5 ms·
Interestingly, capital holders are complaining all the time as well. There are very few places to put money now with a decent return. Savings accounts pay rou
by nostrademons 10y ago
Interestingly, capital holders are complaining all the time as well. There are very few places to put money now with a decent return. Savings accounts pay roughly 0%. Bonds are at inflation, or sometimes less. The S&P 500's P/E is at 25, which is historically very high, implies a rate of return of about 4%, and makes the risk of a correction significant. Real estate is inefficient; property prices are so high that the IRR on rents is only a couple percent.
Basically the only place to get decent returns these days are in startups, which is why valuations have gone sky-high. This in turn cuts the average return, although in tech startups this is manifested as a big chance of losing everything and a small chance of a great return rather than a small chance of losing everything and a big chance at a small return.
I think what's actually going on is a big innovation deficit. We're at the end of the current scientific & technology paradigm, and there's not enough fundamental research going on to generate new technological opportunities. We see this in the returns to innovation (which are sky-high: if you come up with a technical breakthrough that legitimately makes things better for lots of people, you become an insta-billionaire) and the rareness of those returns. Historically, the last time this happened was the Great Depression, and WW2 broke us out of it because the war department funded a good deal of research that could never have happened in peacetime, which were then commercialized over the ensuing 50 years or so.
- posguy 10y agoSavings accounts are basically a negative return due to inflation, even if your credit union will do 1.25%, inflation is still 1.6% to 1.7%. We need to mobilize this capital back into the economy, rather than letting it languish in the financial markets, guarded jealously by a handful of people. The economic stimulus it would provide could easily help kickstart and sustain waves of growth and development, though we should not repeat the errors of the past (urban sprawl, heavy investment in infrastructure in dying suburbs). The last two were borne of an era where sprawl was supposed to distribute the white populace so as to allow some to survive nukes, and it has run its course and proved to be unmaintainable (look at Livingston, TX).
- creaghpatr 10y agoI think most people in the middle class or lower have debt rather than savings so they directly benefit from inflation (while also being directly hit by inflation in terms of purchasing power)
- petra 10y ago>> big innovation deficit. >> not enough fundamental research going on to generate new technological opportunities. And on the other hand, the news is full of items about technologies with large market impact, in almost every industry, and a lot of new technological building blocks. Some of it is crap, but still. >> We see this in the returns to innovation .. rareness of those returns. Maybe this is because of more intense competition - in the past you could had some years before someone copied you. Today, it happens much faster, and barriers to entry are often easier, at those stages.
- nostrademons 10y agoI think we're seeing faster innovation in certain areas (software, mostly), but much slower in others (material science, medicine, sensors, transportation). Remember that line in The Graduate (1967) - "I want to say one word to you: Plastics." You get a new Javascript framework every 6 months, but the last major materials to gain consumer adoption were carbon fiber & titanium in the 80s. The post-war years saw rapid consumer adoption of lots of technologies initially developed in the 20s and 30s but forced into rapid adoption by WW2: radar, sonar, aviation, refrigeration, antibiotics, nuclear energy, microwaves, air conditioners, interstate highways, computers, aluminum, plastics, synthetic rubber, rocketry, and then later the offshoots of rocketry & computers (GPS, software, and the Internet). That last wave is petering out now. There is evidence that a huge new wave is incubating now, with 3D printing, drones, telecommuting, cheap satellite launches, mesh networking, solar and wind energy, and more far-out technologies like carbon nanotubes, memristors, and solid-state batteries. But all of these technologies will need sustained R&D expenditures to get to a robustness & price point level that makes them suitable for consumer applications.
- tomjen3 10y agoCounterpoint: it took less than 10 years for 77%[1] of the US to own a smartphone, which has made many new businesses viable, including arguably the entire IoTs. Then you have the secondary effects: the chips that are used as sensors in the phones are now cheap enough to put into everything. I have an e-parking device that automatically stops and shows the time when I park (many parking spots here are free, but can only be used for a limited time). It is not connected to anything, it just measures when the car moves. [1]: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/01/12/evolution-of-technology/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/01/12/evolution-of...
- ryandrake 10y agoThe "capital holders" are crying crocodile tears. Oh my god, my millions are only making a 4% return! The horror! My heart bleeds for those downtrodden folks, really it does. Tons of people make 0% return because they live paycheck to paycheck, are deep in debt, and have no savings and no investments. Almost half of Americans own no stock (either directly or indirectly through retirement funds, etc.) [1] and therefore do not even have the opportunity to bitch about "rates of return" at all. The capital class (as opposed to workers) has captured [2] nearly all of the business value created since the 70s through productivity improvements. Automation will multiply this disparity. Recent "post-recovery" income gains have almost gone entirely to the top [3]. I really don't think anyone should be expected to give a shit about what capital holders think. Maybe things would actually improve if they could be made to stop "holding" so much. 1: http://www.gallup.com/poll/182816/little-change-percentage-americans-invested-market.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/182816/little-change-percentage-a... 2: http://www.epi.org/publication/understanding-the-historic-divergence-between-productivity-and-a-typical-workers-pay-why-it-matters-and-why-its-real/ http://www.epi.org/publication/understanding-the-historic-di... 3: https://thinkprogress.org/the-1-percent-have-gotten-all-the-income-gains-from-the-recovery-6bee14aab1 https://thinkprogress.org/the-1-percent-have-gotten-all-the-...
- nostrademons 10y agoIf you substitute "retired parents" for "capital holders" and "$40K income" for "4% returns", would it change the tone of your comment? The problem with class-warfare explanations is that class distinctions are a lot more muddled than simple labels, and many people are both labor and capital at the same time. Or if not, one member of a family might easily be working class while another family member relies upon savings to live. (I do think there's something inexcusable about the layers of hedge funds & management fees between a retiree's pension and the actual capital markets; it's like the entire financial industry decided that pensioners are the rubes to fleece.)
- ryandrake 10y agoI would not change my tune that much. The ability to retire with a passive income is a luxury that my generation as a whole may not see in great numbers. I'm lucky enough to be part of the population who does have a little savings--not making even close to 4% obviously, but better than a poke in the eye with a blunt stick. But it's not zero and every day I am grateful and thankful for even having a little. I really have a hard time getting worked up over people who are complaining that their pile of money is not making even more money while they sleep.