4 ms·
For all the criticism he is getting, this would never have happened without him. Taxi companies are too strong, and the US needed someone like him to break barr
by ars 10y ago
For all the criticism he is getting, this would never have happened without him. Taxi companies are too strong, and the US needed someone like him to break barriers.
Lyft would never have existed without Uber. Now that Uber broke through the path (and is getting destroyed for it) the way is open for lots of other companies.
It happens all the time that the company that invents or creates something new, does not actually reap the rewards because the cost of creating it was so high they die in the process - but leave the way open for other companies.
- whyenot 10y ago> this would never have happened without him How can you be so sure of this? The person who came up with the concept behind Uber was not Kalanick, it was Garrett Camp. http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-travis-kalanick-bio-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-travis-kalanick-bio-2014...
- austenallred 10y agoThe hard part of Uber wasn't the idea
- atom-morgan 10y agoI don't think he means the idea wouldn't have happened without him. It's his ability to disrupt an industry tightly coupled with government.
- Fricken 10y agoKalanick is a Napoleonesque figure, a great conqueror who doesn't know when to pull back on the reigns, because he knows nothing else. Our memories are short, we're skewering him for being exactly the kind of animal that not to long ago most everyone was rooting for.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- astronautjones 10y agolol
- sctb 10y agoNot here, please.
- whyenot 10y agoSo essentially he's another Brian Chesky, or Anne Wojcicki who was willing to break the rules. This is not a characteristic unique to Kalanick and I don't see why something like Uber wouldn't have come along eventually without him.
- gesman 10y agoThis is a good perspective
- specialist 10y agoThe idea was in the air. Someone was going to it big. Even my buddy and I prototyped a crappy ride hailing app. When I scouted potential competitors, I found about a dozen. Uber's innovation was financial (fleecing investors), not technical.
- omarchowdhury 10y agoSeriously? Show me a ride hailing UX similar to Uber's at the time Uber launched...
- late2part 10y agoI don't think Uber's UX has ever been great.
- omarchowdhury 10y agoThat's alright, and that's subjective. But they certainly are facilitating a large volume of rides daily, in multiple cities, with tens of thousands of drivers and millions of riders. There UX is working well, but anyway the evolution of the ride sharing market isn't going to be in UX. Right now the market problem seems to be sustainability for Uber, drivers, and riders, since Uber and Lyft are losing cash. But who knows? Do the riders and the drivers really need Uber or Lyft?
- NelsonMinar 10y agoYour optimism is refreshing. The only way Uber makes sense is if they get a monopoly. Uber has been trying to make sure no other company can be profitable by subsidizing rides to unsustainably low prices, in the hope they are the last company standing.
- yawaworht12 10y agoAll the companies subsidize rides, including Lyft and Didi. No company would willingly do it if the others didn't do it as well, except maybe to increase market liquidity as the market maker. Why single out Uber when all the companies in this space are doing the exact same?
- NelsonMinar 10y agoBecause Uber is the market leader, with the most investment, and with the largest subsidies. Given your short posting history's unusual interest in Uber stories you probably know about that already.
- yawaworht12 10y agoLargest subsidies by volume or per ride? From what I've seen based on leaked financials, Lyft is outspending Uber by more than 2x in terms of subsidy dollars per ride [0]. Subsidies do not scale, and Uber is subsidizing less per ride than its competitors so it's surprising to me that it receives the bulk of the criticism when it's actually far the most thrifty of the ridesharing companies. If anyone should be criticized for buying their growth, it should be Lyft, not Uber. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13772168 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13772168
- tedmiston 10y ago> Lyft would never have existed without Uber. Now that Uber broke through the path (and is getting destroyed for it) the way is open for lots of other companies. Lyft rolled out in many cities before Uber. It certainly can / did exist without Uber's aggressive approach in several cities.
- dajohnson89 10y agoBut the business model was proven by Uber.
- tedmiston 10y agoNot really disagreeing with you because I don't think the business model has been proven yet. Neither company is profitable and both are still powered by fat stacks of venture capital. How the unit economics will pan out once that wears off isn't clear to me yet. It's also not that black and white as the Lyft team built Zimride (2007) prior to starting Lyft before Uber existed (2009). Even with that Uber focused on the high end market at the start while Lyft focused on the budget market.
- dajohnson89 10y agoWhile profit is one measure of success, another is whether your company has become a household name across much of the world.
- ktta 10y agoThat's something that interests me about CEOs who constantly face criticism. It was always CEOs like Kalanick who bring difficult but much needed change because they are brave (yes, I said it) enough to make some decisions. It's always easy to point out the things they did and criticize them, but it is harder to realize the work that they put in and the choices they make to keep their company (and most of the time, the industry they're in prosper). If he would've played by all the rules, Uber would've had to put up a Goodbye page on their homepage a while ago. Taxi industry would've tried to decimate it, and what ever would've happened, wouldn't be good for the transportation ecosystem as a whole. Self driving taxis are even being talked about because of Uber. I think Uber moved the arrival of self driving taxis from the concept to the street a decade earlier (although I have to say it might've taken longer if Levandowski was never at Uber; lets wait for the outcome of the lawsuit) Makes me think of Steve Jobs in the same way. Steve Jobs was (and still is in parts of the internet) intensely hated for his contributions. But he made a change in the computing industry which made computers (electronics in general) much more beautiful and a pleasure to use. Bringing about that kind of change is very difficult in my opinion, and we need brazen people like Jobs and Kalanick. They are sometimes immoral with their choices, but people tend to forget the world we live in often is too.