3 ms·
Show this to any conservative who claims that global warming has nothing to do with human activity. I guess it's just a giant coincidence that we live in the ti
by EGreg 10y ago
Show this to any conservative who claims that global warming has nothing to do with human activity. I guess it's just a giant coincidence that we live in the time of the highest CO2 concentration in millions of years? And the highest disappearance of species?
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"Millions of years" is an eyeblink in the history of the earth. In fact, the CO2 level has been much higher than this level in the past (like, orders of magnitude higher). The earth was fine. And no, this isn't the era of the "highest disappearance of species". Not even close. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extinction_event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extinction_event
- Turing_Machine 10y agoModding stuff down doesn't actually change the facts, you know. CO2 levels: http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/Carboniferous_climate.html http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/Carboniferous_climate.html The sources are all linked from this site. Note that the CO2 level in the Cambrian was around 7,000 ppm, or about 17 times the level that this article is having hysterics about. Note that even during the Jurassic (when there were plenty of large land animals and a flourishing ecosystem) the level was about 3,000 ppm (7 times higher than the articles "threshold"). I repeat: the Earth was fine. 2. Extinction. The Wikipedia article I linked has a chart showing the proportion of species that have gone extinct during previous mass extinction. Note that the currently touted "mass extinction" is just a tiny blip.
- burke 10y ago* A CO2 level of 7kppm is not compatible with human flourishing. * Consensus is that the elevated CO2 levels of the Ordovician-Silurian and Jurassic-Cretaceous periods came on over tens or hundreds of thousands of years, not mere tens or hundreds. This gave life a chance to adapt. * Previous mass extinctions have been caused by things like complete ocean ecosystem collapse and massive asteroid impacts. Despite the fact that most of our current loss of biodiversity is mostly related to our homogenization of our surroundings, and not primarily climate change, it is certainly noteworthy and a little horrifying that it's reached a scale that comparison is meaningful. People talking about worrying about the Earth are just using synechdoche to refer to humanity as we know it. I wish everyone would quit painting a strawman over this. The Earth will obviously be fine; I don't think any reasonable person will argue this point. Humanity's future is somewhat less clear.
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"A CO2 level of 7kppm is not compatible with human flourishing." Yes, that's higher than we would like. It's also 17 times higher than the level the original article is freaking out about. "Consensus is that the elevated CO2 levels of the Ordovician-Silurian and Jurassic-Cretaceous periods came on over tens or hundreds of thousands of years," Link to this "consensus"? Thanks. "it is certainly noteworthy and a little horrifying that it's reached a scale that comparison is meaningful." Anything can be "compared". Did you look at the chart in the Wikipedia article? The current extinction rate isn't even a blip. "The Earth will obviously be fine; I don't think any reasonable person will argue this point." Really? So I've just been imagining all the people who are worried about turning the Earth into Venus? I mean, I agree that these people are unreasonable, but there certainly are a lot of them.
- EGreg 10y agoRegardless of all this, it's pretty clear what's causing this currently buildup of CO2. So why deny that man's activity is a major factor? As for "the earth will be fine": yes the planet will still be here, but will humans survive this? In the past, these changes were far more gradual, letting life adapt. As for "not even close", please show me a period when the rate of extinction was higher: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropocene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropocene
- akvadrako 10y ago1. Historical temperature changes were often quite abrupt and of greater magnitude than our current one. 2. Life is anti-fragile, so I think you're really underestimating humans and animals in general if you think a few degrees is something we can't handle.
- EGreg 10y agoI think you need to prove both these assertions. They are quite startling responses to "we have produced a quick rise to the most CO2 in millions of years" or "we have seriously damaged the biodiversity of large animals on this planet". It's as if someone said "we set the entire rainforest ablaze" and someone said "Relax! Nothing to worry about, this happened a few times naturally in the history of the Earth." Can you at least admit that humans are behind this rise in CO2? I mean, it's not like wind and solar energy generation is going to kill the economy. So why is this even debated so much?
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"The highest level in millions of years" is just rhetoric. The Earth is billions (with a b) years old.
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"As for "not even close", please show me a period when the rate of extinction was higher" I provided a link. Here, let me link directly to the graph: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Extinction_intensity.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Extinction_intensity.svg The so-called "Anthropocene" is at the extreme right of that chart. Note that the extinction rate has been colossally higher not just once, but many times in the past. Next.