3 ms·
Chile was never third world. At the turn of the 19th century they had one of the largest navies in the world, and along with Argentina were two of the most pros
by wahern 10y ago
Chile was never third world. At the turn of the 19th century they had one of the largest navies in the world, and along with Argentina were two of the most prosperous and civil societies. For various reasons, by the mid-1900s the Chilean economy fell far behind the rest of the world. But their political culture was still strong. It's possible to be poor but still have a society largely structured like a rich one.
The author's thesis appears to be that the big success stories of the past half century have been countries that never saw much aid. The author overlooks one possibility: that these countries, whilst poor, had always had a strong political culture, and it was just a matter of time before they were able to get back on a strong economic footing.
Whereas the countries that receive the most foreign aid typically have had no strong political culture, at least not in the modern era. Remove the aid and you're likely to see millions suffer even more into the indefinite future. Scholars will debate forever about the origins of political culture. But perhaps it's just random and spontaneous, and it'll happen with or without aid. Until then, you can either watch people suffer (like in Haiti) or try to minimize some of the worst suffering.
All his other points are well known in the foreign aid community, as well as in the political science and economics fields. It's the dominant narrative today. It's just that everybody thinks _they're_ bucking the trend whilst everybody else "doesn't get it". Everybody has read Freakonomics at this point, and everybody is familiar with unintended consequences.
Anyhow, from a realpolitik perspective foreign aid was never about helping the poor. It was always about soft power. With the end of the Cold War people forgot about that, but it still serves the same function. And in this age of terrorism that function is perhaps even more important today than it was 40 years ago.
- valuearb 10y agoI think you mean "rule of law" when you say political culture. People will pull themselves by their bootstraps amazingly well if they know they can keep what they make.