4 ms·
Balance isn't the goal. Equal opportunity is the goal. If the imbalance is due to a lack of interest in a field by one gender or another that's perhaps regrett
by simonh 10y ago
Balance isn't the goal. Equal opportunity is the goal.
If the imbalance is due to a lack of interest in a field by one gender or another that's perhaps regrettable but not a moral issue. If the imbalance is due to obstacles or prejudices faced by one gender over another then would you agree that is a moral issue that is more important for society to rectify?
- pottersbasilisk 10y agoIts clear that certain people here want equal results probably because equal opportunity is much harder to track or destroys certain agendas.
- tptacek 10y agoRespectfully, why are you framing this as a question? You don't need anyone's permission to observe that prejudice is an important moral issue --- and the only people who would answer "no" to your question don't sincerely acknowledge moral imperatives in the first place.
- 67726e 10y agoConsidering you haven't proven any deliberate imbalance.
- simonh 10y agoThat's a perfectly fair question. I asked in order to try and find common ground, and in case the poster has some other reason for caring particularly about imbalance instead of opportunity, or in case the poster doesn't think that the imbalance is due to differences in opportunity as described in the original article. However I could have phrased it more clearly.
- nnfy 10y agoThe problem is the inane assumption, which is now taken as a fact (without rigorous substantiation) that any male heavy gender ratio is a result of bias by white men (not even necessarily the majority, mind you, we simply ignore fields where women are over represented). Not to mention the conflation of equality of opportunity with equality of achievement. In our society it has become a taboo to even consider that stratification by gender and/or race of achievement could possibly be related to group wide differences in behavior or ability. This is, ironically, causing immense bias in modern culture; but it seems bias is OK when its the en vogue kind.
- 67726e 10y agoWhere are the campaigns for female construction and sanitation worker parity? How about male nursing? HR? Nothing? Surely those fields would benefit from equal representation and male insight. Yet we have some kind of crusade against the tech industry. Oh well, I should just shut up since I'm a straight, white, male. I'm just oppressing you poor souls.
- swampangel 10y agoPrograms for women in trades: http://www.careersinconstruction.ca/en/why-construction/opportunities-women/organizations-help-women-get-started-construction-trades http://www.careersinconstruction.ca/en/why-construction/oppo... Programs/orgs for men in nursing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14165427 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14165427 Tech is not unique, but for some of us in the industry it seems logical to focus our attention here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- simonh 10y agoDid you read the article? If it were just an assumption and no effort had been put into investigating the reasons for it and if/how those reasons can be addressed you would be right. From the article: "A new study from Microsoft sheds some light...gender stereotypes, few female role models, peer pressure and a lack of encouragement from parents and teachers largely to blame." So no assumptions are being made, this has been researched. This discussion is even about some of that research and it turns out girls are being discouraged by factors that are completely addressable. > we simply ignore fields where women are over represented Nobody's ignoring anything. My wife is a registered nurse here in the UK and encouraging men to get into nursing is definitely a thing. It turns out that men who do go into nursing have a significantly higher chance of promotion, which you'd hope would encourage them to and is it's own issue. But please, go off on a 'whataboutist' tangent as though the legitimate answer to every uncomfortable problem in the world is 'whatabout' some other problem.
- 10y ago
- 67726e 10y agoEqual opportunity exists. You're asking for equal outcomes.
- simonh 10y agoThis article is literally about research that has identified inequalities in opportunity. Is expecting you to even know what we're talking about really too much to ask? But off you go and take a look. I'll sure you'll find something in the research you don't even seem aware exists, linked above, to complain about. At least we'll have something to discuss instead of just slinging mud around. Also, please, point out anywhere in my posts where I asked for equality of outcome? Which of my posts are you even talking about?