3 ms·
I am reminded of Feynman's musings on rat mazes. Are they quite sure they're measuring what they believe they're measuring? > For example, there have been ma
by hprotagonist 10y ago
I am reminded of Feynman's musings on rat mazes. Are they quite sure they're measuring what they believe they're measuring?
> For example, there have been many experiments running rats through all kinds of mazes, and so on—with little clear result. But in 1937 a man named Young did a very interesting one. He had a long corridor with doors all along one side where the rats came in, and doors along the other side where the food was. He wanted to see if he could train the rats to go in at the third door down from wherever he started them off. No. The rats went immediately to the door where the food had been the time before.
The question was, how did the rats know, because the corridor was so beautifully built and so uniform, that this was the same door as before? Obviously there was something about the door that was different from the other doors. So he painted the doors very carefully, arranging the textures on the faces of the doors exactly the same. Still the rats could tell. Then he thought maybe the rats were smelling the food, so he used chemicals to change the smell after each run. Still the rats could tell. Then he realized the rats might be able to tell by seeing the lights and the arrangement in the laboratory like any commonsense person. So he covered the corridor, and, still the rats could tell.
He finally found that they could tell by the way the floor sounded when they ran over it. And he could only fix that by putting his corridor in sand. So he covered one after another of all possible clues and finally was able to fool the rats so that they had to learn to go in the third door. If he relaxed any of his conditions, the rats could tell.
Now, from a scientific standpoint, that is an A‑Number‑l experiment. That is the experiment that makes rat‑running experiments sensible, because it uncovers the clues that the rat is really using—not what you think it’s using. And that is the experiment that tells exactly what conditions you have to use in order to be careful and control everything in an experiment with rat‑running.
- sjeohp 10y agoMethodology is important but given that (assuming the results are valid): - Ants ignore other ants behind clear glass but inspect their own reflections. - An ant with a blue dot on its head when shown its reflection will rub at the dot. - An ant with a brown/invisible dot on its head will ignore it. - An ant with a blue dot on the back of its head where it can't be seen in the mirror will ignore it. At a certain point Occam's razor comes into play, doesn't it?
- hprotagonist 10y agoAs moyix points out below, Occam's razor could well also point to "the investigators are deluding themselves".
- sjeohp 10y agoNot really since that's not an explanation of the results. The simplest explanation of the results is that ants have some degree of self-awareness.