24 ms·
Happy hiring: The firm that recruits Mr Men characters
- DanBC 10y agoMost important for me is: > "We purely interview for personality," says Mr Timpson, who has been leading his family's firm for the past 42 years. > In explaining the thinking behind this rather novel approach to recruitment, Mr Timpson, 74, says that while you can train someone to do a job, you cannot train their personality. Timpson are good in the UK because for a long time they've been happy to interview ex-offenders. https://www.timpson.co.uk/about/careers-at-timpson https://www.timpson.co.uk/about/careers-at-timpson > Timpson really are an equal opportunities employer. We consider anyone for our vacancies as long as they are able to do the job. This includes ex-offenders and other marginalised groups. We recruit exclusively on personality and expect all of colleagues to be happy, confident and chatty individuals. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandconsumer/10266250/Timpson-has-key-to-giving-ex-convicts-second-chance.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandcon... > Susanna Stephens is laughing as she explains an early quirk of her job. "It did seem quite weird that I was going out of a prison to cut keys," says the 37-year-old who works for Timpson, the shoe repairer and key-cutter that has been a family business for five generations. [...] > But Stephens is no conventional recruit because, like 270 other Timpson staff, she joined the company from jail – for a while going to work in the day and returning to jail at night, under the Prison Service’s Release on Temporary Licence scheme.
- maccard 10y agoI never realised they hired so many people out of prison - Bumps them up quite a lot in my books, will try and consider them in future for more things!
- teh_klev 10y agoJohn Timpson (chairman of Timpsons) was on panel of this episode of BBC Radio 4's "The Bottom Line", that was when I first heard about them having a more open mind about ex-offenders. It's an interesting discussion: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04pr0xp http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04pr0xp
- emurray 10y agoI would expect the additional step of > "If they tick all the right boxes then we put them in the shop for half the day." is also very important.
- bjourne 10y ago> Timpson really are an equal opportunities employer. We consider anyone for our vacancies as long as they are able to do the job. This includes ex-offenders and other marginalised groups. We recruit exclusively on personality and expect all of colleagues to be happy, confident and chatty individuals. So it was just a really happy coincidence that the owners son (James Timpson) becamse the chief executive officer? ;)
- Consultant32452 10y agoThis reminds me of an anecdote about my grandfather. He reminisced with me once about how he became a drafter at Martin Marietta (later Lockheed Martin). They basically gave him an IQ test and then offered him the job. They then taught him everything he needed to know about drafting. Not quite the same as hiring ex-cons based entirely on their personality, but in a similar vein imho. Oh how times have changed.
- cylinder 10y agoIQ tests were common in recruiting for corporate America back then. Unfortunately they were ruled as discriminatory so everyone shifted to signaling with credentials from top universities which is much worse IMO.
- blowski 10y agoI found it a bit of an odd article. I alternate between Mr Happy, Mr Grumpy, Mr Angry, Mr Sad. (Fortunately, I'm never Mr Tickle.) While it was interesting, I'd hate for people reading this article to think it was genuinely a good idea as a hiring practice. People are complicated, and cannot and should not be pigeonholed into such simple categories.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI think it's an extremely good idea. Work generally requires people to suppress most of their personality, often tot he point of treating people as completely interchangeable labor units, which is dehumanising. Acknowledging that there are different kinds of people with different personal drives is an excellent approach. Also, most people who grew up in the UK are familiar with the Mr Men & Little Miss books, most of which treat of the titular character encountering some problem in which their regular personality puts them at a disadvantage. Frankly I'd rather deal with someone who displays extensive familiarity with the Mr Men than some buzzword-regurgitating follower of the latest management guru or MBA fad who has mistaken novelty for innovation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- estel 10y ago> it was genuinely a good idea as a hiring practice There's been enough discussion about how fundamentally broken the current recruitment process is (in tech) that this doesn't seem much worse.
- kristianc 10y agoI've been at a workplace where I was sorted by the Dept head into a 'colour' category according to my personality, based on some bullshit test. There were 4(!) colours. I stayed for three months.
- bitwize 10y agoIt's not any worse than other hiring practices, such as the use of Myers-Briggs types, which are thought of approvingly in the business community.
- sandworm101 10y agoI love that they actively try to hire convicts for a job that involves cutting keys. Im sure it is a non-issue in reality, i just laugh at the irony. I wonder if they would be more or less likely to cut me a set of bump keys if asked?
- celticninja 10y agoI bet this is a non-issue, I'm not sure how many burglaries are carried out by someone that picks the locks or uses bump keys but I'm pretty sure it is close to zero. In addition you probably don't want to be burgled in this manner as proving that you didn't leave the property unlocked would be difficult if there was no forced entry, which would make any insurance claim difficult for the property owner.
- sofaofthedamned 10y agoIf you're not aware of Timpsons they do key cutting, dry cleaning etc and these days mostly operate out of kiosks in supermarket car parks. It's a pretty trainable job to anybody, and the ideal job for somebody who can't get another one. I'm not sure about the Mr Happy thing though, because i've met plenty of grumpy staff there.
- isostatic 10y agoMr Grumpy is also a Mr Men character. As is Mr Muddle. And Mr Tall.
- sofaofthedamned 10y agoGood point. Didn't see Mr Surly Bastard Who Hates People By Default though :D
- rdl 10y agoI just learned which vendor I'll be avoiding. Key cutting is exactly the job I least want ex-convicts to do. It is low-skill, so anyone can do it, but high-risk (you are literally giving your keys to the person, asking them to convert them to a numeric code, easily retained, and produce copies...) (Obviously, I'd prefer an in-house locksmith or resettable locking system, but instead, I use a vendor I've known for 20+ years who uses PGP to authenticate orders.)
- anigbrowl 10y agoYou're either assuming the person cutting your keys also knows your address, or that burglars are in the habit of walking round with a bunch of keys and systematically trying them all in the front door looks of every house that looks like it might be worth stealing from. I'm not sure what is the point of mentioning that your physical security vendor uses PGP other than signaling how awesome your security practices are, but I guess since you're a vendor of security services you have a good reason to advertise that. No doubt you have your reasons for feeling prejudiced about ex-convicts, and as a security professional you can leverage rational paranoia into cash. However, it would be interesting to hear what sort of jobs you do want ex-convicts to do. It's easy to think of security reasons to disqualify people from any given job, not so easy to furnish people with legit alternative opportunities.
- rdl 10y agoI'd disqualify convicts (meaning felony, and in this case, particularly financial or access-related crimes) from physical security custodian roles (such as locksmithing), probably child care, probably financial stewardship. If it's a person with a drug crime history, probably nothing in the pharmacy chain of custody. Nothing in law enforcement. There are exceptions, and famously if someone's going to be providing quality information based on a "nefarious past" like Frank Abagnale, sure, but for a low-level clerk position, eliminating risk by barring 5% of the population from 5% of the jobs (not even particularly good ones) is a reasonable tradeoff. I'd trust an ex-con with finances of the cash register variety, but not unsupervised and unaccounted-for access to large amounts of cash. (It's not something you'd want to have to trust an $8-12/hr employee with in general, but in some cases it's unavoidable.) If someone had higher skills (say, an auto mechanic who was also convicted of a serious felony), the risk/reward of having that person working as an auto mechanic is probably a lot better than a low skill person taking a key cutter job vs. another form of retail job.
- pavement 10y agoDoes this use of personality differ from the qualitative "culture fit" concept? How so?
- hcs 10y ago> while you can train someone to do a job, you cannot train their personality The idea and context reminded me of the identical Mr. Prestos in The Stars My Destination: http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/content.asp?Bnum=2123 http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/content.asp?Bnum=2123
- whatshisface 10y ago>"We're not bothered by qualifications or CVs. We just look at the candidate and work out who they are, are they Mr Grumpy, Mr Slow, Mr Happy? If you consider that presenting a cheerful face for customers is part of the retail job description, then the Mr. Men-themed interview is essentially a work sample. "If they tick all the right boxes then we put them in the shop for half the day." Which is followed by a longer work sample, it appears.