3 ms·
"If I stand on an airplane and jump, do I land where I started, further back, or further forward, relative to the plane?" I would say, that most people would a
by hutzlibu 10y ago
"If I stand on an airplane and jump, do I land where I started, further back, or further forward, relative to the plane?"
I would say, that most people would answer correctly, that you would not land on the same place, but probably be blown away far backwards from air friction (even though they would just call it wind).
- roywiggins 10y agoI was imprecise: I'm not talking wing-walkers, I mean standing inside a plane, where wind is hopefully nonexistent
- hutzlibu 10y agoHm ... and then you expect people would say, they would land backwards? I think allmost everybody would get it right ...
- roywiggins 10y agoThis is based on muddled memories of a highschool physics class, but yes- I'd expect a lot of people to get it wrong, based on the sheer number of my classmates who persistently got it wrong. My teacher subscribed to a slightly nuts teaching philosophy which involved polling the class repeatedly, so I had a pretty good sense of how hard people found the ideas. Example: literally the other reply to my comment. The notion of an "impeller" to continue uniform motion is Aristotelian, and it seems to coincide with a lot of people's intuition: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14175605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14175605
- kwhitefoot 10y ago> The notion of an "impeller" to continue uniform motion is Aristotelian, and it seems to coincide with a lot of people's intuition: It also coincides with the kinds of experiment that people using Aristotelian physics are in a position to perform. See my comment about Carlo Rovelli's paper.