining ethos of a place like Google. So Google's explanation is more credible than Privacy International's speculation.
This doesn't absolve Google -- and the engineer(s) who wrote and deployed the code in question -- from all responsibility. An alarm should have gone off in someone's head -- "collecting this data is problematic!" But it's plausible one person wrote the best scanner they could, and then later another wrote the most comprehensive storage layer they could, and either no one understood the combined impact, or the only person(s) who did were especially obtuse/cavalier about privacy issues. (Lots of niches in the new economy reward, rather than punish, a blaise attitude about privacy details -- at least until it reaches the level of public scandal.)