3 ms·
A large institution I'm aware of that installed thousands of these lights in indoor and outdoor public spaces during the recession. The hook, which was a ROI wr
by Spooky23 10y ago
A large institution I'm aware of that installed thousands of these lights in indoor and outdoor public spaces during the recession. The hook, which was a ROI written by the lighting companies and fed to the facility people indicated that the lights would save some ridiculous amount of money, factoring in fewer bulbs, fewer service calls, etc. The reality is that total cost is only marginally better.
The problems are twofold -- the lights don't last as long as advertised, particularly in enclosed fixtures. Warranty claims are difficult, and they cost 7-12x the legacy bulb. In reality, they are spending more than they did with legacy bulbs because they need to dispatch people when they (frequently) break vs. do scheduled maintenance.
The other issue is that new bulb tech is harder to buy thanks to the carnival marketplace. Legacy bulbs involved a janitor looking up a part number written on the fixture. Exceptions were limited -- exhibit space needed a fancier bulb. The new stuff has different color temps, intensities, etc that nobody understands and many people disagree about.
I'm skeptical about cost savings in these programs. If there are cost savings, my guess is that the savings is stemming from the "managed service" model that the vendors push (i.e. Contractors making $20/hr, vs a $45/hr city worker) and less from the electric bill.