4 ms·
I am traveling in West Africa right now, and the same applies to this part of the world. This place is very, very different from that portrayed by the Western
by grecy 10y ago
I am traveling in West Africa right now, and the same applies to this part of the world.
This place is very, very different from that portrayed by the Western Media.
I was sitting in the Nigerian Embassy waiting for a visa, and an American tv show was on.. NCIS or something, and they had these American "heros" over in some African hell-hole saving the world.. of course they get attacked and then work hard to survive and find their way to some place. People are being dragged out of cars, men smashed in the face by the butt end of AK47s, women thrown to the ground. People's eyes show pure hatred - enough to actually scare me, even though I was just watching TV.
The show was set in Mali, they were supposedly in Bamako.
The kicker?
I was sitting in Bamako that very moment, having spent over a month there already, walking around every day, on my own, perfectly safe and happy. I even walked around at night multiple times. People would say hello and invite me into their homes.
The reality is that I met hundreds and hundreds of the kindest, friendliest and happiest people I have ever met in Bamako, yet millions of Americans are seeing realistic looking images that it's a complete hell hole.
I have driven through more than 500 road blocks in 10 countries in West Africa, and I have never, ever seen anything remotely scary or threatening. Not even once.
It's simply not true. It's fake.
When Africans see super heros flying around New York saving us from Aliens they know it's not real. When Americans see African Hell holes on TV, they have no idea it's not real. They are being lied to en-mass and have no idea.
(if it makes any difference, I'm white, and driving a not-cheap Jeep around Africa)
- mynameisvlad 10y agoI mean, you're comparing real life with a fictional TV show, what did you expect? People don't watch NCIS with the expectation that it's anything like the real world. I mean, even if you were going to criticize the show, you should probably start with its overly broad definition of the NCIS mission, or why they were in Africa in the first place.
- grecy 10y agoThe problem is the show is so life-like, and so realistic, people believe it. I believed it, and was actually a little nervous to walk out onto the streets of Bamako, which is pure nonsense. And of course, the news also does exactly the same thing. Slow news day - let's pick something bad that happened in one of the 54 countries in Africa to show people. Never mind there are literally a billion people who are extremely friendly, happy and peaceful. Think for a moment what your perception of the USA would be if you lived elsewhere, and the only news you ever got was the bad stuff - mass shootings, police violence, undrinkable water, fires, tornadoes, crappy education, high debt, more shootings, more violence, violence when the president is sworn in, etc. etc.
- ptaipale 10y agoI don't find NCIS life-like or realistic at all. Particularly any of the plot lines related to computer technology. It's obviously a show, not depiction of realistic forensics or data mining procedures - starting from roles of people, their mode of operation and permissions to do things, and also how you would realistically build a UI for doing things.
- grecy 10y agoI'm not even sure it was NCIS. I don't know what it was. There were a bunch of military people in uniform shooting people and getting shot at. No computers, etc. It was about as realistic as saving private ryan. Full on war.
- thesmallestcat 10y agoStupid people believe all kinds of things. Like that fantasy-world TV dramas reflect reality. But most are watching for the entertainment and are willing to suspend disbelief, I think.
- wyldfire 10y agoI've never been to Africa, so my perspective has likely been tainted by media and entertainment programs like the ones you describe. How often did you travel to rural parts of Mali? Is it as safe as Bamako? > ... I met hundreds and hundreds of the kindest, friendliest and happiest people... Over the years, I've learned that most people from most places are sane, regular people just trying to make their way in the world. People from Iran, North Korea, Russia, China, Afghanistan, Tibet, Venezuela -- they're just regular folks like you and me. They get up in the morning, go to work, try to have a good time with friends/family in the evenings. If we were to hold up a mirror and try to judge ourselves based on the outlandish things people do and say that end up being worth news coverage, I think we'd feel some dread about where we live too.
- grecy 10y ago> How often did you travel to rural parts of Mali? Is it as safe as Bamako? No, it's not as safe. Certainly not for a white guy. I didn't go North, but a few friends did around the time I was there and had no problems. Regular ordinary people on the streets are very friendly, but there are bad dudes around up there for sure. Though my point is they were depicting Mali (and Bamako) as a hell on earth, and it's nothing, nothing like the show portrays. I drove through many military stops in the country, and they are basically the opposite of what the show portrayed.
- ptaipale 10y ago> People from Iran, North Korea, Russia, China, Afghanistan, Tibet, Venezuela -- they're just regular folks like you and me Of course. However, the environment where they live may not be so regular. Of course it often surprises you when your expectations and prejudices aren't based on real experience, but crazy regimes make people also behave in crazy ways. Remember the idolatry around Pavel Morozov, for instance.
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, murder of the week television is pretty pernicious. Over here in reality, the 2500 member United States Naval Criminal Investigative Service investigates 30-50 homicides a year (over their entire jurisdiction), most of which will be the sort of stupid crimes that typify murder, not the fascinating puzzles shown each week on the TV. At least CSI, which started the modern explosion of such shows, was set in Clark County Nevada where murder is almost a daily thing.
- Grue3 10y agoGood thing you were in Bamako and not, say, in Timbuktu in 2012-2013 when it was captured by insurgents. Mali is hardly a good example of peace and prosperity.
- grecy 10y agoThat's exactly what I mean. You have this information about bad things that happened (true) and you project it onto an entire country, years after the fact. I could say "Lucky you were not in NYC in 2001... USA is hardly a good example of peace and prosperity" Which is the same nonsense you just said about Mali.