5 ms·
>While this can be the fastest route, the GPS’s algorithm does not concern itself with factors important to truckers carrying a heavy load, such as the 43’s 1,3
by dsfyu404ed 10y ago
>While this can be the fastest route, the GPS’s algorithm does not concern itself with factors important to truckers carrying a heavy load, such as the 43’s 1,300-foot elevation drop over four miles with two sharp turns.
I know this is somewhat off topic but the lack of advanced options for GPS routing is such a PITA. It would be trivial to add check-boxes for things like:
"I'm towing a trailer, don't make me take dumb lefts across multiple lanes, avoid clustterfawks and don't make me take unnecessary turns"
"Yes I'm wealthy enough to afford an iphone, that doesn't mean I want you to send me through a $5 bridge toll"
"I'm taking a road-trip, send me on a route that uses ten fewer roads even if it takes twenty more minutes, I don't want to have to look for a turn every 10min"
I know tons of options aren't good for the UI but just hiding all that stuff behind an "advanced preferences" menu or something would be nice.
Just a simple tie in to a weather API that increases the cost of route features that are a PITA in snow would be nice (no I don't want to stop on a downhill to take a >90deg left across 40mph traffic in snow thank you very much).
- eganist 10y ago> "Yes I'm wealthy enough to afford an iphone, that doesn't mean I want you to send me through a $5 bridge toll" https://www.google.com/search?q=apple+maps+avoid+tolls https://www.google.com/search?q=apple+maps+avoid+tolls https://www.google.com/search?q=google+maps+avoid+tolls https://www.google.com/search?q=google+maps+avoid+tolls But I agree with the other ones. Quite a few of them might need better recognition of weight restrictions and other such rules on roadways, though. It in theory shouldn't be hard to develop (self-driving tech already either reads signs or sources data from previous mappings of roads where said signs have been read), but I wouldn't be surprised if this info hasn't yet been catalogued yet.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoI don't own an iphone (my girlfriend does). As far as weight restrictions and stuff, I'm talking even simpler than that. The geospatial data and a lot of the traffic flow is already there. It would be an "summer intern size" project to figure out an algorithm that does an ok job identifying route features and traffic flow situations that are not trailer friendly or delivery vehicle friendly (left turns suck). Even for something other than commercial vehicles this is important. Anyone driving a mini-bus with a student/church/summer camp group will run into a route with a really bad intersection or turn.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoHave you tried installing an actual GPS navigation app (as opposed to just Google Maps)? At least the last time I used one (I think it was CoPilot a few years back) you could specify stuff like "avoid toll roads", "prefer simplest route", and set the size of your vehicle all in the settings menu.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoI don't use my phone for my primary nav device, I use a decade old Garmin for most stuff but if I'm going somewhere I've never been on a more than 1min notice I just Google map it and plan my own route based on that. In urban areas street view is available and I can use that to make sure the Google route and my revisions are sane. In rural areas there aren't as many options or pitfalls so GPS generally works well if. Both the decade old GPS and Google maps have about the same effectiveness when it comes to finding residential addresses on small streets.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoThese would be good options, but to make it intuitive and not overly complex you probably need to group it into a few major use-cases. I recently rented a car and the built-in nav offered 4 route options that I'm pretty sure (tough to interpret some of the icons) broke down into: optimize for time, optimize for fuel, optimize for distance (don't know when I would choose this one - I would think trying to minimize wear on the car would be better when optimizing for fuel), optimize for turns. I think that last one could be improved for the towing use case you mentioned - I would often trade several minutes to make 3 right turns to avoid a left, but for the most part I'd also just like to get to some road and then not worry about any lane changes for a while. Maybe "fewest turns" and "fewest left turns" should be separate options. There's also a "no tolls" option on every nav system I've used, but I wish you could configure the trade-off there too- there's a dollar amount I'm willing to pay for every 10 minutes it saves me, depending on the day.
- michaelt 10y agoSpecial GPSes for truckers are available from companies like TomTom and Garmin. If truckers are choosing to save a few hundred bucks by using their smartphones, which don't have the trucker-specific features, surely the fault lies with the trucker for using a consumer-grade product, not with the consumer-grade product for not being professional-grade?
- shagie 10y agoWeight limits, clearances, weight stations, truck routes, city boundaries (transporting material restricted in a city?)... There is a whole host of features that are trucker specific. Trying to reconcile the hard copy guide for the possible route and a phone based route planner is something I don't want to imagine.
- macNchz 10y agoA truck GPS is extremely helpful if you're driving a commercial vehicle any appreciable distance in an unfamiliar place. They include many additional data points in routing: vehicle height for overpass clearance, vehicle weight for bridges, "No Trucks"/"Passenger Cars Only"/"No Commercial Vehicles" restrictions etc. You can get yourself into hot water if you're following car GPS directions with even a mid-sized U-Haul. See: http://11foot8.com http://11foot8.com
- logfromblammo 10y agoYou're already in hot water with a U-Haul. Anecotally, they have been the worst cargo vehicle rental business in my life. Get a truck from Budget, Hertz, or Penske instead. Every friend whom I have helped with their move has experienced a mechanical failure of some kind with a U-Haul vehicle that significantly increased the stress of an already stressful event. Know your clearance and pay attention to road signs. Your regular car insurance may cover rental cars, but it probably doesn't cover rental trucks. So if you peel your top on a low underpass, you may find yourself in a world of pain and regret for a long time. Ideally, if you are in a rental truck, you should already know how to get where you are going without GPS assistance.
- douche 10y agoOr, to cite another case that I see quite often on my commute home: I'm driving a tall panel truck, don't route me onto routes with low-clearance overpasses... I see beer trucks and U-Hauls with the top six to twelve inches sheared off by the railroad overpass at least once a month.
- helthanatos 10y agoGoogle maps normally gives you a few routes and you can choose the best. You can avoid highways, tolls, and ferries. You can preview all your turns. You can add stops if you want. I don't believe Google maps has many weather suggestions, but there are apps to check the whether. I've found Google maps to be better than any built-in GPS in my cars.
- Fjolsvith 10y agoI deliver sheds I build, and I use Windria to see which way the wind is blowing to find out the best time to travel with them.