4 ms·
That is absolutely ludicrous. Monopolies are terrible for everyone except the owners of the monopolies. I've never heard anyone argue for monopolies before.
by smt88 10y ago
That is absolutely ludicrous. Monopolies are terrible for everyone except the owners of the monopolies. I've never heard anyone argue for monopolies before.
- themoonbus 10y agoEven in the game Monopoly, the whole point is to show how bad Monopolies are!
- joshuamorton 10y agoBeing large does not imply being a monopoly.
- smt88 10y agoYou're attacking a straw man. Someone said we need to stop breaking up companies, implying that breaking up companies (even monopolies) is always bad. I'm not saying large companies are all monopolies. I'm saying that all monopolies are bad.
- joshuamorton 10y ago> I'm saying that all monopolies are bad. Including regulated, natural monopolies? (I'm speaking of utilities mainly). Sure they're not great, but I can't think of a better alternative.
- smt88 10y agoYes, those are bad. Something can be bad without having a better alternative (wars can be examples). Also, there increasingly are alternatives, like home solar panels.
- joshuamorton 10y agoTrue, but wars don't generally provide necessary services. That is, most people would like to avoid wars. Most people would prefer to have utilities.
- andars 10y agoI have. By and large, I agree with you, but there are some arguments to be made in favor of allowing monopolies. I find the story of Bell Labs (mentioned in the article) especially striking: a frankly unreasonable number of innovations and ideas were developed there. The creation and continued existence of Bell Labs as a dominant force would likely have been impossible without Ma Bell's monopoly. Peter Thiel also makes a case for monopolies in Zero to One (do not interpret as an endorsement).
- fiatjaf 10y agoMonopolies are the creation of government, they are facilitated, enabled, done by governments. When you give the government the power and the legitimacy to break up companies the government will do that at its own discretion, to serve the interests of some other company, or some other greater power. Also, what is a monopoly? Is Google a monopoly? Google provides an invaluable service for free, if monopoly means higher prices (as every textbook economics teach) for the consumer, I think you should think again about Google.