4 ms·
If you make a poor argument with emotionally loaded words (e.g. "primitive"), and then phrase it such that downvoting is a vindication of your argument, you are
by CalRobert 10y ago
If you make a poor argument with emotionally loaded words (e.g. "primitive"), and then phrase it such that downvoting is a vindication of your argument, you are not contributing to the discussion. You're just lazy.
- Chris2048 10y agoThe burden's on you to show it's a poor argument. I can just as easily state that it's a great argument. Also, I think it's clear that OP expects down-votes for "going against the gender narrative", rather than the incidental swipes at America; That said, it is baiting to provoke in this style, rather than stick to the point.
- DanBC 10y ago>> BUT statistically, far fewer women than men enjoy STEM. Women are less interested in STEM. This point has already been debunked in this thread, with links to data.
- Chris2048 10y agoCan you link to that post, to clarify that? Though the post I responded to didn't mention that - it just said "this is a poor argument" without reference to bad statistical claims or the other posts. Also, what is the standard for "debunked"? links/data by themselves don't mean anything without validity, and what you and I consider valid may differ.
- futun 10y agoTo start with a premise (in this case: 'men and women are exactly the same except for genitalia'), and to accept only that data which supports that premise is what is "lazy". This mode of thought is indeed "primitive" as it describes most of human understanding which predated science and the scientific method. This discussion must be about gender differences. And those differences must include desire, drive, taste and preference. To accept as a premise that 'there are no differences' is anti-scientific as it is not an observable phenomenon. This unsupported belief is based upon fringe theory held in a minority of countries -- including the US and (some parts of) northern Europe. Holding the belief in 100% gender-sameness up as a fundamentalist truth, and blasting all those who oppose it as "sexist" does not make this belief any more valid. Quite the opposite: It vividly illustrates its similarity to other primitive, pre-science (and mostly religious) belief systems. The onus is not upon me to present this argument in a palatable, non-offensive way. Science is not PC. The onus is upon you rather, to not be offended. Offense is offensive in a context of science.