3 ms·
The ecosystem did not survive the Chicxulub event. "Ecosystem" is not shorthand for "life exists on Earth somewhere." An ecosystem is a particular state of the
by snowwrestler 10y ago
The ecosystem did not survive the Chicxulub event.
"Ecosystem" is not shorthand for "life exists on Earth somewhere." An ecosystem is a particular state of the dependencies between life forms.
The ecosystem that existed before the big asteroid strike was thoroughly and rapidly destroyed; a new ecosystem developed afterward. That's fine from a general "life finds a way" perspective, but it sucked for the sauropods, who went extinct.
EDIT: if you want a sense of why the indirect effects of anthropogenic climate change might be bad, look at the social unrest reacting to a couple million people migrating out of Syria. What do you think it's going to be like when about a billion people have to migrate inland due to sea level rise?
- Turing_Machine 10y agoBy your definition "the ecosystem" never "survives", because it has been in a state of constant change since life first developed on earth. "What do you think it's going to be like when about a billion people have to migrate inland due to sea level rise?" Considering that even the worst-case doom-crying scenarios issued by the IPCC predict a sea level increase of the order of 1 meter over the period of a century (i.e., ~1 cm per year), your (and Hollywood's) suggestion of rioting mobs fleeing the tsunami-like rising ocean is just not based in reality.
- snowwrestler 10y agoYes, ecosystems change constantly. An ecosystem is a state and the state changes as its components change. The fact that this is news to you is a clue that perhaps you know less about this subject than you think you do.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoNow you're just getting nasty, without any substantive response to my assertions. Hint: that means I won. You claimed that the ecosystem "didn't survive" the Chicxulub event because there were different organisms afterward. I pointed out that by that "definition" the ecosystem has never "survived", because it has been in a state of constant change since day one. Rather than responding to this, you just got nasty. I repeat: I win. Sorry.
- snowwrestler 10y agoI did respond: I said that you are correct that ecosystems are always changing. The question is, what do those changes mean for individual organisms? Because that's what you and I are. Changes to the climate and ecosystem are like changes to velocity. Whether the change is good or bad for people depends on the magnitude and direction. I do think that your focus on who is "winning" an imaginary Internet slap fight is detracting from your understanding.