8 ms·
Goldman Sachs Introduces Real-Time Employee Performance Reviews
- wsgeek 10y agoVery Bridgewater-eque ...and the employees "wanted" this? I doubt it. Seriously, did I misinterpret this? Not trying to be a troll.
- zzalpha 10y agoWhy wouldn't they? Seriously, I'm curious. If you're going to get 360 feedback, wouldn't you prefer to have it in a timely fashion instead of getting blindsided monthly, quarterly, or yearly? Or is the very concept of a 360 where you have issues?
- delias_ 10y agoAn immediate review system, which in this case sounds like just a forum for immediate complaints/reprimands, sounds terrible because given a negative situation the feedback hasn't had any cool-down time. It sounds very toxic, tactless, lacking introspection, and easily decorated with anger. We need to be focusing on the context around failures and what the factors were in a situation where a person's actions contributed to a failure. Why did what they were doing make sense to them at the time? This isn't captured in a 360 review cycle, nor this particular one. I just don't think it fits the tech paradigm of blamelessness/blame-aware at all. I am struggling to find any reasonable point in this process. Performance reviews in general are more formality than anything in my opinion. At the end of the day I can gauge how my impact is respected across a company on a mgmt/executive level by the money that lands in my bank account. The review cycle from mgmt really does not address any other intricacies.
- zzalpha 10y ago> An immediate review system, which in this case sounds like just a forum for immediate complaints/reprimands, sounds terrible because given a negative situation the feedback hasn't had any cool-down time. It sounds very toxic, tactless, lacking introspection, and easily decorated with anger. You've described basically any feedback mechanism at all. Cooldown time or not, a 360 feedback system only works in a culture that enables it. The feedback will be toxic if the culture is toxic. The timeliness of the feedback isn't likely to change that. > Performance reviews in general are more formality than anything in my opinion. Ah, and now we come right to it. You don't actually believe in a system of employee evaluation. That's your opinion. You're free to have it, but it implies that feedback is not a path to skill or career development, and I deeply and fundamentally disagree with that premise. > At the end of the day I can gauge how my impact is respected across a company on a mgmt/executive level by the money that lands in my bank account. If you think that's all that reviews are about--gauging impact, ascribing blame, or simply analyzing failures--you're already missing the point. Feedback is about many things: * Identifying and lauding successes. * Feedback to address performance concerns. * Feedback for skill improvement. * Feedback for career development. If you don't think you have anything to learn from your peers or your managers that can help you in these areas, well... we'll have to agree to disagree.
- zerg2k 10y agoI believe you are missing the problems that such environment creates. Back-stabbing, and simply not well thought out events will start to take place. This is not about the "good" things 360 has in favor, it's about the bad ones that such environment can unleash!
- delias_ 10y agoGood feedback from peers I think is critical, but the 360 review process most companies have does not provide introspective and effective feedback. Your bullet points can be addressed in productive 1-on-1s with your direct report manager and regular check ins between your team and project management to critically discuss recent milestones and what emergent work has been created from them. I agree with your points, but I feel the formal corporate review process does not sufficiently facilitate them and instead succumb to the pitfalls highlighted where they only focus on the negatives. It is not that I only think reviews are for that, it's that I think those things are a bad end state where formal reviews converge. The 360 review does not contribute meaningfully toward creating a learning organization. It is not the right mechanism for feedback and reparative methodologies. We're not building technology. We are building organizations who are building technology. If we are not focusing on the way in which people are doing the work that they are doing as a feature of the actual work, then we are not building a learning organization. An effort to create continuous feedback is a better gesture than a yearly review, but this article/video is a fluff piece. If the feedback you're getting in a 360 review is in any way new information, then you're not exhibiting the elements that make a good team in the first place. If you're attempting to aggrandize feedback behind formality and process, even in the name of immediacy, I think it's counterintuitive. Feedback needs to be a native mechanism that is implicitly built into the way we are working -- not a sidebar conversation. That's what postmortems are for.
- sheepmullet 10y ago> but it implies that feedback is not a path to skill or career development, and I deeply and fundamentally disagree with that premise. Feedback is important. Negative formal feedback... not so much.
- ordinaryperson 10y agoImagine thinking you did a good job all year, only to hear in your review everyone hates your guts -- and you had no idea. If the critique is fair, timely feedback also gives you a chance to change instead of letting it build up until they hate you. Imagine your wife/husband told you they always hated your cooking. Why not tell me before instead of while we're divorcing? If you're guaranteed to get feedback, it's always better delivered in a timely fashion.
- losteric 10y agoThis seems like an over correction for bad management. A good yearly review should be a quick unsurprising formality because everyone was openly communicating the entire year. To stretch your analogy... if your spouse doesn't tell you they hate your cooking, that's the real problem: trust and communication. Asking them for feedback after every meal won't help resolve the real problem.
- ordinaryperson 10y agoYou're right, a good yearly review should be a boring summary of everything you already know. But often, it's not. A lot of colleagues and managers are too timid to provide timely feedback, they think they need a formal moment like an annual review to speak up. Do you believe every single employee and manager has the skillset you describe to be open, honest and trustworthy? If not, then having a system to help shepherd feedback isn't a bad idea.
- sheepmullet 10y ago> Imagine thinking you did a good job all year, only to hear in your review everyone hates your guts -- and you had no idea. Imagine you talk to your manager and coworkers regularly to get feedback but you don't put the negative feedback into a formal software system that encourages politics and backstabbing!
- zzalpha 10y agoWhy on earth do you believe a formal system would make backstabbing and politics worse? I'd argue it has the potential to make it better since it creates a papertrail and transparency. I'd rather that than Joe Angry Developer sneakily badmouthing me to my boss or my co-workers behind my back. Worst case it seems like a lateral move as far as politics goes.
- basseq 10y agoI'm unclear if this replaces in any way their existing (annual?) performance review process. Employees do request immediate feedback: it's a major "best practice" and a very common performance improvement area. Now, usually this takes the form of just talking to your direct reports when you see them do something good or bad. I haven't seen an institutionalized IT system that would do this, nor that those micro-interactions would somehow "add up" to a full performance appraisal. So this seems to add more friction to giving feedback: never a good thing. And refer also to the whole Amazon "Anytime Feedback" peer feedback tool that turned into political posturing and back-stabbing. http://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-employees-reportedly-slam-each-other-through-this-internal-review-tool-2015-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-employees-reportedly-s...
- slimsag 10y agoDoesn't sound like it. The video mentions their annual performance review process still being a 'big deal' and that it is still where raises and bonuses are determined.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zzalpha 10y agoMy guess is it supplements. Ultimately the person managing an employee's development still has to be involved in coaching and formal evaluation. 360s provide data points as well as an opportunity for ongoing improvement rather than saving it all for a once-a-year feedback loop.
- biocomputation 10y agoDon't see how something like this will be good for morale, but I suppose that's what the enormous bonuses are for.
- sgt101 10y agoYes! Because this has worked so well in politics and on the internet.
- danso 10y agoThe article makes it sound better than what immediately popped into my head, which was employee performance via metrics shown on a Chartbeat-like animated dashboard. Sadly, some media companies are indeed mesmerized by watching article performance via Chartbeat's real-time traffic charts.
- uncensored 10y agoWorst. Idea. Ever. Says I.
- uncensored 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_X_and_Theory_Y#Theory_X https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_X_and_Theory_Y#Theory_X back to the golden age of terrible ideas
- sctb 10y agoWould you please not post unsubstantively here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- uncensored 10y agoSubstansively? Tons of replies are not substansive at all but they pass thru your filter because they just more words in them. Sad!
- crispyambulance 10y agoCome on, it's yet another HR bullshit vehicle to suck away time and good-will. Any happy, healthy and productive working group with a manager and directs enjoys an environment where feedback is "realtime" and context sensitive. It has been this way since the dawn of modern workplaces. People got stuff done and companies flourished even without HR-driven company-wide "reviews". HR departments, unfortunately, aren't satisfied with the annual hoop-jumping exercise that everyone hates but finishes in haste to get it over with. The fashion now is to drag out this process over the whole year. Instead of you and your boss having to "prove" your worth once a year to HR, you now have to do it several times a year, tracked and nagged by a "realtime" system. Goldman Sachs isn't the only company doing this stuff, it's all over the place, sadly. For once, I would like to see large companies take a step back and reduce the burden of these stupid reviews, but it has only been getting worse and more annoying.
- alexanderh 10y agoYea I hate this stuff... No longer is it good enough to work hard, you have to work hard, and then campaign for recognition for it... It should be the job of good management to recognize and foster tallent... but unfortunately, you have to be a good worker and a good politician on your own behalf to get ahead in a lot of corporate environments nowdays.
- jdmichal 10y ago> No longer is it good enough to work hard, you have to work hard, and then campaign for recognition for it... I find it interesting that people seem to think that there was a time when this wasn't the case. I think it is potentially true in a small-group setting. And by that, I mean that magic number around 150 people where you can have a fully-connected network. The moment you cross that mark, the network can no longer maintain full connection. That is the very same point when signaling worth becomes important. And humans have had organizations larger than 150 people for a very long time. I've posted before about "meritocracy" being a fairy tale that technical workers need to stop telling themselves: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10978841#10980628 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10978841#10980628 EDIT: Sorry, was off on Dunbar's number, which is 150. Though I think the constraints required for a desired organization without signaling are a bit heavier -- you need to not only maintain the social network, but also the value of each person. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar's_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar's_number
- pasbesoin 10y ago"Dashboard" Danger! Danger! Danger, Will Robinson! Pardon my ingrained reaction to the Christmas tree metrics. When I was back in corporate land, real, ongoing feedback and a real conversation would have been useful. But, it all came down to the yearly ritual and basically fitting people into the slots (including pay increases / pre-defined budget) that were available. Maybe Goldman Sachs will come up with something else, but with respect to "real time" reviews, I can't help thinking of the old expression: "What have you done for me, lately?" On the other hand, to re-introduce the sarcasm, it couldn't happen to a nicer group of people.
- davidlee1435 10y agoI've never been through a performance review before (currently a college student), but I'm curious: what distinguishes a good conversation about your performance from a bad conversation? Do you receive a plan of action? Is it the way that the conversation is conducted?
- pasbesoin 10y agoThere are many things that could be said, I guess, but a good and concise summary would be, "Trust your gut reaction." If/When you get into such meetings, if you feel uncomfortable -- not that you have goals to meet, but with respect to the natures of the goals, measurements, and feedback, itself -- trust your reaction. In my corporate experience, all of this ultimately goes to serve Human Resources (HR). And, contrary to the impression some newer employees can have and that HR itself often fosters, HR DOES NOT serve the interest of the employee. They are there solely to staff and to protect the organization. Much of the performance review process serves to produce documentation they can subsequently use to justify whatever action they decide to take. Note that such actions may not actually correspond or respond to your real performance. Hopefully, you'll end up with a good manager that will help you grow and understand the system. But, that is your direct management. THAT is the critical decision. I had one manager who was like that. Things were good, until they early-retired him out. I basically consolidated the work of a 5 department team down to one person -- me -- as we continued to go through layoffs. Done in substantially less time and with substantially less errors, more flexibility, and a complete change-over, with much greater complexity and variability, in the underlying data. I received an award. And another time, that manager, before he was retired out, just showed up at my desk one day with an unsolicited 12% raise, because "I was doing the work." In the midst of a company-wide pay freeze. But when they were done with me, I received a very cold stare from our HR manager as I passed her in the hall one day, and the next I was out. Trust your gut. Not any "performance review" process. You need to respond to and manage the process, as it unfolds. But you trust your gut. P.S. Yes, I should have gotten out a lot sooner. I had basically become a "workaholic" to avoid a lousy home circumstance and personal life. Another lesson to learn and avoid.
- pcurve 10y agoI think it's fair that employees are given regular feedback throughout the year, instead of it be withheld until evaluation time and not have opportunities to correct. I think it's also fair that the feedback mechanism is bi-directional. However, what concerns me about this is, managers with lower-performing employees may get dinged harsher than managers with top performers. In large companies with many teams, this will require a bit of digging to uncover this factor. What is manager's recourse without looking like he or she is throwing his/her team members under the bus?
- dannyr 10y agoIt's like to Twitter but for Performance Reviews.
- throw2016 10y agoOne would think HR would be against something that introduces constant stress in the workforce rather than introduce it. It comes across as a company obsessed with getting the maximum possible output from their workforce like from a machine but quite not sure how to pull it off from human beings.
- cs702 10y agoThe obvious next step is to create a real-time market for employee performance reviews, allowing employees to bet on and against their and other employees' performance reviews and possibly even trade derivatives priced based on baskets of rising or falling performance reviews. There would be many benefits. For starters, having a liquid, efficient market for performance reviews in which employees are able to bet on each others' reviews with minimal frictional costs would unleash market forces that would keep the performance reviews accurate (right?). But the really big payoff would come down the road, when this market could be opened to external investors like the venerable firm that manages your Aunt Tilly's pension plan, generating new sources of trading revenues for Goldman. In all seriousness, I'm not sure real-time performance reviews are a good idea. They immediately bring to mind the societal nightmare of Black Mirror's "Nose Dive" episode: http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/24/13379204/black-mirror-season-3-episode-1-nosedive-recap http://www.theverge.com/2016/10/24/13379204/black-mirror-sea...
- AstralStorm 10y agoPeople cannot bet on what they don't know. This is how all markets are really inefficient.
- uncensored 10y agoHaven't they learned from history? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_X_and_Theory_Y#Theory_X https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_X_and_Theory_Y#Theory_X
- brianwillis 10y agoMy employer tried and failed using a similar system with Salesforce Work.com. It all seemed a bit pointless and forced to me. In the early days of using it while it was still a novelty, managers were giving feedback to people so that they could demonstrate to HR that they were being good little soldiers by using the tool, rather than because they wanted to praise good performance. This insincere praise was worse than no feedback at all. In the end, it never really went anywhere because it became another inbox to check, and we already have too many of those. A chicken-and-egg problem also presented itself, where people only checked the site when they got a notification saying they'd received feedback, which led to no-one visiting the site to give feedback.
- davidlee1435 10y agoIf you don't mind me asking, what did you guys fall back to, and were you guys satisfied with it?
- mythrwy 10y agoIt's a terrible idea. Please don't even think about building it. As another poster mentioned real time feedback between team members and leaders happens organically (if the people are any good). The HR annual or bi-annual review is a formalization and documentation step but I can't imagine usually leads to better performance.
- brianwillis 10y agoWe didn't replace it with anything. We still do formal performance reviews every six months.
- mnglkhn2 10y agoIt is a result of a test driven education system. Young people want feedback more often to feel secure in their actions.
- davidlee1435 10y agoI think (and maybe this is a flawed premise) that most folks desire genuine, helpful feedback (or perhaps more generally what other people think about them). However, it seems like folks have difficulty when being on the giving end of the feedback, which makes tools for real-time feedback a one-sided marketplace. I could hypothesize a few reasons (i.e, feedback taken the wrong way could damage interpersonal relationships, feedback is awkward to give to a colleague, feedback is based on a sliver of the full-picture of an employee's performance, etc.), but I'd like to know y'all's opinions on the matter. What seems to be a part of the problem is also how nebulous workplace interactions are when administrated by HR. It's awkward and unnatural to ask a close friend to "describe something that <other close friend> has done well." Most of the time when I give feedback about someone, it's a reaction to something that that person did that I observed. Having such an open-ended review in annual performance reviews seems to create a breeding ground for feedback that isn't helpful, and asking those questions constantly like Goldman and a lot of other companies are trying to do serves only to exacerbate the problem.
- anon263626 10y agoThey're crooks whom subvert democracy and exploit people and businesses with obsfucated trickery. Who cares? Next financial crisis brought closer because coworker competition in performance reviews means legitimized stealing even more money, faster.