5 ms·
It would be interesting (although I expect impossible) to figure out how many of those thousands were compromised by the NSA vs those compromised by people who
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
It would be interesting (although I expect impossible) to figure out how many of those thousands were compromised by the NSA vs those compromised by people who got the tools through the leak. It was nice that Microsoft had already fixed a bunch of them (almost like they were told ahead of time they were coming).
It is also interesting to read the outrage about the tools and the presentations on how to use them. If you have ever read the user's manual for a cluster bomb which no doubt tells you in detail how to maximize the number of people it will kill, you get a sense of how destructive and outrageous war can be. Why should cyber war be any different? And how is it any different to use a zero day to compromise a system than it is to use an architectural feature of a building to bring it down on top of its occupants (other than the obvious loss of life). Exploiting defects in the deployed system to maximize the effectiveness of a munition, not a new thing at all. Just the reality of warfare.
We're pretty clearly already in a form of warfare and it is having visible effects on things like infrastructure and elections. So how do we make the battles visible to the common folks? How do convince Mom & Dad to patch their router so that they don't inadvertently aid the 'badguys' in their quest for dominance on the digital battlefield?
Definitely feels like Phase III of the Internet has begun to me.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dmix 10y ago> Definitely feels like Phase III of the Internet has begun to me. I knew it wouldn't be that semantic web babble nonsense. I really hope it is the realization that infosec is important and we become closer to real engineers that factor in risk. My only fear is that it results in more useless regulatory oversight with marginal ROI. The recent controls put on zero day sales are a good example. They will do nothing to prevent the proliferation of malware and only punish honest companies helping to secure systems with practical attacks. It's like how the city I live in (Toronto) just enacted another round of rent control to deal with a lack of affordable housing. Rent control makes people happy by seeming to address the problem but ultimately historically has always resulted in less development of affordable housing by disincentivizing investment rather than helping developers build more buildings cheaper, by reducing red tape. This is what we need to do with security research. Stop villianizing researching exploits and sending innocent kids to jail and start paying them good money for their (often profitless) energy expenditure.
- thomastjeffery 10y ago> Why should cyber war be any different? Because we aren't talking about bombs. We are talking about security. We are concerned about "nuclear proliferation". Why aren't we concerned about the proliferation of these tools? It takes material to make nuclear weapons (obviously nuclear weapons are much more concerning, that isn't my point), but it only takes instructions to create and use security exploits. In this scenario, threats only have power for everyone who knows about them, and that is inherently dangerous. We should put all of our focus into getting rid of security exploits, not creating them.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWe are talking about both because they are the one and the same. I was talking about aggression against an enemy. Bombs, sanctions, cyber war fare. All in service to making the 'other guy' pay the price. In the context of cyber warfare getting rid of your own security exploits and creating them for stuff the 'other guy' uses. But that gets right to the essence of how this is different. The NSA sought to use a superior knowledge of exploits available in the software their enemies used against the enemy, even tho the same tools can be used on their friends. That is no different than picking up the weapon of an enemy soldier and using it against his own squad mates. Or having the enemy pick up your weapon and use it against your squad mates. Computers and networks are now (and arguably always have been) weapons of war. Just as cars and the people walking into markets wearing vests full of semtex are. And that is a sad truth because it means becoming a casualty can happen anywhere without warning. And that seems to be what Phase III will be about.
- i336_ 10y ago> It was nice that Microsoft had already fixed a bunch of them (almost like they were told ahead of time they were coming). Hmmmm. I wondered for a minute, then remembered that the leak was dropped, encrypted, onto torrent sites. So there's your "it's out there". And you have a file size. From there, well, Microsoft is yuuuuge, so it's entirely feasible that some nice person with connections to the leak in question could probably drop "well this and that was in it." From there it's not too much of a stretch to imagine a response team quietly forming to prioritize fixing everything "just in case". It's entirely possible Microsoft ended up fixing more things than have been disclosed here - I vaguely recall the core leak involved hundreds of GBs of stuff, but that only a part of the data/code actually escaped. If that's true that's almost funny.