9 ms·
I worry about this for my oldest son. He has dyspraxia and apraxia. In practice that means he has difficulty with memory (at 15 he still doesn't know his multip
by irrational 10y ago
I worry about this for my oldest son. He has dyspraxia and apraxia. In practice that means he has difficulty with memory (at 15 he still doesn't know his multiplication tables) and putting things in order (such as speaking - you have to put phonemes, words, sentences together in order to speak). But, he doesn't look like he has a disability and he doesn't speak much so people don't readily realize he doesn't talk like other people. There are people who know him for years without realizing there is anything "wrong" with him. Unfortunately there is no way he will be able to go to college. He is basically flunking middle school despite putting forth his best effort because he simply can't remember anything and can't put things in order to respond to questions or write things down. However they will basically pass him since they have documentation that he has a disability. He will get a high school diploma because if you have a documented disability and attend public school they will basically just give you a diploma if you at least show up. College, obviously, doesn't work the same way. I'm not really sure what will become of him. I'm not sure he could hack a trade. He could do manual labor, but that doesn't really pay well enough to live on your own, at least where we live. I'm afraid he will end up with the problems outlined in this article.
- cryptarch 10y agoMaybe learning a craft could work for him? Woodworking, metalworking, glass-blowing, programming? An apprenticeship might just be right up his alley, but I'm not sure how available that is in the US.
- vkou 10y agoProgramming is extremely memory intensive.
- kevindqc 10y agoand the order of things is pretty important
- Jtsummers 10y agoApprenticeships happen a fair amount with electricians and plumbers here still. And that's work that can't be readily outsourced (though it can be undercut with cheaper labor). The need to have work up to code ("need", some people don't care) does keep the rates higher than, say, carpentry work.
- posguy 10y agoFor plumbers, electricians and a few other trades you can become a journeyman apprentice in the US, and after a few years you can earn high 5 digits to low 6 digits with healthcare usually. That being said, its a mature industry and not highly regarded in the US as it is a "blue collar" job. Stigmatizing & devaluing an honest days work is ridiculous to me, but that is what our society has done to these jobs.
- stinkytaco 10y agoYou also likely can't work into your 60s doing work like this. Some people move into management, assessment, inspection, etc, but not everyone can do that. There's more going on here than stigmatization (which I rarely see in real life), these jobs have a different set of concerns that we aren't good at dealing with socially.
- pc86 10y agoBarring accidents, injury, or bad luck (e.g. a car crash or something), you can absolutely save enough to retire as a plumber before your body starts to break down. Especially if you assume SS will still be around for a new plumber's retirement, which may or may not be the case. Even without, it's doable. I know two plumbers socially and both are in their late 40's. One owns a plumbing business so mainly does office/marketing tasks but one is just a standard plumber and does plenty well for himself and his family.
- posguy 10y agoThis ^^, you can do well as a plumber and retire after 2 or 3 decades of working if you play your cards right, leaving you with a fairly functional body and freedom from working 1 to 2 decades ahead of most people in the US.
- stinkytaco 10y agoWhich brings up another issue: manual jobs involve non-trivial amounts of physical risk. Not only does getting injured negativly affect your life you will always do better working than on disability. And I agree that it's possible for some people to own a business or or do office work, but not everyone who is a plumber today will be able to do that. There are fewer owners than workers. I don't think we should discourage trades, but we can't sugar coat them either. I used to work as a mechanic and never met one that was 65 (the SS retirement age). The safety nets in place are optimized for people who work office jobs, not manual jobs.
- sbardle 10y agoI went to a school where a number of friends were not academic in the slightest. They left as soon as they could often with no qualifications but gradually learnt trades. Many now have their own businesses (one is a plasterer, another a builder) and they earn good money, own their own homes, and have no student debt. The reason? They had supportive parents. Many of the people who are falling into despair tragically come from very broken families.
- emodendroket 10y agoI'm guessing the successful people you're describing do not have severe learning disabilities. And I find it at least questionable that parenting has gotten markedly less supportive in the past few decades.
- anigbrowl 10y agoHe didn't say that parenting had got less supportive, he said that many people with severe structural disadvantages come from badly broken families.
- emodendroket 10y agoHe said that in the context of a discussion of deteriorating conditions, so I think it's fair to bring it up.
- posguy 10y agoIn a way, parents can support their kids less today. Wages have stagnated and stratified heavily, leaving the median home with less effective income, meanwhile the cost of college has gone from free (at public institutions) and nominal at private schools ($400/yr adjusted) to over $10k a year minimum. Housing rising in cost is only dog piling on and exacerbating the issue.
- will_brown 10y ago>And I find it at least questionable that parenting has gotten markedly less supportive in the past few decades. Look at the trends of the past few decades: divorce; single parent; and dual income households. There is in fact remarkedly less two parent, supported by single income households, meaning it's a rareity for a child to simply have a parent at home when they return from school to fix them a healthy snack, ask how their day was, or help with homework. Certainly it's not a single cause, but stability in the home is indisputably tied to mental well being of the child.
- cookiecaper 10y agoMy grandfather was dyslexic and in his 92 years, he never could learn to read. He started his own garbage disposal business and became wealthy from it, eventually getting contracts with several significant municipalities in the Northwest before he sold it off. He surrounded himself with intelligent, well-educated people who would read the contracts to him and advise him (primarily his sons and wives, but also trusted employees and confidants). Of course, this was a different time, but I believe the principle is valid. If you have confidence, charm, and enterprising spirit, the world is open despite any particular individual limitations. The white-collar career path of collegiate education is not the only option, and as many upset Millennials are discovering, it's often not even a good option anymore.
- magic_beans 10y agoAh, that is the very definition of white privilege. This despairing young white America just doesn't realize they actually have it, unlike their truly hopeless minority counterparts.
- magic_beans 10y agoNaturally this comment won't go well on HN.
- cookiecaper 10y agoFirst, you've presumed that my grandfather was white. Second, I'm not connecting the dots anyway. How does this involve race or privilege? One would assume that illiteracy is a substantial disadvantage regardless of one's family background or ethnicity.
- magic_beans 10y agoHonestly, I assumed he was white because it was entirely unremarkable for a black person your grandfather's age to be illiterate or close to it. (I know your grandpa isn't black). An illiterate black person had almost no chance to have a successful life. > If you have confidence, charm, and enterprising spirit, the world is open despite any particular individual limitations. THAT is white privilege. You must understand that the world is simply NOT open to black people this way. Not at all.
- shortimer 10y agoBeing another person giving you advice may be irritating, but on the off-chance it helps, in my area (Northeast USA) there are places where people who need help "living" can do just that. They get a room, food, help with transportation, and "recovery" (life) planning assistance, and it is "free" (their Medicare/Medicaid). They are free to get jobs, and some do, either at partner facilities where they do small repetitive tasks, or in a traditional job in the community. The #1 challenge is quality - as a parent, you'd have to be and stay involved, as even within a single organization, the quality of each "house" can vary really significantly based on the people who work there, and further, can drift over time as the staff evolves. Anyway, here's to you; parenting is never easy. edit: grammar
- magic_beans 10y agoHow does your son do with physical objects? Could he learn plumbing or handyman work? Both of these trades still bring in enough money to live, and in some cities, enough money to live extraordinarily well.
- hourislate 10y agoIf he can physically hack it then a career in Landscaping. It's just that it is physically demanding. Cutting Grass, planting trees, interlock, etc.
- cmdrfred 10y agoA low overhead / low start up capitol business to start as well. I have a few friends that own their own businesses in that field.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Retric 10y agoMany collages will make accommodations for people with learning disabilities. However, I think he needs to have a longer term plan than just going to school. He needs to gain a skill that will provide gainful employment and collage is often not the right path for that.
- Mendenhall 10y agoI wonder what he likes to do? It may be hard for him to fit into a "normal" job, but it makes me ponder the edge case "jobs". Things like making stuff and selling on etsy, Twitch channel or youtube videos, buying and selling comic books etc, cutting grass to start own landscaping business. It seems like he has supportive family so that to me is huge. Best wishes and I understand that concern completely, it just got me thinking about possible ways of harnessing what he is into etc.
- morbidhawk 10y agoMy son is a lot younger than yours with a different set of struggles (currently he's just preschool age) but he also appears to be completely normal to people who haven't spent a lot of time with him. He especially struggles with sensory processing and fine motor related tasks. We haven't got a firm diagnosis yet but hope to find out more from behavioral testing (neurological testing hasn't been able to give us any good answers yet) so he'll hopefully be able to qualify for disability. I'm also worried about my son's future, especially since a lot of people he might end up working with likely won't understand that just because he might not look like he has a disability doesn't mean he doesn't have one (I see this kind of ignorance all the time). Best of luck to you and your son, I wish I knew good answers to give you about these kind of struggles but this is still fairly new to me.
- irrational 10y agoYeah, it took years of therapy and testing before we were able to determine what exactly was going on. For some reason have names for his disorders makes things more understandable.
- devnullmonkey 10y agoWelders in my area can make > 100k easy. Houston area. Lots of work, not enough qualified welders.
- rabboRubble 10y agoThink you underestimate the certification requirements for welders. A simple welder certificate holder does need basic math skills. Required classes may include advanced mathematics, metallurgy, blueprint reading, welding symbols, pipe layout and a welding practicum. http://study.com/welding_education.html http://study.com/welding_education.html If the OP's child can not multiply, or follow ordered operations, it may be a huge stretch to to follow welding step-by-step assembly instructions. The higher level welding certifications have chemistry and physics knowledge requirements. http://www.aws.org/library/doclib/CWEng-bok.pdf http://www.aws.org/library/doclib/CWEng-bok.pdf Source: Dad welds and has attempted to teach me. Only marginally interested :)
- tomjen3 10y agoDoes it have to be near you? Farmers in America have severe trouble hiring people - I can't find the article now, but they were basically offering 60k/year to drive a tractor, no experience needed. Not SV money, but the cost of living is also much lower and no college debt.