3 ms·
> by financial metrics. There are three stakeholders in any company: * The owners (stockholders) * Employees * Customers When a company makes profit (eg, t
by josephg 10y ago
> by financial metrics.
There are three stakeholders in any company:
* The owners (stockholders)
* Employees
* Customers
When a company makes profit (eg, they manufacture a mattress for $500 thats worth $1000), the profit is divided between those three groups of people. How the money gets divided depends on the relative power those groups hold.
- In a market with lots of competition, the price goes down and the customers get a windfall through cheaper products
- When there's not enough supply of labour (like in software), the employees can demanding higher wages, better working conditions or shorter hours
- And otherwise, usually the owners get the profits.
The easiest metric of a company is to evaluate profit to shareholders. Thats not what coops are trying to optimize for. Instead they want a high quality of life for their employees. So I would expect you would see coops rated poorly, even when they're functioning (for their employees) very well.
- Kalium 10y agoYou're right! Cooperatives have a fundamentally different structure that makes the typical metrics of return to non-employee shareholders hard to use or make sense of. Fortunately, I think this is addressable. Cooperatives still have owners, be they employees or customers. The structure works by merging two of the three legs you sketch out. For worker-owned cooperatives, it should still be possible to evaluate how effectively they return profits to owners. You just have to evaluate it a little differently, perhaps by classing worker pay as dividends (or maybe the premium over non-coop competition). Plus, you can look at things like their offerings and the cost or quality thereof. I don't know anyone who goes to Rainbow Grocery Coop for reasonable prices. To recap, you're absolutely right. Coops are not optimizing for returning profits to uninvolved investor/owners. Instead, they are optimizing for returning profits to actively involved who act as one of the active groups above. As a result, I would think that metrics for evaluating a business could still be calculated and examined for a enterprise. After all, cooperative enterprises are still businesses.