13 ms·
This discussion has reminded me that I intended to make a donation to the Guardian, since I read it every day and use an adblocker. The link for a one-off cont
by Symbiote 10y ago
This discussion has reminded me that I intended to make a donation to the Guardian, since I read it every day and use an adblocker.
The link for a one-off contribution is here: https://contribute.theguardian.com/ https://contribute.theguardian.com/
Or for a subscription, here: https://subscribe.theguardian.com/ https://subscribe.theguardian.com/
I tried the weekly paper edition for a while, but although it was posted on-time at the printers (in Britain or Austria), the Danish postal system usually delayed delivery to me by at least a week.
- danieldk 10y agoI tried the weekly paper edition for a while, but although it was posted on-time at the printers (in Britain or Austria), the Danish postal system usually delayed delivery to me by at least a week. Same here. I had a subscription and they'd usually arrive in Germany a couple of days too late. Luckily, Germany has Der Spiegel, which is also more than worthy supporting.
- RVuRnvbM2e 10y agoI've mentioned here before that I'm a Guardian Weekly paper edition subscriber, mostly because: * no tracking of the articles I choose to read, as in online news subscriptions * cross-section of articles that I wouldn't otherwise seek out (no filter-bubble) * very little advertising, none of it obtrusive It's also a great way to support real journalism, and learn about world news, not the parochial junk my local tabloids cover.
- asQuirreL 10y agoThere absolutely is a filter bubble, you just aren't the one doing the filtering. Not that I am philosophically opposed to the filtering, but rather the denial of its existence.
- Pica_soO 10y agoYes, but part of the newspaper experience of old was- that it breaks it. You paid for news, you usually wouldn't read- thus, you would at least skim it- thus such things could be relevant for everyone.
- popinman322 10y agoBut there is limited space in a physical newspaper. With finite space some choice has to be made as to what goes in and what doesn't. It's the same filtering that occurs with new media, except on a less personal scale and for different reasons.
- noway421 10y agoIt's not necessarily filtering when it's a aggregated. Hard to achieve uniform coverage though, correct, and not all the topics which have happened may be touched on (even in a one sentence or less)
- mathw 10y agoIt's the filtering which conforms to the wishes of the newspaper's editor, rather than the personal tracking profile of the individual reader. Hence why the various newspapers have known political positions - because their editors in the past put them there, and their readership now expect it.
- Ntrails 10y agoWhich is why you aimed to get in the position of reading a couple of news sources of different known biases. That's the old school counter to stuff being filtered
- freehunter 10y agoThe filter is which paper you choose to read. Reading The Guardian instead of Wall Street Journal is a filter.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- flurdy 10y agoI joined the Guardian some time ago as a member https://membership.theguardian.com/ https://membership.theguardian.com/ It's £5 a month, and whilst you do get some extras it is mostly just to support their journalism. You can pay more as partner and patron if you choose.
- Markoff 10y ago5 pounds per month for maybe 5-10 interesting articles is quite steep price compared to offering of Netflix for instance or BBC
- CalRobert 10y agoI like to think of it as buying a journalist a pint once a month. Also, when I had Netflix I found it to have a pretty terrible selection after I'd finished the two or three series I liked. Maybe that's just me though. Finally, at £145 a year, the BBC costs quite a bit more.
- dazc 10y ago"...at £145 a year, the BBC costs quite a bit more" Because anyone in the world can have free access
- cja 10y agoThe BBC website and radio is free, although ad-supported outside the UK. Only BBC television costs £145 a year.
- runeb 10y agoI've never seeds ads on BBC website or radio outside of the UK. Do you have more info on this?
- confounded 10y ago
- Markoff 10y agoi am in quite opposite situation, i used to like guardian and read it almost daily, until they started to beg for money, which turned me away, rather put it behind paywall than annoy me with begging, i don't find their content so exclusive that i would make donation to them, almost everything i read there i can find elsewhere
- flurdy 10y agoI think balancing the need to promote their various income methods and readers ability to tolerate those promotions is probably quite tricky, and a Venn diagram that may never intersect for some people. As a member I shouldn't see these but I am often not logged in so I still do which is annoying but unavoidable. But to be honest they are not that intrusive (mostly a paragraph at the bottom of an article) and 1 million times better than a paywall.
- tsiki 10y agoFor me the problem is that the number of sites I'd like to support to some extent. I'd love to donate to The Guardian, but I also frequent The Atlantic, BBC and many other sites. Actually supporting all these sites would take time and effort. I took a look at some chrome extensions which try to make this easier (namely tipsy) but they seem to have very few publishers signed up.
- danielpatrick 10y agoCheck out Brave (browser) with built in payments. Of course, this doesn't solve your problem of who's signed up, but Brave has a protocol for that scenario and they reach out to sites and offer them the money before returning it back to you.
- Baeocystin 10y agohttps://blendle.com/ https://blendle.com/ lets you pay a small amount per article, pulls from a variety of sources, no-questions-asked refund if you decide it wasn't worth it.
- joering2 10y agoOne day someone will come up with "paypal for articles online" - one button to comfortably and securely click to pay a few cents for an article you want to read. And of course get enough traction for it to get popular and be used by enough people to be sustainable. Until then, your problem will be mentioned on HN again and again...
- hashhar 10y agoThe better way would be for a service that installed an extension that tracks number of visits to distinct URLs on a site you tell the extension to track. At the end of the month, it uses a multiplier with the number of visits to either: 1. Autopay using PayPal or something or the other. 2. Open the payment links with the relevant fields autofilled.
- confounded 10y agoFor print magazines like The Atlantic, why not subscribe?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- clamprecht 10y agoYour comment gave me a small idea: What if adblockers kept (locally stored) stats on sites you visited (where ads were blocked) and how often, and provided a link to donate to them, if you were so inclined. In your case, it might say "You visit guardian 10 times per week. To donate, click here, or to subscribe, click here".
- ams6110 10y agoHonestly I don't think it would make a lot of difference. If I can read The Guardian for free, I'm not going to pay for it. Period. And I'm going to block the ads if I can. Note that I'm not saying I would never pay for access to content; I do, e.g. Netflix, and my town's local newspaper website (which has subscription-only access). Content is either worth paying for or it isn't. News orgnizations are in a tough spot here because there are so many news sources online it's not necessary to pay anyone. Anything newsworthy will be covered by a number of sources. The exceptions are local news, or highly technical/industry-specific news and analysis.
- noway421 10y agoAdblock actually acquired flattr to do exactly that.
- mathw 10y agoThat kind of thing has been speculated on repeatedly. Nobody's really built a system to do it that's ever caught on, but there seem to be an increasing number of attempts as the online advertising model continues to collapse. I think we'll see a mainstream effort at some point, and at the moment with rumours of an ad blocker being built into Chrome I think it may well come from Google. They already had a sort of prototype microtransaction system, it's not at all inconceivable that they could expand that programme. And with their own ad network already running, they might be able to make the transition very easy for people who're running Google ads - they are theoretically in the position that they could say okay, anybody visiting a Google Ads site using Chrome has the choice to see the adverts or pay a small fee, the browser will handle it smoothly for them and the payment will go through the existing AdSense arrangements with the site owner.
- Theodores 10y agoDo not feel guilt tripped into supporting the Guardian through donations! The Guardian turned their back on investigative journalism and went for columnists (that write columns concerning the agency news). This was decided years ago and last year there were more cuts to the budget, so even more agency news and flim-flam columnist nonsense. How can the Guardian compete when they are just churning out the same agency news stories as everyone else? Opinion pieces from a select few columnists worked fine in the days of print but it does not cut it online, people are not that bothered about what their columnists think. It is too late to turn the sinking ship around, the rest of the Scott Trust money will be thrown down the same hole and it will be game over, with cycles of cutbacks along the way. At the moment the chickens are coming home to roost, a friend in the Farringdon area recently took on two refugees from the Guardian, or maybe they were 'rats leaving the sinking ship'. In former times the Guardian would be the company you would want to work for, not flee because the writing is on the wall. Had they done it differently and actually done the independent reporting and investigative journalism instead of the agency news with columnists, then things could have been different. Nowadays the 'please donate' deal sounds a bit like 'give us some money then we will do this investigative journalism stuff, honest'. It is back to front and not as if they really believe honst money can be made from honest journalism - everything is someone else's fault.
- moonshinefe 10y agothey're still better than most big news organizations, but they're massively scewed toward a certain type of left wing echo chamber at this point. I loved reading the publication for years; the Snowden revelations were the high point. Now you'll get a massive dosage of anti-Sanders, anti-Corbyn hit pieces and similar along that political vein. You'll get a solid 70% of opinion articles pushing extreme feminism. If that's your cup of tea, all the power to you. But I don't think they're remotely impartial for a second anymore. Comments sections strategically opened or closed or moderated depending on the subject. Good on them for pulling out of Facebook I guess, but that definitely doesn't mean they're remotely objective at this point in my experience.
- hyperdunc 10y agoI agree. The Guardian's definitely gone down hill since Snowden. The news they do decide to report is pretty good, but their opinion pieces very often push socially regressive viewpoints.
- otalp 10y agoWhat usually happens with their opinion pieces is that most of them are pretty uncontroversial and bland. But the ones that are silly, extreme and/or hypocritical are the ones that make it to the top precisely because they are so. Take the example of their opinion pieces today. Article 1: French polls show populist fever is here to stay as globalisation makes voters pick new sides Article 2: How the opposition parties can still make a contest of this election Two reasonable articles, which are not amongst the 10 most viewed or clicked on. What is amongst the most viewed opinion pieces then? Article 1: Allow me to womansplain the problem with gendered language Article 2: Serena Williams’s pregnant victory reminds us how amazing women’s bodies are. Subititle: Are women the weaker sex? I don't think so. So the well-reasoned, sane articles are ignored, while the clickbait rubbish is well....clicked on, makes their 'most viewed' and is featured on their front page. A large part of the problem is people's tendencies to click on what you call "socially regressive" viewpoints. It's not like the people agree with them either, most of the comment section involves bashing the author. Some people are just looking for articles to get angry too.
- idlewords 10y agoThe Guardian published a terribly misleading series of stories about WhatsApp that it refuses to correct, despite being called out by most of the security industry. Keep your wallet in your pocket! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nqlE6UQjbUmgoMeJCePVcY5flqn8hAhmfIjeVE8PnEk/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nqlE6UQjbUmgoMeJCePVcY5f...
- andybak 10y agoI'm not defending the Guardian but if we boycotted publications for terrible tech reporting we'd probably be trying to get our world news from Ars Technica.
- idlewords 10y agoThe bad tech reporting is not the problem. Failure to retract or acknowledge mistakes, in a situation where the bad reporting might get people killed, is the problem.
- andybak 10y agoI had only skimmed the link when you replied. I now understand a bit better. I still don't think a boycott is useful in this case but continuing to publicize the issue is a valuable service.
- jgraham 10y agoThis is true and they ought to have retracted that. However if you apply the principle that you should boycott — at least least refuse to pay for — all publications that have ever published a misleading article on an important topic, then you will rapidly run out of options. If you want to take a moral position it should be based on an overall assessment of whether the world will be improved by a particular news source ceasing publication. Given the rumored state of the industry it's easy to imagine that in a few years we could be in a "post news" society, where reputable sources have not managed to keep the lights on and it's only the populist publications that are still in business. If the long term choice is between "support a publisher that once made a bad mistake in a technology story" and "The Daily Mail is the only source of news", well to me that's not a moral dilemma.
- zem 10y agoi'm a happy subscriber. i initially subscribed in gratitude for their making their entire crossword archive free, but i also appreciate the journalism they do and are happy to support them. interestingly, their lack of a paywall is a definite part of the value i feel i'm getting for my subscription; if i had to log in to read them i'd be a lot less likely to subscribe in the first place. i wish more sites followed an explicit "pay to help keep us free for everyone" model.
- kombucha2 10y agoIs there anyway to donate by BTC?