5 ms·
With conservative Supreme Court justices loudly and proudly rejecting non-American sources of legal standards, I wonder how European perspectives came to domina
by pmoriarty 10y ago
With conservative Supreme Court justices loudly and proudly rejecting non-American sources of legal standards, I wonder how European perspectives came to dominate the US legal system on copyright issues but are ignored on human rights, labor law, and the environment?
- ghaff 10y agoThis wasn't about legal precedent though, so very little if anything to do with SCOTUS. This was about aligning worldwide copyright under the Berne Convention. I'm not familiar with the detailed history but it's pretty easy to imagine that aligning on a longer term would be much easier than on a shorter one. After all, even in the US, on the one side you have plenty of interests in favor of longer terms even if there are somewhat abstract constitutional principles that favor a shorter term.
- toyg 10y agoIt's just a play: one side says they need to align to the other, so they pass law to match the other's limits... and raise them a bit. The other side notices and lobbies for alignment, which again will go a little bit further. Rinse and repeat. Deflecting criticism by claiming another party forced your hand is one of the oldest tricks in the book, but it still works extremely well. See also: EU directives, which are requested and agreed upon by all EU governments, just to be immediately turned into "tyrannical rules from Bruxelles" the minute they have to be applied.
- tradersam 10y agoIt's called picking a choosing what's convenient and makes/saves the most money.
- neffy 10y agoKind of. It's really an instance of market failure. In particular, it's an instance of the failure of market based systems, which is intrinsic, to be able to set prices when there isn't any scarcity. Markets can't really solve that problem. Unfortunately our present legal/economic system decides to solve it by creating scarcity.
- krapp 10y ago>I wonder how European perspectives came to dominate the US legal system on copyright issues but are ignored on human rights, labor law, and the environment? Even the left in the US would be considered right-wing in much of the rest of the world. It's not surprising that the dominant perspectives in these cases tend to be whatever most favors corporate interests, or opposes state regulation or traditionally "leftist" influences, such as labor unions or environmentalism. In most situations, the quickest way to get Americans to reject an idea on principle is to tell them that it's the way things are done in Europe.