5 ms·
Have you heard? There's a shortage of new Ferarris. I've been trying to buy one for $5000 for years now, and just can't find a single one. We need to do somethi
by ryandrake 10y ago
Have you heard? There's a shortage of new Ferarris. I've been trying to buy one for $5000 for years now, and just can't find a single one. We need to do something about this shortage.
EDIT:
The first paragraph of this article is straight out of la-la-land. In any market, if there is really a shortage of a good, the price of it would rise to the point where supply met demand. So why is the price of tech talent not rising (consequently demand falling) to the point where the existing supply meets demand?
A half a million open computing jobs. LOL. It's pointless to claim you have an open job you can't fill when you're not willing to pay what the market is demanding. I'll hire someone for a dollar an hour to do my personal web site. Should that count among these half a million open jobs? It's just as serious an opportunity as most of them.
- jchin 10y agoYes, but isn't the article basically saying you could buy a cheaper non-Ferrari and do a little work on it to make it comparable to a Ferrari? And in the end, it would be cheaper than buying the Ferrari outright. I think the premise is reasonable. Why do you need a $5000 Ferrari? Is it to transport you from one place to another? Because then another car would do. And I think that's what this article is saying about these companies. They believe they can ignore all those Ferrari devs out there because they can build their own that will reasonably do the same thing at a price that is "suitable" for the company's needs. EDIT: typo
- draw_down 10y agoNo, see, market logic is only sound when it doesn't suggest that laborers be paid more. If that happens, there must be something wrong with the market.
- xaa 10y agoYou're really quite correct. Businesses are all "small government, low regulations, free market" until government, regulation, oligopoly, etc., would help them.
- wai1234 10y agoYour economics are incomplete. You can't buy your way out of an aggregate shortage. The price will rise until only the rich can afford what is in short supply, and then, eventually, only the richest rich, and so on. The rest do without. These companies have created their own shortage by insisting they will only hire the top 1% and be unwilling to invest in anyone less 'capable' regardless of the quality of their so-called filter at identifying talent. So now they have 'discovered' the concept of actually helping people they would have ignored yesterday to grow into the talent they need (and absorbing the marginal costs of that investment). An idea boldly entering the 1950s as an innovation. The revolving door hiring in SV has maxed out with virtually all the 'suitable' talent in play and still many openings unfilled despite plenty of reasonably capable but sub-superstar talent pushed to the margins. The lid has been maintained on salaries mostly by agreements between the usual suspects, not market forces. The fact is that many perfectly good developers will be ignored by SV at any price and that's now biting the companies hard.
- xaa 10y agoWhat do you mean by "aggregate shortage"? Since you reference economics: There's a supply curve, there's a demand curve, and QS/QD/price are set by where they intersect. The fallacy in this article (and in your first paragraph) is pretending that the supply curve for programmers is vertical; i.e., that the same amount of people would be programmers (i.e., QS), no matter the salary. Patently false. For that matter, demand being inelastic is false as well which is what GP is pointing out with his website job. AFAIK, shortages only exist if either price or quantity produced is held static by some external force. There is no shortage here. The demand curve for programmers is just such that employers are unwilling to pay for the quantity they SAY they'd like. The very nature of demand curve is such that the people who are willing to pay most will get the item "first", no shortage required.
- wai1234 10y agoPlease re-read my comment. The quantity produced is held static by an external force: the ridiculous filter used by the SV bigs that exclude 99% of developers sight unseen. They create a shortage for themselves and then complain there is a shortage because the world isn't producing enough 'geniuses' to meet their needs (without also requiring any investment by them). It's a self-inflicted problem for which they accept no blame. This 'farm team' notion is just the light dimly dawning on some of them that they might be able to solve their own bind by actually engaging (and investing) in the solution and not just whining. By cutting themselves off from the vast majority of the potential talent supply, they have, in essence, stranded themselves on a desert island of their own manufacture. Side rant: Directed at many posts already in this tree. Economics 101 does not describe any real market and the labor market is about as unreal as it gets. Developers are not interchangeable goods, and the flexibility in supply is almost non-existent. There will not be 100 new universities founded this fall to 'sell' into this 'market'. The market for DaVinci's would never clear if he were alive in a way that would make all buyers happy. Not. Going. To. Happen.