6 ms·
I don't see the "illusions". It isn't as if these people are daily choosing their life. There aren't huge numbers of well-paid jobs out there for them or anyo
by sandworm101 10y ago
I don't see the "illusions". It isn't as if these people are daily choosing their life. There aren't huge numbers of well-paid jobs out there for them or anyone else. Just because someone isn't successful doesn't mean they are under some sort of illusion. The word "parasite" also implies that these people should somehow stop living, that they are such a drain that the parasite should just let got and die rather than continue the only life available to them.
They may have made some mistakes, but in previous generations a few mistakes now and again was not a life sentence. A few years off the books wasn't a big deal in the 80s or 90s. Now any gap in your linkedin profile is interrogated. In Japan and elsewhere, anyone with a blot on their employment record is doomed. And heaven help those with any criminal convictions. Our societies today deliberately push away so many people. It is improper of us to then say that it is entirely their fault or that they suffer illusions. The illusion is ours, that by shunning and dispossessing people for slight imperfections we only amplify them.
Once upon a time there was a net of reasonable jobs that didn't pay well but allowed people a life, low-level government jobs that took anyone willing to work hard. But has anyone here looked at how hard it is to become a postal worker or to join the army? Ability and willingness is no longer enough. (I have relatives in the Canadian Armed Forces. The application process takes at least one and sometimes many years.)
- devoply 10y ago> Once upon a time there was a net of reasonable jobs that didn't pay well but allowed people a life, low-level government jobs that took anyone willing to work hard. But has anyone here looked at how hard it is to become a postal worker or to join the army? Ability and willingness isn't enough any more. This is all about Neoliberalism then isn't it. Privatize everything and then the privatized companies are highly competitive and only want the best and couldn't care less about the middle or the bottom. It's not about jobs, it's really never been about the jobs that's just rhetoric. It's about profits. And profits are stuck in large consolidated corporations that pay as little as possible to the middle and the bottom, preferably on contract or the "sharing" economy of contractors. For full-time employees with benefits they just want the top which is often overworked. I mean the economy was engineered to be like this specifically for the benefit of those with money.
- HappyTypist 10y agoYeah. It's fundamentally broken. Companies maximise shareholder profits; minimizing pay of employees. It's a downward spiral on the cost of labour.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ithinkinstereo 10y agoI think the "illusion" referenced in the article is the sentiment that "things will just work out." Frankly I see this sentiment alot with today's millennial generation (really anyone from early 20s to mid/late 30s). Everyone thinks they'll have that dream job, life, marriage, kds, etc.... even the uber drivers and starbucks baristas. The "oh things will work out" attitude is especially prevalent given the popular parenting slogans of the past few decades: everyone's a winner; every child is special; you can do whatever you want if you put your mind to; etc.
- iphonethrowaway 10y agoMaybe we will see a rise is suicides? Oh wait, we already see that in decreased life expectancy via alcahol, drug abuse, and less access to medicine.
- ithinkinstereo 10y agoHah, why do you think weed is so popular?
- sandworm101 10y agoIt is only an illusion if you actually believe it. There is a fine line between an illusion that something will come, and hope that it will. I cannot fault people for hope.
- wtvanhest 10y agoFrankly, millennials were completely robbed by the generation before them in the United States. Incredible escalation in college costs, with the requirement that you need to go to college to get jobs that in no way require collegiate training. Severally penalizing even small mistakes by basically giving people as the OP put it, a life sentence for a single crime. Disgusting. I am one of the oldest millennials (born in 82) and my age group was the last to have it somewhat easy. People born in 92 are in a pressure cooking from every angle. The only answer is to transfer wealth from baby boomers to millennials through inflation. I have zero idea if it will happen, but as the pressure builds on this generation, they will surely look for political solutions, one of which is printing money.
- red_hairing 10y agowell, of course the media is going to depict these people negatively--the media lives off of corporate profits which are spent in part on media advertising...these stay-at-home people are just living a lovely life...but they are not working and are not consuming...and thus not helping to increase corporate profits much and thus not feeding the media...work work work...consume consume consume....rinse and repeat...
- tps5 10y agoI agree that saying they "suffer from illusions" is silly. But the rest of your analysis here seems off. There's no reason to lionize these people and act like "society rejected them." It's just (comparatively) easy to not work in the modern world, in first world countries, and these people didn't. I don't think there's that much more we can say.
- phs318u 10y agoDirect quote from the first subject: "I got used to living in an unstable situation and figured somehow it would work out" That last bit is illusory thinking. Also, I'd beg to differ on your suggestion that these people aren't choosing their life every single day. I'd suggest the opposite is true for most of us (leaving aside those who through incapacity have diminished options). Every single day you don't make an effort to look for work, don't volunteer for something, don't organise an activity, don't spend some time learning something, don't go somewhere to meet people, don't go on a date - you are making a choice. Living with your parents and (more importantly) living off your parents well into your fifties is not an accident. You can't accidentally do that. That is directly the result of daily choices and illusory thinking. And while we can agreee that the term "parasite" is pejorative, I find it is deserved- at least from the perspective of the parent (who in this case is probably as much to blame for this situation). My daughters are 20 and 18 and the expectation has long been set in our family that they will be moving out once they're in stable employment (and by that I mean any job that can pay their bills, not their dream job). When both kids are out of the house, we'll downsize and share some of the cashed out equity to help them get started on the property ladder. Then they're on their own. In our family we refer to this as "The Plan". They've been hearing about the Plan (and been onboard) since their early teens.
- sandworm101 10y ago>>> ... they will be moving out once they're in stable employment. Have you met any 20-somethings in stable employment? Unless your daughters are supermodels or have PHDs in biotech they are in for at least a decade of contract work and constant job-hunting. Even those at their dream jobs know they stand on the knife's edge. And the property ladder, the average home price in my area is over 500k and closer to 1m if you want to be in driving distance of any "stable" job. Even with the 20% down payment only top earners even qualify for a loan. I hope you are ready to co-sign their mortgages.
- sanderjd 10y agoWhere do you live? I know 20-somethings with stable jobs. Housing is expensive, but with good credit, it isn't hard to get a pretty big mortgage, even with much less than 20% down. I'm usually sympathetic to this sort of argument - I do think it's quite a bit harder for young people to get started than it was in the fairly recent past, but your comment seems hyperbolic.
- gragas 10y ago>Now any gap in your linkedin profile is interrogated. You don't need a LinkedIn profile to be a - plumber - electrician - nurse - teacher - truck driver The list goes on.
- eximius 10y ago> You don't need a LinkedIn profile. FTFY. If an interviewer criticized my lack of a LinkedIn profile, that is a warning sign to me.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoAgreed. Avoiding any employer that requires a LinkedIn profile at all strikes me as a wise policy.
- toyg 10y agoTruck drivers are on the verge of severe disruption, the category might even be extinct by the time the next generation comes around. Teachers are horribly underpaid and overworked. Nurses are in demand but there is no career. Traders are at the mercy of real estate markets. Sure, you don't need a LI profile to get a dead-end job.
- gragas 10y ago>Sure, you don't need a LI profile to get a dead-end job. I'm pretty sure the only people who ever say that are people who were raised to hate themselves if they aren't at least in the upper-middle class. There will always be teachers making $50k per year and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. In fact, if you look closely, all across America there are millions of people earning less than $60k per year. Guess what? They're doing just fine. They're content with life. They aren't toxic as*holes who can't live with themselves because they don't make X thousand dollars per year and live in Y school district.
- linkregister 10y agoI think you are in a bizarre region or do not have friendships with people in the mentioned occupations. Nursing, plumbing, and electrical work are all stable, rewarding jobs. Nursing has no career? Get real. Nursing has as much career progression potential as a software developer: nurse -> administration/policy/public health; nurse -> manager; nurse -> nurse practitioner; nurse -> anesthetist.