6 ms·
I've spent a bunch of years teaching college students and suspect that part of the problem is simple: 95% of people are fine, but that last 5% can occupy a lot
by jseliger 10y ago
I've spent a bunch of years teaching college students and suspect that part of the problem is simple: 95% of people are fine, but that last 5% can occupy a lot of time and mental energy. So there's a temptation to become somewhat armored against that last 5%, which impacts one's interactions with the vast majority of people, who are normal and reasonable.
A lot of public-facing professions seem to have this problem, including emergency medicine doctors, cops, retail workers, and public school teachers. Because that bottom 5% is so noisy and time-consuming, a kind of misanthropy can set in, as one begins to think the bottom represents the whole, even if intellectually one knows it does not.
EDIT: I wrote more about related issues here: https://jakeseliger.com/2014/12/22/how-do-you-know-when-youre-being-insensitive-how-do-you-know-when-youre-funny https://jakeseliger.com/2014/12/22/how-do-you-know-when-your...
- gist 10y agoI have a similar experience with customers in various businesses that I have run. I have arbitrarily put the number at 10% but thinking about it a bit it may actually be at roughly half that (which is your number). An odd corollary (to my point) is that I have noticed that a customer that gives you 10 orders of $1000 seems like a better customer than one that gives you a $10,000 order, all else equal. The increased amount of interactions creates a closer bond at least with people that you deal with personally.
- jseliger 10y agoI have arbitrarily put the number at 10% but thinking about it a bit it may actually be at roughly half that (which is your number). Yeah. I mean, I haven't done a specific study and suspect one would be impossible, but I think it's under 10% and maybe even as low as 2%. But there seems to be something about the human mind that makes one negative interaction stand out more than 10 positive or normal interactions. So there's a kind of crowding out effect going on. To take one recent example, a lot of people have seen crazy social justice warrior stuff in the news, like the Middlebury College thing: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/03/middlebury-free-speech-violence/518667/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/03/middleb... or the Halloween costumes at Yale: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/08/us/yale-lecturer-resigns-after-email-on-halloween-costumes.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/08/us/yale-lecturer-resigns-.... This stuff is in fact outrageous, but, again, it's salient because it's unusual and because it's unusual one sees it in the news (and it does represent a real problem: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/09/the-coddling-of-the-american-mind/399356/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/09/the-cod...). People will ask me about whether I see this kind of stuff. I do, a little. The vast majority of college students, however, seem to want what college students have always wanted: to learn something; to get by; to get a job when they're done; to get laid; to learn something about themselves and the societies they live in; to make friends; to individuate from their families. To be sure, this is an incomplete list. Most, if they've thought about free-speech issues at all, vaguely support it. But a minority of well-organized and angry activists can make a lot more noise and news than the silent majority! I think similar issues play out in many fields. One angry, unreasonable, or irrational customer or client drowns out a lot of generically happy or satisfied ones: https://sivers.org/real https://sivers.org/real.
- gist 10y ago> But a minority of well-organized and angry activists can make a lot more noise and news than the silent majority! Oh man you have hit on a point that I am always complaining about. Pretty much as a result of social media's ability to blow thing entirely out of proportion. It's like everyone gets to vote on everything but it's not about the most votes but noise.
- zzzeek 10y agoSame thing in open source. 90% of my users read all the documentation and have no issue; it's the 10% who don't, and in particular don't know the difference between a "bug report" and a "mailing list question", who drive me nuts with their out of context, incomplete examples "it didn't work!" etc. These are the people who take up all my time.
- cookiecaper 10y agoJust want to say that I've used SQLAlchemy for years and really enjoy it. Thanks for all your work. For what it's worth, I do notice and pay attention when I see your posts and comments around the web (HN, Twitter, SO, and elsewhere). I'm sure that some of the asinine questions you've deigned to answer on SO or IRC have helped me before. :)
- Merad 10y agoWhat infuriates me is how much our society coddles and encourages that 5%. I used to work in customer support (call centers), and I couldn't tell you how many times I saw the following scenario play out: * Customer calls in angry about a legitimate problem they're having, but their anger is 2-3 orders of magnitude larger than the actual severity of the problem. * Customer attacks and berates the CSR, often to the point of tears, before demanding a supervisor. * Supervisor takes over the call, apologizes profusely for the "incompetent" employee, showers the customer with account credits and so on, and maybe (but often not) fixes the actual problem I'm not necessarily blaming the supervisor. If they pretended to have a backbone and the customer managed to escalate beyond them, then they'd be the one thrown under the bus while their manager verbally fellates the customer. It's very clear at basically all levels: the employee is 100% expendable, while any risk of the losing the customer's business is unacceptable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- otterley 10y agoWhat if the front-line CSR were empowered to solve the problem in the first place? Then no one would have to be "thrown under the bus."
- ceejayoz 10y agoThey often are, and would if they weren't wasting so much time being screamed at.
- inetknght 10y agoYou mean spend engineering resources to help employees? That's not profitable! /s
- deadbunny 10y ago"solve the problems" varies wildly from call to call, one could be that they haven't paid their bill and got cut off (but it's your fault obviously), it could be a physical fault with something that requires a return or engineer site visit, or any one of a million things. 99% of the time the person answering the call is there as a buffer, cheap fodder infront of the more expensive people who can do things. You either have a very expensive resource manning the phones and working inefficiently with long wait times or you have the meat shield filtering for you. I've been on both sides of this (meat shield and technical fixer) it's driven by about 30 layers of management so it's always a mess, the alternative is the Google/Valve model where there is zero support. (Yes i know support is good on paid Google products. It's not on the free ones)
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoExcept that some of your examples are different-cops and doctors have much, much more authority and power than grocery store cashiers.
- kbenson 10y agoThat makes the consequences of them developing that view worse, but doesn't necessarily mean there's any difference in why or how it develops.
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoBecause it's unaccountable power.
- cookiecaper 10y agoYes, people naturally develop pre-emptive defense mechanisms to lower the impact of the ornery members of the public. This kicks off a self-reinforcing downward spiral where people with innocuous intent are misclassified and treated tersely, that party responds by iterating to a less polite/more direct posture the next time, which reinforces the original party's assumptions, which eventually degrade into general hostility, which loops back around to inform the other party that he needs to be even less polite to get what he wants the next time... However, it is probably the case that those lower 5% actually are so potentially damaging that imposing strict preventative policies to inhibit them is legitimately worthwhile, despite the negative impact on everyone else. Airport security is a potentially good example. Yes, there are many ways to bypass it. Yes, it is very annoying. Yes, it creates other liabilities that are arguably more exploitable in the absolute sense. But the bottom rung of civilization is not sophisticated. They are looking for the path of least resistance, and putting some basic barriers in the way may well put disruptive/negative behaviors outside of their reach. Most people who are smart enough to bypass airport security would not see the incentive in doing so. From the policy/standard perspective, that's the barrier that has to be established; the cost has to be sufficient to exclude people who would be doing it out of insanity or other generalized anti-social malice. It'd be interesting to see some discussion of methods to limit human "interaction fatigue" in the context of the modern service professional, and how we can simultaneously implement policies and protocols to protect ourselves from the insane, unstable, and truly incompetent.
- lpcrealmadrid 10y agoThis seems very reminiscent of two things: i) The rule of "The Most Intolerant Wins", coined by gadfly Nassim Taleb > The minority rule will show us how it all it takes is a small number of intolerant virtuous people with skin in the game, in the form of courage, for society to function properly. Also works in the inverse. ii) Mishandled Bags Rate vs. Bag Complaints Levied Against Airlines On "Why do more passengers complain about United than Southwest even when the service is the same?" > So why does United generate a higher rate of complaints than Southwest? I think it has to do with basic training and empowerment of frontline workers. When your bag doesn’t show up, your immediate recourse is not calling the FAA; it is speaking with an airline employee. If that employee can show a little empathy and try to help, no one will be rushing to call the Feds. Said another way, well designed recovery processes matter and that is true independent of niches the firm targets or how it prices. If you look at the dataset, Frontier actually has one of the lowest mishandled bag rates of the bunch, but the highest complaint rate. That sucks. --- https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dictatorship-of-the-small-minority-3f1f83ce4e15 https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dict... https://operationsroom.wordpress.com/2014/02/12/why-do-more-passengers-complain-about-united-than-southwest-even-when-the-service-is-the-same/ https://operationsroom.wordpress.com/2014/02/12/why-do-more-...
- kbutler 10y agoFrontier charges you for every bag checked, more for a carry on, and even more for each subsequent bag. https://www.flyfrontier.com/travel-information/baggage/ https://www.flyfrontier.com/travel-information/baggage/ If you're paying specifically for the service, and it is mishandled, you're more likely to complain.
- arkitaip 10y agoHere's an anecdote from my time working in an outdoors store. It's a fairly busy Saturday and the owner and I are busy helping customers and maning the checkout. In comes this angry looking guy with his daughter and immediately throws a pair of pants on the counter. He's so furious that he can't even explain what his problem is, just shouts something about the product being garbage. As he starts walking towards the exit - he has been in the store for less than 30 seconds - the owner picks up the pants from the counter and casually remarks that he couldn't have had bought the pants in our store as we've never carried that brand, that he must have bought the pants at a competitor nearby. Angry "customer" suddenly bursts into laughter, takes the pants from the counter and leaves the store without an apology or explanation, having spent maybe less than a minute in the store. I am sure that there are lessons to be learnt here, but working in retail can expose you to all kinds of sudden bullshit with no closure or deeper meaning to be had. Shit just happens and you have to shrug it off. But the negative experiences do add up and they come to shape you in some way. That's why I believe that entrepreneurs should work in retail. You get to understand the nature of business under challenging circumstances and learn how to (not) handle difficult customers.
- deepGem 10y agoI do second your recommendation. Even going on a sales call exposes you to highly stressful scenarios under which you cannot buckle but you cannot explode either. This skill helps you in all walks of life, managing a team and even managing your family. It could also go the other way for some people, as it happens in Seinfeld's 'Serenity now' episode
- klenwell 10y ago> I am sure that there are lessons to be learnt here, but working in retail can expose you to all kinds of sudden bullshit with no closure or deeper meaning to be had. Shit just happens and you have to shrug it off. But the negative experiences do add up and they come to shape you in some way. You also have to factor in the vagaries of human beings dealing with human beings. I guess you can say I paid my dues working in customer service (actually, "Guest Relations") at Disneyland for a stint in the late 90's. A couple episodes stand out: 1) Middle-aged father, clearly angry, storms into City Hall one weekday morning around Spring Break and says, "I'm ready to blow this damn place up." I happen to be in an especially good mood that morning so I just laugh and say, "Well, sir, you can't do that but maybe I can help solve your problem." He vents a bit, calms down. Turns out it some silly misunderstanding (I don't remember exactly, but something on the order of nobody warned him that Pirates of the Caribbean was going to be closed for refurbishment that day.) I apologize, give him a couple freebies we keep just for this occasion, and peace is preserved in the happiest place on earth. It was an otherwise unremarkable encounter, one among thousands fitting the pattern. Still, I guess I remember it but I do see a lesson to be learnt. I often think how easily it could have gone a different direction. If I'm in not so great a mood, or someone else is in my place that morning, or even if it's a couple years later post-9/11, oh the possibilities... 2) "Gypsies." Not the most politic phrase but that's what we called them and working the closing shift, you came to recognize them as a distinct category of obnoxious professional. People, families, who make a living off of scamming businesses. Here's one of the more infamous cases: http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/1993-10-06/news/9310060151_1_disney-property-disney-hotel-normile http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/1993-10-06/news/93100601... Every once in a while, when confronted by one of this class, if I was particularly grumpy or bored and things weren't too hectic, I might play Columbo and, after patiently and sympathetically listening to their tale of woe in all its sloppy details and taking notes on a notepad of the pertinent facts, point out the obvious plot holes and call them on their bullshit. If management had ever caught wind of one of these incidents, I probably would have been written up. They preferred to just pay the negligible cost-of-doing-business tax and keep things humming. I don't disagree with that approach. So I can sympathize with airline workers perhaps to a slightly greater degree perhaps than most. What caught my ear in the case of United CEO's first response to the passenger being dragged off the plane was not so much the tone-deaf off-note of an out-of-touch executive impervious to the miseries of the schmucks who are his customers but rather the echo of a decent boss who understands the kind of shit his employees have to put up with and is trying to stick up for them. I agree that his response was a disaster. But I suspect those who act like this was an obvious blunder and Munoz should have just accepted blame profusely and unconditionally for his staff's incompetence and promised the obligatory additional training to avoid issues like this in the future may be underestimating the importance of staff morale, in both the soft and hard (as in dollars and profits) sense, for the airline industry.
- tlogan 10y agoThis is so 100% correct. From my experience (simple SaaS) it is like this: 1) There is about 5% to 8% of customers who might be very hostile at very beginning of interaction 2) However, 60% to 80% of these people can be calm down with a few nice words. Put yourself in their shoes - it might be something else completely unrelated to your product or service made them angry. 3) If the above does not help, we politely close conversation and fire the customer so that we can focus on other customers. Easy for us. The problem is that it is much much harder do "fire customer" if you are a flight attended, if you are teacher, cop, etc. For example, I just had a parent-teacher conference and my son's teacher was crying because the parent before me was one of "unreasonable ones". Next time, I bet the teacher will just call the police so he does not need to talk with that parent any more. So this is a conundrum... 3% of pathological customers will make us all suffer.