5 ms·
That's a general problem with efficiency regulations: they don't model the full benefits of the (product with) higher energy use, nor do they give the users a c
by SilasX 10y ago
That's a general problem with efficiency regulations: they don't model the full benefits of the (product with) higher energy use, nor do they give the users a chance to pay for the purported externalities if they they value them so highly.
In that respect, they commit the planner's fallacy of acting on costs they can't observe.
(If your model says that the externalities are infinitely bad and inherently unaffordable you're probably very wrong.)
- xapata 10y agoThe solution would be a simple carbon tax rather than efficiency thresholds. I don't understand why the supposed "small government" folks dislike a carbon tax when it'd avoid so much bureaucracy.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoBecause a) it's a tax, and b) it would impact gasoline prices, and thus their freedom to drive everywhere. I.e. the very reasons it should be introduced.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoIn other words, it's about controlling other people's behaviour - which is the very basis of one of the arguments against it.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt's about pricing back in what is now externality. It's about making things fair. Which is the basis of living in a society. For max freedom, people should move to Somalia.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoWhat makes you think you can achieve maximal freedom without a functioning Government to enforce the rule of law? I think you're erecting and attacking a strawman, there.
- aurelianito 10y agoOne of the main attributes of the state is its ability to tax things. You cannot have one without the other. If the bad thing is the tax just for being a tax, then it is legitimate to compare against a no-state situation.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoAlso, taxes don't have to be compulsory. Rand addresses several alternatives to compulsory taxation for funding the State in one of her essays. The three main problems with carbon taxes are: * they're compulsory (and therefore theft) * they're guaranteed to be the wrong amount, as attempts to calculate externalities are subject to the socialist calculation problem * they are usually motivated by a desire to control people's behaviour (see the point about driving above)
- rfrey 10y ago"a functioning Government to enforce the rule of law?" i.e. controlling other people's behavior. Also, a tax is a law, so enforcing a tax is enforcing the rule of law. It's just a law that some people don't like.
- duncan_bayne 10y ago> i.e. controlling other people's behavior. Well, yes. Everything from murder to moral, legal police action can be so described. > It's just a law that some people don't like. ... because it's legalised theft. Libertarians (well, minarchist-Libertarians) support Government, and the rule of law. That doesn't mean we support _all_ Governments, or _all_ laws, as moral.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> because it's legalised theft Yes, and public schools are legalized brainwashing, and hospitals are legalized slaughterhouses (after all, that's where most people die). You can draw many comparisons like these if you ignore the details, but sometimes those details are exactly what's important.
- batguano 10y agoThe point about tuning the LED spectral emission for broader, warmer, or generally more aesthetically pleasing illumination is a good one. A carbon tax had nothing to do with that.