3 ms·
I dunno, "living longer" is one of the least offensive ways someone can get disproportionately more money from taxpayers. I think the focus should be on the opi
by sp332 10y ago
I dunno, "living longer" is one of the least offensive ways someone can get disproportionately more money from taxpayers. I think the focus should be on the opioid epidemic that is shortening middle-aged people's lives.
- NoGravitas 10y agoWell, it's concerning that in the US, wealthier people live longer. Generally, when you hear someone trying to justify the extreme wealth inequality of the US (compared to most of the developed world), the response is along the lines of, "well, there's huge inequality in relative terms, but that's not important, because in absolute terms, the poor in the US are pretty well off". But if being poor in the US means you die young, then wealth inequality is pretty important in terms of quality of life!
- pdonis 10y ago> if being poor in the US means you die young That's not what the article is saying. According to the table it gives, the life expectancy of the bottom 20% is still 76.1 years. That's not "young". It is significantly younger than the top 20%. > wealth inequality is pretty important in terms of quality of life I think it's hard to make this case just based on life expectancy; what we really need is some way of quantifying how healthy the bottom 20% are from, say, age 60 on (or even earlier), compared to the top 20%. I suspect that this would show a much larger disparity than just the life expectancy data.
- Recurecur 10y ago> The life expectancy of the bottom 20% is still 76.1 years. That's not "young". It's also worth considering that the lowest 20% is much more likely to encounter violent crime, and also more likely to enlist in the military. I'm sure those things play into lower life expectancy as well.
- pdonis 10y agoThe key thing to look at here would be the variability: what is the standard deviation of life expectancy for the bottom 20%, vs. the top 20%? The factors you bring up would suggest that the SD should be significantly higher for the bottom 20%.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoThere was an article in The Nation earlier this year which gave a little more detail on the life expectancy issue: https://www.thenation.com/article/why-are-poor-americans-dying-so-much-earlier-than-rich-americans/ https://www.thenation.com/article/why-are-poor-americans-dyi... As for how socioeconomic inequalities translate into inequities in life span, “It’s rather mysterious,” said Lisa Berkman, the director of the Center for Population and Development Studies at Harvard University. One answer is that low-income people tend to be sicker in the first place, because the neighborhoods they can afford to live in are more polluted; because they can’t afford to adopt and maintain healthy behaviors; because they can’t afford health insurance premiums, copayments, and prescription drugs. Woolf accounts much of the disparity in death rates to what he calls “stress-related conditions.” People who aren’t secure economically are likely to experience high levels of stress, which studies have linked to shorter lifespans and a heightened risk of death from strokes, heart attacks, and other illnesses. “We’re seeing a dramatic increase in deaths from opioids, whether we’re talking about prescription painkiller or heroin, but also from suicides, liver disease, and other conditions that I personally feel come from different ways that people are coping, in an unhealthy way, with the stresses that they’re facing in their daily lives,” Woolf said, particularly since the recession. Smoking, the leading cause of preventable death, takes a particularly costly toll on low-income people. Berkman traces at least some of the stress load on lower-income Americans to changes in the workplace. The 1920s cohort analyzed by the Brookings researchers had their greatest earnings in the 40s and 50s, a time of economic growth and greater equality across the income spectrum. While low-income people born in the 1940s entered a labor market that was less demanding physically, they may also have experienced greater insecurity as wages stagnated, and difficulty balancing work and family life as more women entered the workforce. Unlike many other peer countries with more robust family support, the United States didn’t do much to accommodate the increased challenges facing working parents, Berkman noted. “The second wave of occupational risk are sets of working conditions that are hugely stressful,” she said. “They aren’t so physically stressful, but they’re socially stressful. They’re insecure, they’re inflexible, or they have no ability to balance work and family issues. We need to rethink what occupational health and safety is.”
- clarkm 10y agoThe story isn't so simple. Hispanics have a longer life expectancy than non-Hispanic whites in the US, despite having much lower income levels. This is known as the Hispanic Epidemiological Paradox, and a lot of research has gone into studying this: https://www.princeton.edu/main/news/archive/S46/31/53A76/ https://www.princeton.edu/main/news/archive/S46/31/53A76/
- Retric 10y agoThey live longer, are more likely to be married, get a lot more per month, and have a capped tax.
- sp332 10y agoWhat's the cap?
- snissn 10y agoIn 2017, the Social Security Wage Base was $127,200 and the Social Security tax rate was 6.20% paid by the employee and 6.20% paid by the employer.[1] A person with $10,000 of gross income had $620.00 withheld as Social Security tax from his check and the employer sent an additional $620.00. A person with $130,000 of gross income in 2017 incurred Social Security tax of $7,886.40 (resulting in an effective rate of approximately 6.07% - the rate was lower because the income was more than the 2017 "wage base", see below), with $7,886.40 paid by the employer. A person who earned a million dollars in wages paid the same $7,886.40 in Social Security tax (resulting in an effective rate of approximately 0.79%), with equivalent employer matching. In the cases of the $130k and $1m earners, each paid the same amount into the social security system, and both will take the same out of the social security system. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Wage_Base https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Wage_Base
- lg 10y agoif we lift the tax cap, can we also lift the benefit cap?
- Retric 10y agoAs long as it's still a diminishing return and includes investment income, I have no problem with that. The real issue IMO, is it's simply not diminishing enough relative to expected lifespans, and there is a huge benefit associated with being married.
- gregable 10y agoThere is no benefit cap, just a progressive rate. At low lifetime contributions, you get 90% benefit compared to contribution. As you increase your contribution this moves up to marginal rates of 32 and 15%.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]