8 ms·
The NDA is not a valid contract because there is no consideration. For a contract to be valid each party has to gain something. This is why many contracts inc
by lisper 10y ago
The NDA is not a valid contract because there is no consideration. For a contract to be valid each party has to gain something. This is why many contracts include a token consideration of $1. This one didn't, so it's invalid.
- rpedela 10y agoAre you an IP lawyer?
- lisper 10y agoNo. But I can read.
- notyourwork 10y agoAre you a heart surgeon? No but I can read. I'll stick to advice from subject matter experts, not self appointed experts.
- lisper 10y agoAs you wish. My legal advice comes with a free double-your-money-back guarantee if not completely satisfied.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoThere's a helicopter crashed in a house. I don't need to be a pilot to know it's not supposed to do that.
- jdmichal 10y agoThis is actually pretty close to how I personally define a "professional": A professional is someone whose work can only be judged by other professionals of the same domain. Obvious failure modes are exempted. Anyone can tell you about a bad bridge after it has failed. But it would take a bridge engineer to tell you that before it fails. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8960822#8963307 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8960822#8963307
- peterwwillis 10y agoYour definition would include tradesmen and craftworkers, then, who are not strictly professionals. Anyone can work in wood long enough to say "That wooden bridge looks like it'll hold X people," and not have any way of conveying how they came to that conclusion, because they didn't learn via a means of studying a specific body of work that can be measured and accredited. Without this distinction, many professions would not exist. https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/The_architectural_profession https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/The_architectural_... Also, your definition includes itself as part of its own definition, which is a circular definition fallacy.
- jdmichal 10y ago> Your definition would include tradesmen and craftworkers, then, who are not strictly professionals. According to what definition? > Anyone can work in wood long enough to say "That wooden bridge looks like it'll hold X people,"... I severely doubt that, given the complexity of trussed bridge designs [0]. There's a lot more to it than how much weight a 4-by-4 can support. > ... and not have any way of conveying how they came to that conclusion... If you can't transfer knowledge in a way that other people can independently verify, you're working in magic. If such a transfer is possible, but simply not possible for a particular person because they lack the tools, then that's a professional failing. For some reason, this state seems acceptable to you when we're talking about physics and complex loads. But could you imagine a doctor describing the appendix as "that thing sticking out where the long thin squiggly bit meets the short thick squiggly bit"? > Also, your definition includes itself as part of its own definition, which is a circular definition fallacy. You can't just throw out "circular definition is fallacy" and dismiss the idea. That itself is a fallacy -- "argument from fallacy". [1] Yes, I use the word "professional" twice, but that's not necessarily a circular definition and especially not necessarily a fallacy. First, the two "professionals" are not the same person. The first mention of "professional" is an individual, while the second mention is a group. What I did is tie membership of a group to a conditional ability which is dependent on the group itself. However, I did cheat a little bit. Because what I did not define is the individual ability necessary to meet that conditional. Because, of course, that changes depending on what group of professionals we are discussing. For backup, let's look at a definition of malpractice [2]: > a dereliction of professional duty or a failure to exercise an ordinary degree of professional skill or learning by one (as a physician) rendering professional services which results in injury, loss, or damage In other words, malpractice is a professional doing something which such a professional should not do... Because the mere fact of a person being a professional implies that they should know better. It's this same logic that I am using: A professional is someone who acts in a professional capacity, and understands the practices of such profession, and thereby is capable of judging whether another person understands and acts in a professional capacity. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truss_bridge#Truss_types_used_in_bridges https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truss_bridge#Truss_types_used_... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy [2] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/malpractice https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/malpractice
- notyourwork 10y agoAnd the validity of an NDA is blatantly obvious to any person who can read?
- Twisell 10y agoLawyers tend not to tell they are on internet because of potential liability. Thus when you read IANAL odds are goods that the writer known about the subject but don't want to be liable in any way so he just protect itself. PS: and if you want an advice by a lawyer that accept liabilities for its counsel just pay for it, because that is the only way you get it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- devy 10y agoAre you saying NDA without putting a dollar value are unenforceable?
- bjt 10y agoConsideration doesn't have to be denominated in dollars.
- dublinben 10y agoConsideration can be as minimal as "your continued employment with this company." It does not have to be any sort of additional dollar amount.
- __jal 10y ago"We won't sue you", however, is not consideration.
- PeterisP 10y agoI wouldn't be so sure - for example, out of court settlements pretty much amount to "We'll pay you $x without admitting that we ever did something wrong, and you agree not to sue us over that thing that we totally did not do.", and these definitely are valid contracts.
- idbehold 10y agoNot suing in that case is the terms of the contract. The consideration is $x for party A and for party B it's not having to admit wrongdoing. Had the NDA in question given William $x to not disclose the security hole then he would certainly would be in breach of contract. But the NDA gave him nothing.
- fulldecent 10y agoWhen they were drafting the "contract", the concept of consideration was very interesting. I had considered that if I would receive cash for agreeing to not disclose then this would be blackmail which apparently is bad.
- beefhash 10y agoConsideration is a common law concept as far as I can tell. As someone unfamiliar with how it came to be: Why was consideration introduced? What's the rationale, the goal behind it?
- cmdrfred 10y agoI believe the idea is nobody would willingly sign a contract that does nothing to benefit themselves so they must have been mislead into the agreement thus it is invalid. Sort of a rational actor theory of law.
- idbehold 10y agoIsn't the benefit for William that he was provided some confidential information in addition to what he already knew?
- lisper 10y agoPossibly. But the contract doesn't say so. This is exactly why the consideration has to be explicit, so the judge adjudicating disputes doesn't have to guess about such things.
- jdmichal 10y agoTypically yes, access to the information is the proper consideration for agreeing not to further disclose the information. But as lisper says [0], that will also typically be spelled out in the contract. If a contract doesn't outline consideration, and the jurisdiction requires consideration, then the lawyer writing the contract was not very good at their job... [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14167805 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14167805
- fulldecent 10y agoBasically, per our phone call, my consideration was duress. As in "sign this or else..."
- rhizome 10y ago
- azhenley 10y agoWhat about NDAs for interviews? What am I gaining (a chance at getting a job doesn't seem like a gain)?
- lisper 10y ago> a chance at getting a job Yes, that is exactly right. > doesn't seem like a gain Why not? If you don't think that's a gain, why are you wasting your time doing the interview in the first place?
- pdelbarba 10y agoOTOH, I've heard that you can't be forced into an NDA with the consideration of only continued employment.
- lisper 10y agoConsideration is a necessary but not sufficient condition to have a valid contract. There are a lot of other requirements as well. This is why it is best to have a lawyer review any contract you sign, especially when the stakes are high.
- r00fus 10y agoThe government taxes you for stock options (which are opportunities to gain profits). A chance for employment (over an outright dismissal) is a recognizable gain. You are however, free to decline with the appropriate consequences.
- pmiller2 10y agoThis was my question: is this NDA even enforceable and why would the author have signed it?
- mcbits 10y agoMy reading is that he signed it because he was falsely made to believe he may have done something illegal and this would protect him from the FBI. I.e. he was coerced.
- fulldecent 10y agoYes.
- stordoff 10y agoI agree. There's plenty of "Tester agrees"/"Tester shall (not)", but the document provides nothing of value/benefit in return. Worth noting that just because it doesn't stand up as a contract doesn't necessarily mean a claim can't be made under breach of confidence (I doubt it would be applicable here, but just pointing out that contracts aren't the only form of legal protection provided to confidential information).
- lisper 10y ago> I doubt it would be applicable here Definitely not. The bank did not disclose the vulnerability to him, he discovered it on his own. He had absolutely no obligation to the bank.
- Spoom 10y agoAgreed, that was the first thing I thought when I looked through it. It's a totally one-sided contract, which is invalid for that reason.
- regulation_d 10y agoI definitely think you're correct. In the future you could probably save yourself the hassle of the "Are you a lawyer?" questions by dropping the phrase "almost certainly" right before "not a valid contract". Most attorneys I know are super reluctant to call a contract invalid without some sort of qualifying language. This contract might actually be egregious enough to warrant an unqualified declaration of invalidity, in which case you should go the other direction and overstate your case with conclusory statement and some word like "clearly" or "patently". "This contract is patently invalid!" and then explain why.
- lisper 10y agoDespite the fact that I'm not a lawyer, I happen to know quite a lot about contract law because I was once involved in a contract dispute. That provided quite a good education on this particular topic.
- regulation_d 10y agoWhat really made me laugh was "Are you an IP lawyer?" This isn't even an IP question!
- user5994461 10y agoYour statement is 100% incorrect. P.S. It might be of limited correctness, only in some states, in the USA. I'd suggest you don't talk people into signing perfectly valid contracts hoping for an unlikely loophole.
- jhall1468 10y agoCare to explain why he's wrong, or are we to assume your expertise, random internet person?
- user5994461 10y agoAssume the expertise. A whole semester of university dedicated to contract law: Consumer contracts and B2B contracts in the national law, then the specifics when dealing with a party in another European country and internationally. You'll see what a contract needs to be valid during these courses. There is simply nothing about both parties requiring to gain something.
- lisper 10y agoYou should demand your tuition money back. http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/consideration-every-contract-needs-33361.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/consideration-every-c...
- user5994461 10y agoToo bad, the best schools are free where I come from. A few ones actually pay you. The point stands. Your link doesn't infirm what I said.
- lisper 10y ago> Your link doesn't infirm what I said. LOL. Res ipsa loquitur.
- joshmn 10y agoCame here to say just this.