2 ms·
The Adams Complexity Threshold is the point at which something is so complicated it no longer works. The Gulf oil spill is probably a case of complexity reachi
by stcredzero 16y ago
The Adams Complexity Threshold is the point at which something is so complicated it no longer works.
The Gulf oil spill is probably a case of complexity reaching the threshold. It was literally impossible for anyone to know if the oil rig was safe or not. The engineering was too complex. I'm sure management thought it was safe, or hoped it was safe, or hallucinated that it was safe. It wasn't possible to know for sure.
Disagree. If the oil companies had put together a consortium to research such "worst case" scenarios and develop equipment and procedures to deal with them quickly, then this would have been preventable. (How about an even worse scenario: oil rig blows up, sinks, smashes the blowout preventer. Even Michael Bay can think of that one.) The oil companies could've done this, but chose instead to gamble on what they thought was a "good enough" lower level of safety.
No one can be 100% sure all of the machinery and safety mechanisms and procedures will work, but it is possible to make the likelihood reasonably small and then add an additional fallback position that you are pretty certain will work. The oil companies didn't have a fallback beyond the blowout preventer that they knew would work in a short timeframe.
An unreasonable expectation? Perhaps. Technology companies do this with their data all the time. Of course, protecting data is 1) much cheaper and 2) is protecting an asset and not preventing an unfortunate externality.
- pigbucket 16y ago> No one can be a 100% sure The problem is complexity plus scale. Do something potentially disastrous a 100k times, then you need to be impossibly close to being a 100% sure you've made it safe for every case. 99.9% doesn't cut it. BP's fallback position is: if it blows, and we can't stop it, we'll drill a relief well. That's the kind of decision that looks ethically bankrupt, probably is ethically bankrupt, and is nonetheless going to be made every time unless all the other oil companies also agree, or are forced to have, the fallback already in place.