3 ms·
Couldn't there just be developed a bookmarklet for Wikipedia edits that takes a text selection, posts it to the user's personal blog, and then turns the selecti
by tokenadult 16y ago
Couldn't there just be developed a bookmarklet for Wikipedia edits that takes a text selection, posts it to the user's personal blog, and then turns the selection into a quote from the blog? What would be the difference?
Blogs wouldn't be the sources I would want to see more of in Wikipedia. Dead trees, because of their expense, still prompt more fact-checking and editing.
I'm an editor of an article that is before the Wikipedia Arbitration Committee just now. (I happened to wander by, as a newbie Wikipedian, just as the article went from failed mediation to arbitration.) There is enough making stuff up already on Wikipedia. The last thing it needs is more ease in using blog posts (generally very unreliable) as sources.
- derefr 16y agoI didn't mean to suggest that it would be a good thing :) That's the point—it's a parasitic corner-case of the rules, and should probably be patched up somehow.
- joeyh 16y agoWith the amusing result that Wikipedia will cite newspaper articles that cite information from blogs, rather than directly citing the blog. (Happened to me and my blog. And as a data point, out of some hundreds of newpaper etc articles about a blog post, the total number that seemed to involve any kind of value-added fact checking was 2.)
- mukyu 16y agoI have seen cases where news articles are written using the wikipedia article but not citing it and then the information in the original wikipedia article is citing using the news article that got the information from wikipedia in the first place.