8 ms·
s/Lynch/Herbert/ I remember as a teenager eagerly anticipating reading Dune. And was totally disappointed. There's nothing SF about it.
by BeetleB 10y ago
s/Lynch/Herbert/
I remember as a teenager eagerly anticipating reading Dune. And was totally disappointed. There's nothing SF about it.
- cafebabbe 10y agoMind reading, Personal shields, planetary nukes, FTL travel, cyborgs, history of AI war vs humans...
- metaphorm 10y agoall of those things are more like "space fantasy" than sci-fi.
- Keyframe 10y agoAny and all of these don't make an SF. It's debatable whether Dune is SF or Fantasy. Star Wars, for example, is an action fantasy with an SF theme (more or less). I've found a definition of what makes an SF recently and this is it: Science Fiction is speculative literature that generally explores the consequences of ideas which are roughly consistent with nature and scientific method, but are not facts of the author’s contemporary world. The stories often represent philosophical thought experiments presented in entertaining ways. Protagonists typically “think” rather than “shoot” their way out of problems, but the definition is flexible because there are no limits on an author’s imagination. At its core, SF is putting characters into far psychological extremes and thought experiments.
- cafebabbe 10y agoI'm not saying Dune is idiomatic Sci-fi ... but your definition fits almost perfectly Dune :) > The stories often represent philosophical thought experiments presented in entertaining ways Like acquired omniscience, for instance ? Or the idea of a galatical economy based on travel fuel ? > Protagonists typically “think” rather than “shoot” their way out of problems, About half of the story are analytical inner monologues... > SF is putting characters into far psychological extremes and thought experiments. Yeah well that's the TL;DR of the Atreides arc...
- Keyframe 10y agoIt's debatable, as I've said. It certainly can be viewed as an SF. However, main story vehicle is that of 'the chosen one' and of 'the legend / prophecy' which is usually main driving vehicle in fantasy. So, maybe an SF Fantasy? :) Matrix trilogy dwells into that space as well. I love Lynch's Dune adaptation very much though.
- fao_ 10y agoThe Lion of Commare follows "the chosen one" arc, yet nobody doubts that it is science fiction.
- the_af 10y agoIndeed. There is very little action in Dune. Almost all of it is politicking and inner monologues. Dune is definitely NOT a space opera like Star Wars.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoI like my definition better: "if the main character is wielding a sword, then it's Fantasy; otherwise, it's Science Fiction". Star Wars, for instance, is Fantasy because lightsabers. Star Trek is Sci Fi because phasers. Hobbit- swords. Dune- weirding modules. Highlander- swords. Blade Runner- no swords. Etc etc.
- Keyframe 10y agoI get what you're saying, but I wouldn't cut it just like that. I mean, you could and it would kind of be valid, but hear me out. In my opinion, SF is really about thought experiments, psychological stress to the extreme and what if's. One could imagine a story with a swords and sorcery and still keep it like that. There's also that whole science aspect of SF which I don't think has to be held up to literally. Fantasy, in contrast, is more goal oriented where there's a clear hero's journey line to it. Whether more stories in fantasy wield a sword could lean distinction like you've mentioned. I'm trying to keep the line more at the base level. FWIW, I've been in TV and Film and storytelling for the better part of last ten years or so, so I might have another perspective on it. I'm looking at the distinction based on character development. SF stories have character arc driven by internal goals, whereas Fantasy is more the opposite where external motivation is the one driving the development of the inner goal (a proverbial journey, if you will). It's not a clear line when you look at the story structure, but it's definitely clear when you look at the arc and inner vs outer motivation on the character development front. I've been taught of a certain way of developing stories, so maybe that's my bias. Always develop the character change first and then build the supporting ones and their arcs as well. Then, build a story structure around it (like a separate supporting structure on top of it). Character change IS the story. If character is the same in the beginning and the end, you haven't told a story. The way character changes, not the mechanics, but expression of goals is usually what defines the genre in my opinion. Theme, setting, story structure, and rhythm are flairs which can be genre-specific, but are on top of the 'main story'. I might've gone maybe too much into it though.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoI appreciate your reply and I find it well thought-of. The problem is that Science Fiction is, literally, Fantasy without swords (or sorcery, but my position is that the two basically go together). Or at least that's what it started as, back in the Golden Age. For instance, you'll probably know that in that era the editors of Sci Fi pulps would reject a story if it had magic in it, so writers instead framed magic as "psionics" - because that made their stories sound more scientifically plausible (for their time, always). So in essence, you could take the exact same story, with the same characters having the same motivations and advancing down the same goal etc, and simply change the external trappings, from sword and sorcery to ray guns and psionics, or vv, and- presto, genre change. The distinction is entirely artificial, is what I'm saying, and dictated more by the needs of the publishing (or TV, film, etc) industry than what kind of stories a writer wants to write or a reader/viewer enjoy. That is as true now as it was back then but it's actually a good thing, nowadays, because it means that you can tell the same stories either as Fantasy or as SF and all that matters is really how good the story is. Hero's journey with aliens and spaceships, for Star Wars, gritty realism with swords and dragons for The Game of Thrones. And why not? The best Fantasy and SF is very often found in the boundary between the two genres. The flimsier the boundary, the easier for the two genres to intermingle to the delight of all of us who enjoy a good story, regardless of the trappings. Btw, I should say that most of my interest in (and knowledge of) Fantasy and SF comes from novels, rather than TV shows and films. I appreciate that TV shows, in particular, have been able to tell more engaging stories in recent times (eg. I'm totally a BSG fangirl) but still TV prioritises tropes and specialises in providing a quick fix- which though makes my criterion even more relevant. In writing, it's a lot easier to escape the tropes and just tell a story about people doing things, rather than who-fought-whom-with-what.
- flanbiscuit 10y agoMy guess is that BeetleB has certain expectations of Sci-fi that probably aligns more with the Hard Sci-fi genre. Which is a personal preference. To me, Dune is Sci-fi + Fantasy.
- cafebabbe 10y agoWell I can agree with that, but he stated "nothing like sci-fi"
- Houshalter 10y agoDune's setting feels almost medieval instead of futuristic. Some futuristic technologies exist. But in many ways it shows how humanity has regressed rather than advanced. A lot of it feels an awful lot more like magic than science. Like the mind reading and prophecy stuff. The more interesting technology, personal shields, is just an excuse to explain why people fight with swords instead of modern weapons. Which lends to the medieval feel thing. And an awful lot of technology is missing, like anything remotely like a computer. The robot wars happened in the distant past and aren't part of the story. Just an explanation for why there aren't any computers. It's barely mentioned in the book at all actually.
- Eupolemos 10y agoTrying to classify Dune, I think it's more of a Hyper-Postappocalyptic setting with today's eyes. I tend to think of Fantasy as linked to philosophy (moral choices etc), while Sci-fi is linked to sociology (what would society be like if...). But those classes don't really help with Dune, so I choose the HPA definition.
- Jtsummers 10y agoMindreading? Was that in the books, have I forgotten it? I believe it's in the movie, sort of, but in the book the Bene Gesserit were trained to communicate with covert hand signals while simultaneously carrying on a verbal conversation. I think they conveyed this in the movie as mindreading, but it's been years since I watched it.
- howard941 10y agos/mindreading/truthseeing/
- Jtsummers 10y agoAh, yeah, forgot about that. Reminds me a bit of Lie to Me taken to an extreme.
- Houshalter 10y ago
- Robin_Message 10y agoWitchcraft, sword-fighting, riding around on beasts, feudalism, scarcity, walking... Dune is great sci-fi even just for pointing out the future might look more like the past than the present. Then, the middle books cover prescience and its implications. The last two have more typical 80's sci-fi: ships, planets, weapons, dystopian overcrowded cities. The final clincher for me though is the strong thread of politics* throughout and the exploration of relationships outside of the bounds of the possibilities of past or present. In case you can't guess, I highly rate it all! (Although 2 and 3 are a bit weaker.) * Indeed, in an early scene, Paul identifies the purpose of the Bene Gesserit as politics, and they are arguably the main thread of the books.
- flukus 10y agoThere's nothing sci-fi about mind reading, the may as well cast a spell to read minds, it's a plague on the entire genre. Fortunately dune didn't have mind reading.
- fao_ 10y agoScience Fiction is about political/social/ethical problems in a future setting. This is one of the most consistent things that runs through the works of Clarke, Asimov, Banks, PKD, Le Guin, etc. they take political and social problems, reframe them and drop them in the future, and solve them there, mostly relying on human puzzle solving than technology itself. Even in hard science fiction, the technology is simply the spice for the political/social/ethical problems that are presented. In Dune, the politics are the centerpiece. The scientific background of this, [the ethics of] genetic breeding, the butlerian jihad, [the ecology of] Arrakis, [the sociology of] the Fremen and their customs, all make it true science fiction.
- technofiend 10y agoIt can be about politics - See Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars series and Foundation by Asimov for two classic works with that as the center theme. But you're painting with too broad of a brush when you label all sci-fi as primarily about politics. There still plenty of other aspects of humanity and society to explore.
- icebraining 10y agoFunny you should mention the Mars series, as in Red Mars one of my favorite characters actually says “Everything is political!”.
- arethuza 10y agoSounds like either Frank or Maya?
- icebraining 10y agoArkady, actually :) Frank has another quote which I relished: “It was a mistake to speak one's mind at any time, unless it perfectly matched your political purpose; and it never did.”
- technofiend 10y ago
- najajomo 10y ago@BeetleB: "I remember as a teenager eagerly anticipating reading Dune. And was totally disappointed. There's nothing SF about it." To whomever modded down the above, care to offer a reason as to what you find objectionable in that statement. Personally I don't need other people to censor posts on this here forum. I am quite capable of making up my own mind as to the veracity of such statements. edit: Censorship practised on Hacker News I'm sick of the censorship practised here through the use of the modding system to render certain comments invisible. Yet another self confirming echo chamber on the Intertubes. So long and thanks for all the fish :)
- pjc50 10y agoI didn't bother to downvote it, but it's obviously wrong and probably trolling? Not to mention that "is this SF" is a bad question, like "is this Art": it tends to produce gatekeepering flamewars rather than an interesting discussion on genre boundaries.
- BeetleB 10y agoAs the original commenter, I feel I should at least somewhat explain. The article is about how Lynch's movie "has no interest in science fiction". And why? It lists qualities that are true for many, if not most, SF movies. Essentially, the author of the article may have made good arguments on why Dune is not a good movie compared to the novel, but did not make any good arguments on why it is not SF. So, I can make the exact same silly comment in response. Yes, it's true that Dune did not fit my liking for SF, and when I read it, it was just a fantasy with some whizbang stuff thrown in. >Not to mention that "is this SF" is a bad question, like "is this Art": it tends to produce gatekeepering flamewars rather than an interesting discussion on genre boundaries. Is that not what the article does? Why is my comment so irritating to others when the article isn't? Ultimately, I think I'm downvoted because people liked the book and I didn't - the same reason the article is being upvoted.
- pjc50 10y agoWell, thanks for the explanation. Context is a hard problem in text.