7 ms·
> With index funds so big, who determines prices? ... At some point, this has to create problems, but so far it hasn't. Any active trader remaining in the mark
by loeg 10y ago
> With index funds so big, who determines prices? ... At some point, this has to create problems, but so far it hasn't.
Any active trader remaining in the market. Fortunately, active traders still make up a large part of the market. And the bigger indices grow, the larger the opportunities for active traders to profit. It's not a real problem — it's self-correcting.
- ipsum2 10y ago> And the bigger indices grow, the larger the opportunities for active traders to profit. I'm having trouble understanding why this is the case. Care to clarify?
- adrianN 10y agoIndex funds are buyers that don't think. If you have information that a stock has the wrong valuation you can sell to an index fund.
- alphadevx 10y agoIndex investments are still investments, they help push up the prices of the stocks they buy too. That creates opportunities.
- awjr 10y agoYou also have the situation that index funds must buy or must sell a stock if it enters or leaves an index. This creates an opportunity for active traders.
- kennethh 10y agoMost indexes are fairly predictable, so the changes are usually frontrunnered by index funds and traders.
- bdonlan 10y agoIndex funds buy or sell blindly, at whatever the prevailing best price is. Naturally, if there were only index funds in the market, the price would vary randomly. That being said, consider what would happen if stock prices did start to vary randomly - if you had actual research suggesting the price was too high or too low, you could trade accordingly. This would net you a profit, and also help push the price in the opposite direction, towards whatever a reasonable price is. The larger the deviation from the "correct" price, the larger the potential profits are to be had. So if the problem ever starts to be significant (i.e. a few cents of deviation caused by index funds), this means a very large potential profit for any active funds or traders out there. And so we would expect the system to reach an equilibrium - where there are just enough active funds and traders to snatch up the profits that arise from tiny price errors and distortions caused by index funds. In effect, the index funds are paying those remaining active funds and traders a tiny "management fee" (in the form of exploitable trading behavior) to figure out the appropriate price of stocks for them!
- gcb0 10y agostock prices Do vary randomly.
- rjtavares 10y agoI'm assuming that is a reference to the random walk theory. That theory suggests that "the past movement or trend of a stock price or market cannot be used to predict its future movement". It's random in the sense of unpredictable, not in the sense of actauly being determined by chance. The implication of the random walk theory is that current information is already uilt into the price of the stock. That is only true insofar as there are active traders acting on that information. The parent is merely explaining why those traders will exist, and why you only need a small part of the market to actively trade.
- hueving 10y agoRandom walk depends on all participants acting rationally based on the same information released at the same time. However, index funds are not rational, they always buy in the same ratios regardless of news.
- cJ0th 10y ago> And the bigger indices grow, the larger the opportunities for active traders to profit. It's not a real problem — it's self-correcting. I appreciate that finally someone puts forward a rational argument as to why index fonds will keep working. Books and online resources tend to not take a critical look at the system at all or they offer an answer along the lines of "Trust me!" Having said that, only hindsight is 20/20! It feels like we are rushing into the next great financial experiment. In a complex world there is simply no telling what's actually going to happen. I assume (any sources?) that currently more money than ever is flowing into index fonds. Furthermore, chances are this is just the beginning. For instance, the buy-and-hold hype is just arriving in Europe. Blogs and online communites on this topic are currently mushrooming here! Yesterday I even saw an ad on Germany's biggest TV station right before the evening news. This is very unusual to say the least as the common people of Germany by and large have an incredible amount of distrust in anything but savings books! This current gold rush mood is just scary to me as usually, when something hits mainstream media, the magic is gone! Anyhow, the question I am asking myself is: What will the market do now that it has access to more cash than ever? Are the markets even productive enough to put those sums of money to good use? Or is this bonanza just FU-money that encourages more reckless behavior? I can only speculate as to what is going to happen but my hunch is that in the long term the gap between returns from index fonds and savings books is going to become a great deal smaller as more people are willing to shoulder risk for companies and thus risk premiums go down. There may still be active traders who try to find opportunities but I suspect structurally the percentage of passive investors will expand quickly and won't go back below today's percentage.
- lmm 10y agoYou're talking as if there's a swarm of fresh money flowing into the market, whereas it's more a case of people shifting away from traditional actively managed mutual funds etc. into indexing. Money is cheap at the moment because growth is low, and that in turn means risk premia are lower and so on, but I don't think that's related to the rise of index funds. Then again I never understood why active management was so popular in the first place.
- cJ0th 10y ago
- thisrod 10y agoDoes anyone know what fractions of American equity currently belong to active and index investors? That seems like an important question, but the article doesn't address it.