3 ms·
Weight. Multirotors scale up poorly, since the mass of a bigger propeller makes the rapid speed changes required for control harder, or require more energy. Fi
by falcolas 10y ago
Weight. Multirotors scale up poorly, since the mass of a bigger propeller makes the rapid speed changes required for control harder, or require more energy.
Finding an engine / generator / capacitor combo which is light enough and powerful enough to work well with a multirotor is expensive.
Not to mention that such machines would be looked down on because of their use of fossil fuels.
- Retric 10y agoIt's more R&D costs than anything else. Batteries and electric motors are really easy to use and scale up. Micro/Nano Gas Turbine Engines easily surpass batteries over 1h, but are not cheap or easy to use. And, if you only need 10 minutes at a time for testing then batteries are significantly lower weight. EX: Wren's MW44i 46 oz (1320g) and produces almost 7 hp or ~5kw.
- falcolas 10y agoSure, batteries and motors scale up fairly linearly, but the physics don't. The energy required to change the rotational speed of a prop goes up exponentially as as the prop gets bigger. Above a certain size, it's simply more realistic to use variable pitch rotors that don't rely on speed changes to maintain stability, at which point the traditional helicopter design becomes more efficient.
- Retric 10y agoYou can add more blades which changes things somewhat, but the transition point is around ~10lb with 30m of flight time. So, any man sized flying machine is going to quickly cross that threshold.
- vadym909 10y agoCan they attach a helium balloon on top to reduce the left requirement?
- mcculley 10y agoMy question wasn't about changing the size of the propellers. I was wondering if one would get more range by substituting a battery pack for a gas tank and a tiny generator.
- falcolas 10y agoIt's still a weight problem. Gas engines and generators are heavy. You also have to add a capacitor system to handle spikes in demand for sudden maneuvers or stabilization jumps in electric demands. Increasing the weight increases the engine & prop size, which increases your energy needs. EDIT: From the few multirotors with a gas engine that I've seen, the right combination of weight - maneuverability sweet spot appears to be around the 750mm size - around 2 feet in diameter. They also tend to have good flight times, but still in the sub-one hour range. Again due to weight.
- mcculley 10y agoI get that one still needs a capacitor or battery. My intuition is that this is still better energy density in watt hours per pound than a battery. Maybe I'm just too used to old battery tech.