3 ms·
When you come across a single credit card number (say, by finding someone's card on the ground), the response by most financial institutions is to invalidate th
by joshuamorton 10y ago
When you come across a single credit card number (say, by finding someone's card on the ground), the response by most financial institutions is to invalidate that card and mail them a new one. Why shouldn't the response be the same if you come across a stack of 100 credit cards?
- josh2600 10y agoBecause shutting down 100 credit cards has more reputation and monetary liability than shutting one down? You're basically saying "academics can derive your social security number using public information!" And wondering why they don't reissue all of the SSNs...
- joshuamorton 10y agoSo? When a website has its passwords stolen (even just the hashed, salted ones) the immediate step is to invalidate every password potentially compromised and force users to reset them. Doesn't matter how or why the passwords were lost, you start by mitigating the damage someone can do. Why isn't the response for when credit card information (which is very often more valuable) is stolen similar? >You're basically saying "academics can derive your social security number using public information!" No, I'm saying that if my name, social, DoB, mother's maiden name, and credit card number appear online in a csv file with 200 other people's personal information, I'd really appreciate it if my credit card company would take proactive steps to keep my accounts secure.
- platz 10y agoThe response to invalidate is a choice by the bank, not the person who finds the card. Also, that is a single number. It's suspicious/threatening for a non-trivial amount of cards when the presenter also makes demands.
- joshuamorton 10y agoHow is "someone has stolen your clients information and likely already sold it to nefarious actors, because otherwise it wouldn't be on the internet anywhere, so you should keep them safe by deactivating those accounts" threatening? I'd be annoyed if my bank didn't do something.
- platz 10y agoThat is a different point. You are changing the party being considered by re-framing it under yourself, a customer, instead of considering it from the point of view of the bank.
- joshuamorton 10y agoThat's ridiculous. If the bank is aware that my credentials are available online somewhere and are taking no action to protect me, they're being complicit in any harm that comes to be, because they have both the responsibility and ability to take action, and refuse to. They're being irresponsible and potentially harming their clients. So again, how is saying "You should take action to protect your customers' data" a threat? How can it be interpreted as a threat? What is threatening about it?