6 ms·
A black hole in a low mass X-ray binary star
- userbinator 10y agoThe title would be so much clearer with the addition of one more word: "star". On the other hand, it did make me click to find out what "binary" was about...
- dotancohen 10y agoAt least the star offers binaries. I hate it when I get to a system and I have to compile everything myself.
- m_mueller 10y agoProgrammer dad?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- SpaceManNabs 10y agoThe title is pretty clear for the target audience as it is using the standard jargon.
- lutusp 10y agoSpecialized language. Imagine editing today's technical stories to replace "automated driving" with "automated car driving". Remember that the original journal is read by astrophysicists, for whom a low-mass X-ray binary is perhaps more detail than they would need in a title.
- xioxox 10y agoIn an LMXB the companion object is a neutron star or black hole. This isn't necessarily what people would call a star, so it may be more confusing to call it a binary star.
- sctb 10y agoThanks, I think we can afford to add this to the submission title.
- xenophonf 10y agoLook! The actual scientific data and analysis! https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/3052451/The https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/3052451/The
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> There are many neutron stars in clusters, but black holes that form in these dense stellar environments are expected either to sink down to the center of the cluster or else to be gravitationally ejected from the cluster after they are formed. Why would this be the case? Unless you're extremely close to it, a black hole is just a mass, like any other stellar object.
- relieferator 10y agoThese globular clusters have always seemed peculiar to me. One would surmise that such a structure would result in a massive black hole without the rotational effects of say a galaxy.
- xioxox 10y agoSpiral galaxies tend to have regular rotation, but elliptical galaxies are much more like a globular cluster, although globular clusters aren't thought to contain dark matter. It's just a lot of stars going round in random orbits. They would have to lose angular momentum in order to collapse into the centre. They can get stripped, however, by tidal gravitational effects.
- antognini 10y agoTo provide a little bit of context, it is known that globular clusters should produce a lot of black holes, but it has long been believed that they should retain very few, if any of these black holes. One reason for this is that black holes should receive a kick upon their formation. The gravitational potential of a globular cluster is weak enough that this would generally be enough to kick the black hole out of the cluster. For those that remain in the cluster, the black holes would be much more massive than the rest of the stars in the cluster. Globular clusters undergo a phenomenon called mass segregation, where the most massive stars settle to the center of the cluster and lighter stars occupy the outer regions. So over time the black holes would sink to the center of the cluster where they would interact and form binaries with each other. These binary-binary interactions would, over time, kick single black holes out of the cluster. Since these interactions happen on timescales that are much shorter than the lifetime of the cluster, the received wisdom about twenty years ago was that globular clusters should have only a couple of black holes left, if any at all. In 2007, Thomas Maccarone (who is an author on this paper) discovered a black hole in a globular cluster in another galaxy. It wasn't until 2012 that any were discovered in a globular cluster around the Milky Way. Now that computers have gotten fast enough that it has started to become possible to simulate the dynamics of globular clusters, theorists have found that globular clusters retain a much higher fraction of black holes than they originally thought. The reason for this seems to be that the distribution in black hole masses leads the black hole population to remain better mixed with ordinary stars than was originally thought.
- dave_sullivan 10y agoYes, it's unlikely and pretty tin-foil-hat, but wouldn't it be nuts if it turned out to be a manufactured black hole? http://accelerating.org/articles/transcensionhypothesis.html http://accelerating.org/articles/transcensionhypothesis.html Intelligences could be expected to slowly accrete the mass of their parent star, rather than lifting or collapsing that mass and then inefficiently recreating fusion within the black hole (if the laws of physics even allow the latter, which they may not). In other words, you might absorb your star in a passive and gravitationally-driven process that would look a lot like a low mass X-ray binary (LMXRB) system to external observers, but in which the black hole companion begins as a planet mass black hole on the order of 1000 times less massive than the star companion, which should be a main-sequence star, likely with a spectral class G, like our Sun. Approximately 100 LMXRBs have been discovered in our galaxy to date, and about 13 of these have been found in the globular clusters, areas at the rim of our galaxy that may not harbor intelligence. They have also been found in many distant galaxies, again often in globular clusters. Few have involved G class stars, and none have yet been discovered with the very high, 1,000:1 mass ratio the hypothesis appears to predict. This may simply be a problem of detection. XRBs emit X-rays only when they are "eating" their companion sun, a transient phenomenon. Chandra, our best X-ray observatory, may also not have the sensitivity or persistence needed to detect very high mass ratio LMXRBs, or those that absorb their star's matter very infrequently or in very small doses. More research and theory is needed in this area.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoMacroscopic black holes seem like a good source of energy mid-term. But if you consider the very long term (tens of billions of years and beyond), this seems like a waste of matter. You're sending lots of precious baryonic stuff literally down the cosmic drain. Microscopic black holes seem more efficient. They are one of the very few ways to achieve total mass conversion (complete conversion of mass into energy).
- Tloewald 10y agoThis was, iirc, the energy source used in Arthur C. Clarke's Earthlight et al.
- rusanu 10y ago> such as would be produced by a black hole of about one solar mass How do such low mass black holes form?