3 ms·
Not to downplay climate change, I believe in it no matter what and I know it's one of the biggest catastrophes our planet has ever faced. But I see a predictio
by mrfusion 10y ago
Not to downplay climate change, I believe in it no matter what and I know it's one of the biggest catastrophes our planet has ever faced.
But I see a prediction of 32 cm rise by 2050 on Wikipedia (1)
It doesn't seem like the Florida coast is going anywhere overnight. Is there a chance we're panicking?
(1) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoThe article says- "The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration predicts sea levels will rise as much as three feet in Miami by 2060." 3 feet is 91 cm so there seem to be different estimates than the one you have, unless the sea will rise two feet from 2050-2060.
- xoa 10y agoTaking for granted for a moment that predictions are not conservative: This has been oft-repeated, but in many areas things go very bad long, long before the water is actually lapping at the front steps. It's very geology and geography dependent on exactly how and when localized effects start to kick in, but major categories include: - Worsening effects from storms. - More serious, frequent, and lasting flooding. - Destruction of subsurface fresh water (big, big problem in most of Florida, it's not on bedrock). - Increasing difficulty in all subsurface infrastructure systems. - Vegetation death due to above. Just for starters. These are all probabilistic scenarios but the curves absolutely do matter, they are what feeds into insurance, predicted maintenancerequirements, QoL assessments and so forth, which in turn has a major effect on property values. You should also remember the fact that property markets in particular have a predictive component as many people think longer term then they do elsewhere. Just because a problem is years down the line doesn't mean it won't start getting taken into account now, and that's particularly true with financing which matters since many property deals are heavily debt financed or leveraged. We're not even touching on politics here. So there's quite a significant number of potential areas for negative feedback loops to kick into effect and end the party real fast, with the rational actions of every individual actor precipitates a readjustment that's much more rapid then you might expect otherwise.
- stevenwoo 10y agoThe global warming related pages on wikipedia are one of the most contentious pages on wikipedia. http://www.livescience.com/51926-are-wikipedia-science-pages-trustworthy.html http://www.livescience.com/51926-are-wikipedia-science-pages... So in this case, wikipedia is not a good source unless one happened to edit it last, and investigates the source data.
- rjsw 10y agoWhat do you suggest that people in Florida should drink ? The underground springs will become contaminated with salt water fairly easily.
- cowpewter 10y agoExactly. The whole state sits on porous limestone, and we get all our drinking water from underground.
- Atheros 10y ago32 cm is more than enough to prevent an area from draining quickly after a storm. Sea level rise won't be what gets you directly, it'll be the fact that infrastructure, like storm drains, no longer function.
- jdmichal 10y agoAbsolutely. Even right now, low-elevation roads in coastal areas flood terribly when it rains. And if it's high tide, it can be hours before the water clears. The future is going to look like the article's story about Key Largo first. Flooded streets and other infrastructure for periods of days instead of hours. And that's definitely enough to drive educated buyers away. I would have loved to live in a different area than where I bought my house, but I couldn't argue with the advantages that come with being over 30' above sea level. Already I'm not required to purchase flood insurance, which is a large savings every year.
- michaelbuckbee 10y agoI think you have to look at it in the context of home ownership. There was a NYT article [1] about Norfolk and the relationship between flood insurance, climate change and housing values. I live in Virginia Beach, in what's officially not a flood zone, but Hurricane Matthew (which was pretty mild as things go) put our street 4 feet underwater and about a foot below our front door. If our neighborhood gets redesignated as a flood zone, we'll lose a big chunk of our house value immediately and may not be able to sell it. I'm definitely thinking that we need to move sooner rather than later as no matter if it's 32, 28, or 57 centimeters of sea level rise it's hard not to think we won't see more hurricanes, worse flooding, etc. 1 - https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/18/magazine/when-rising-seas-transform-risk-into-certainty.html?partner=socialflow&smid=tw-nytmag&smtyp=cur https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/18/magazine/when-rising-seas...
- WillPostForFood 10y agoLike most articles about Norfolk, it is incredibly disingenuous to focus on sea level rise, and not land subsidence, which is the primary cause of the flooding there.
- treebeard901 10y ago> the relationship between flood insurance, climate change and housing values This is a really interesting perspective on the problem. If one of these three variables change dramatically it will feed back into the others. The average person may not try to predict their future home value 5-10 years out or have enough scientific background to understand climate science but an insurance company covering the area will have to consider both. It will be increasingly difficult for people to deny climate science as large number of homes and business properties lose value while at the same time their insurance rates dramatically increase. EDIT: a word
- guelo 10y ago32cm is a foot. Many parts of Florida are a foot above sea level. The rule of thumb in the flat parts of Florida is that for each foot of sea level rise the shoreline moves inland 300 feet. One foot could be a mile inland on tidal rivers. Drainage and other water systems are already being affected at current levels.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>But I see a prediction of 32 cm rise by 2050 on Wikipedia... Is there a chance we're panicking? It's not about everyday sea levels. It's about what happens during storm surges.