4 ms·
How about hire smart people, trust them to do the job, and then leave them alone!
by sjg007 10y ago
How about hire smart people, trust them to do the job, and then leave them alone!
- leggomylibro 10y agoThat would mean fewer HR jobs to go around, presumably.
- zzalpha 10y agoBecause no one can possibly get better at their jobs? Everyone just wants to hide away and quietly keep doing what they were originally hired for? And feedback has no value in helping people improve? Seriously, I'm baffled by this attitude... yes, I love to hire smart people. And the smartest people? They realize they can learn stuff from other smart people, and that sometimes, those smart people are even their... gasp... managers. Worse, the really smart, driven people may even want to stretch or achieve career goals and don't want to just do the same thing forever! OMG! Frankly, it's the folks who don't understand this that worry me the most. I've worked with my fair share of talent that believes they're the absolute best at everything they do, no one can possibly teach them anything new, and we should all just leave them alone to achieve greatness in solitude. They're a nightmare.
- quanticle 10y agoEveryone just wants to hide away and quietly keep doing what they were originally hired for? And feedback has no value in helping people improve? The problem is that you're assuming that there's a level of honest and integrity in HR reviews that just isn't there. HR reviews are fundamentally deciding about who should be promoted and who should be fired. Giving feedback as to how you can get better at your job is, at best, a secondary concern.
- sjg007 10y agoYou're missing the trust piece.
- flyinglizard 10y agoThat's precisely what I, being considered a star programmer, thought when I was 20. I knew better than anyone, so I wanted to be left alone. I looked down on methods, tools and organizational systems. Over a decade now and being in charge of 20+ smart people now, I understand how without effective personnel and project management, employees are irrelevant. Now, if you get a smart person that's responsible, driven and methodical enough so they can be effective and contribute without being managed, you just make them a manager for other people so they can make them effective. Skilled managers are a force multiplier. Unfortunately technical ("smart") skills are often contradictory to management and people skills, so that person is very much a unicorn (but when you find them, it can transform a dysfunctional organization to a performer). Between having a mediocre managed brilliant group, or a brilliantly managed mediocre group, I know where I'd put my money.
- sjg007 10y agoThis is about performance reviews and not about managers. Although you can argue effective management does not require managers. What you missed is autonomy. That's the key. Alignment (join the company), autonomy (trust), effectiveness (facilitate).
- flyinglizard 10y agoEffective management requires managers, it just doesn't say how many managers (just one at the top, or many levels). But someone has to set the tone. Trust is not enough. People need to be guided, synchronized and harmonized. It doesn't happen well in a flat, distributed system. A good employee receives autonomy, a great employee often receives control over other employees. But autonomy is not independence; it still requires a guiding hand, which is management.
- sjg007 10y agoAgain, I didn't say anything about managers.
- Spooky23 10y ago