5 ms·
Can You Swim Faster in Water or Corn Syrup?
- yanowitz 16y agoThis is science at its humorous best.
- S_A_P 16y agoI think mythbusters did the same thing with similar results. Im surprised they didnt do(or if they did, it wasnt mentioned) the difference in long distances. Maybe it doesnt make much difference for a lap, but what about the 100m?
- klous 16y agoYep, Mythbusters covered this. http://dsc.discovery.com/videos/mythbusters-swimming-syrup/ http://dsc.discovery.com/videos/mythbusters-swimming-syrup/
- watty 16y agoI think the turn would be considerably slower due to the extra friction in the somersault. When swimming straight, there is a "narrow frontal profile" and little form drag but that isn't true when spinning in the water. I wouldn't have guessed the results of this experiment so my slower turn theory is probably wrong as well...
- jerf 16y agoNote this article does predate the Mythbusters episode (and the study probably precipitated it). The Mythbusters anecdotally reported that while you could go roughly as fast in high-viscosity fluid it was much harder; IIRC Jamie couldn't even finish his highest-viscosity run, or at least made very heavy weather of it. (I for one would accept anecdotal reports on the matter, but if you're in an excessively science-uber-alles mood YMMV.)
- aliston 16y agoRight -- this was my initial reaction. You can generate more thrust in a higher viscosity fluid, which will "cancel out" the increased friction, but it also takes more energy to generate the increased thrust, so you'd tire out more quickly.
- bryanh 16y agoThis may sound absurd, but I wonder if this has ever been seriously tried as a training platform for competitive swimmers.
- mcav 16y agoI'd hate to practice swimming in corn syrup, if only due to the risk of inhaling mouthfuls of corn syrup, which I imagine would be more difficult to get rid of than a mouthful of seawater.
- electromagnetic 16y agoIIRC mythbusters used a medal winning swimmer and he couldn't perform. His body was attuned to swimming in water and he was messing up on his strokes (from what it looked like, he was taking longer to do a stroke in the more viscous liquids but he was going further with each stroke).
- michaelcampbell 16y agoDunno; I suspect I sink faster in water than I would inevitably sink in Karo... does that count?
- hkuo 16y agoThis is pretty interesting, but perhaps the new question would be at what point does the thickness of a liquid slow down a swimmer. For example, there's no way a person could swim equally fast through water vs mud. Perhaps the thickness of the syrup was not a significant enough difference to prove this.
- obsaysditto 16y agoyou can read the study here http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/fulltext/109667863/PDFSTART http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/fulltext/10966786... [pdf]
- ImFatYoureFat 16y agoI only skimmed the article so they might have covered this, but I would think that this comparison would, at least in theory, hold true for any two substances. Pressure is pressure. No liquid is going to react differently to pressure applied by your head and shoulders than it does to pressure applied by your arms and legs. In other words: swimming is essentially pushing against something with your head while you push against something else with your arms and legs. The pressure and force received from these two actions should stay comparably constant in any PURE substance. So maybe you would swim at a different speed in mud, if there were rocks in it.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoI don't think so. I think that at the extreme (say, the consistency of peanut butter), the amount of force you expend simply in inserting and extracting your arms (that is, not in the direction that propels you forward) becomes excessive.
- sliverstorm 16y agoOr, to put it in terms of a simple thought experiment- can you 'coast' or 'glide' in water? can you do the same in molasses? How about caramel?
- SamReidHughes 16y ago
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoI swim faster in honey. Don't ask how I know.
- bradhe 16y agoAccording to the MythBusters, no. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hs4Q5jZSJbA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hs4Q5jZSJbA
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- noonespecial 16y agoTo quote my favorite philosopher: Yes, Pinky, but who would want to?!
- nkurz 16y agoThis title is misleading, as the article makes no mention of 'corn syrup'. Instead, they thickened with guar gum to achieve "liquid twice as thick as water". I'm not sure what standard they are using for 'thickness', but corn syrup has a viscosity thousands of times more than water. The article points out that "below a certain threshold of speed and size, viscous drag becomes the dominant force". I'd strongly guess that humans swimming in corn syrup is below this point. Thus despite the summary article, I'd answer that one can swim faster in water than corn syrup.