3 ms·
More generally, black and white thinking is often less effective than thinking in scales.
by colordrops 10y ago
More generally, black and white thinking is often less effective than thinking in scales.
- dionidium 10y agoIs this really true? I was a vegetarian for 10 years. It was easy. Meat was verboten. Full stop. I never had to negotiate it with myself. But, now, at any individual meal I can convince myself that it's no big deal to eat a little meat. Crucially, I can convince myself of that for several days in a row. If the end goal is less meat, then, for me, the results were clear: black and white thinking was far more effective.
- ch4s3 10y agoHave you tried rate limiting? Or setting other simple rules? For example say: 5 servings of meat per week max, and only 1 of red meat?
- xexers 10y agoAgreed. I am normally a very nuanced person who tries hard to see all sides of an issue... but with my vegetarian diet, I find total abstinence to be the best thing. Eating a little bit of meat requires will power to not eat too much... and I have a limited reserve of will power which I want to save for other things in my life. I've been vegetarian for 9 years.
- colordrops 10y agoFar more effective for you as an individual, but has it been far more effective in the reduction of the absolute amount of meat that has been eaten world-wide?
- jdietrich 10y agoBlack-and-white behavioural change is almost always easier than quantitative change, because the cognitive burden of a prohibition is far less. Counting calories is rational but time-consuming, complex, error prone and open to self-deception; an absolute prohibition on starchy carbs is arbitrary but much easier to stick to. Not drinking at all on weekdays or drinking only with meals is cognitively much easier than restricting yourself to 14 standard drinks per week. Most religious laws are absolute prohibitions or absolute mandates - no foods are mostly kosher or halal, no foods become haram or treif merely because of quantity. None of the ten commandments are quantitative or subjective. Being a frummer is burdensome and inconvenient, but it's also remarkably straightforward. Strict and absolutist behavioural rules are easy to understand and apply.