3 ms·
A company isn't like a single group of people, really. It's more like a confederation of affiliated fiefdoms. Some companies are worse than others in this regar
by philwelch 16y ago
A company isn't like a single group of people, really. It's more like a confederation of affiliated fiefdoms. Some companies are worse than others in this regard (for instance, you can actually find pirated copies of Windows 7 by searching on Bing: http://www.bing.com/search?q=%2bpirate+windows+7&FORM=RCRE http://www.bing.com/search?q=%2bpirate+windows+7&FORM=RC...) but even Apple is somewhat affected.
In one office, one group of people working on Safari decided Readability was a good idea worthy of reimplementation. In another office, possibly another building, another group of people decided iAd would be a good idea. Any higher ups, including Steve, probably agreed with both assessments without thinking to put the two together, because they have far more important work to do than designing absurd conspiracies to "punk the web and gild the iPad".
- cobralibre 16y agoThis is certainly true of many companies and may well be true of Apple, too, though it doesn't really fit the prevailing narrative we have of Apple as a company precisely steered by an extremely hands-on executive team. Personally, I'm tickled by this silly and completely implausible variant of the "corporation as federation" idea: That the the executive team is focused on the iOS platform to such an extent that the desktop Safari team implemented Reader -- "annoying ads" marketing and all -- simply to see if they could get away with it.
- philwelch 16y agoWhy would it a matter of "if they could get away with it"? It's a genuinely good feature. What I am saying is that it's highly implausible that the executive team deliberately set out to advantage iAds by reimplementing Readability in the Mac version of Safari. (If Mobile Safari had Reader--where it would be even more useful--then some suspicion could be warranted.)
- cobralibre 16y agoBear in mind that you're responding to a bit of fanciful musing which was explicitly signaled by the phrase "I'm tickled by this silly and completely implausible... idea" -- the idea being that the Reader feature is a public thumbing of the nose towards the iAds initiative, made possible by upper management's ostensible neglect of Apple's desktop software.