3 ms·
> The U.S. retirement system looks more even-handed if you include in the analysis all government benefits received and all taxes paid by Americans after age 50
by loeg 10y ago
> The U.S. retirement system looks more even-handed if you include in the analysis all government benefits received and all taxes paid by Americans after age 50.
This graph shows a roughly flat benefits-less-revenue per quintile, but is still disingenuous because it ignores revenue from under age 50. Social security payouts start as early as 62 — so this only factors in 12-20 working years and ignores the first 28-32 working years. I would guess the higher quintiles at 50 also paid more in Social Security taxes during their younger working years.
I suspect a lifetime graph of benefits less revenue would show the system is still progressive, if not as progressive as it was 30 years ago.
Either way — the headline statement, "Wealthy Americans Consumer Disproportionately More Social Security," is false.
- jeffdavis 10y agoI am confused by the wording of that graph. Does it include a lifetime of contributions and a lifetime of benefits? Or 12-15 years of contributions and a lifetime of benefits?
- loeg 10y agoI read it as "After age 50 by income group," but it is somewhat ambiguous. Maybe it uses "lifetime" to distinguish ordinary payouts from survivor benefits? I'm not sure.
- twoodfin 10y agoI think it's the (less interesting) average benefit minus tax per year, not in aggregate. The latter is presumably much harder to measure. I'd be shocked if high earners with average life expectancies could expect to recoup (inflation-adjusted) their lifetime contributions, given the "bend points" of the benefits formula.
- basseq 10y agoCorrect. Given average life expectancies, the IRR of contributions vs. benefits of Upper-Middle and Top 20% are 2.9% and 1.7%, respectively. Given a 3.22% inflation rate, both are negative (meaning the returns don't even keep up with inflation).