6 ms·
I know at times I may sound like a shill for Patreon, but I have no connection to them whatsoever beyond "normal customer", and don't care if you use a competit
by jerf 10y ago
I know at times I may sound like a shill for Patreon, but I have no connection to them whatsoever beyond "normal customer", and don't care if you use a competitive service to them or whatever. But if you are in the position of finding yourself with a growing show like this, I implore you to set up some sort of voluntary subscription revenue as soon as possible, before you embed into the very foundation of your content a dependency on ad dollars. Even if you use it as an augment to ad revenue, it's so much better for you. It's more stable against Youtube deciding to tweak an algorithm one day. It's more stable month-to-month. It's even more socially stable since it releases you from having to chase ad dollars by keeping advertisers happy instead of your "actual" customers. If your primary money base is subscriptions rather than ads, you could even completely shift video services if you need to without crashing your income.
My interest in pitching this so often is my desire to play my little part in sticking a stake in the idea that getting advertising money is the default path to monetization. I'd rather move to a world where it's either merely one option among many, or even, dare I dream, a last resort considered vaguely déclassé.
Oh, and I would also implore you, let your patrons download video directly somehow. I'd love to not even have to go through YouTube at all. Of course, I'm a crazy Linux user for whom YouTube isn't as convenient as it could be, but it's another way to detach your patrons from a particular video service.
- brudgers 10y agoThe difference between advertising and Patreon is B2B versus B2C. It is the difference between sales based on economic value and donations solicited through donor development; between competing based on ROI and competing based on prestige and need each individual's alma mater, place of worship, or local food bank. Creating content every day or several times a day is what fans demand. It's not a question of if a dumb idea will make it into production and upset the audience, just a matter of when. Consider it like bugs. PewDiePie's patron, Disney, dropping him was a reversion to the norm. As recent stories about large advertisers reallocating dollars illustrate, it takes something a lot worse before eyballs and clicks don't drive the decision.
- sandworm101 10y agoFellow crazy linux user here. I follow many youtube channels but, as a canadian, am not allowed to support them with cash. (Red and all the other premium schemes never include us.) I too have trouble with youtube's interface and am often on a sat connection which makes everything more frustrating. Instead i use a combination of tools to download the vids directly, which denies my favorite channels even basic ad revenues. Youtube is the choke point.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoA bit of a sidebar but what tools do you use? Youtube-dl and a script to handle lost connections or something more complicated? I'm looking for a solution to a similar problem.
- sandworm101 10y agoI use a rather shady service popular with filesharers. For about 3$ a month i get access to a web interface that will download from the various hosting services (ie rapidgator) but also youtube. The video downloads then as a normal mpeg file over a secure connection, not a stream. They do the same for torrents, allowing me to get many linux distros without running a torrent client over a sat connection.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoThe script is barely necessary, youtube-dl resumes downloads when run again. If it's a regular thing, set up a cron job to run more frequently than necessary, if it's one time run the command then ; sleep 300 ; the command again Youtube-dl just does what you want 90% of the time, and good docs for the rest.
- rasz 10y agoI made https://github.com/raszpl/smplayer4YT https://github.com/raszpl/smplayer4YT for windows and chrome/vivaldi/opera
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- elsonrodriguez 10y agoThe flipside to this is that there are people who will never ever pay money for your content, and ad revenue is the only way to directly capitalize on your popularity among those people. This also means that when your ad revenue disappears, you will NEVER get that revenue back. Your only recourse is to get more popular, as your supporters are already buying your merchandise and donating. It's going to become much more difficult to support yourself via creating content if step 1 becomes "be famous".
- stcredzero 10y agoIt's going to become much more difficult to support yourself via creating content if step 1 becomes "be famous". It's already becoming like this for certain forms of media. Videogames, in particular. It's amazing how many things become easier, once you've already gotten notable. Come to think of it, it's been true to some degree, even in the days when media only existed in the form of spoken word and songs.
- sp332 10y agoBut to get money from ads you have to be famous too.
- rhizome 10y ago10,000 views means "famous?"
- sp332 10y ago10,000 ad views means supporting yourself from ad revenue? I mean if one person buys a t-shirt you've probably made more money, so I don't really see the advantage to ad revenue over merchandising, Patreon etc.
- rhizome 10y agoNo. YouTube announced recently that they aren't paying out on videos with less than 10K views. http://www.theverge.com/2017/4/6/15209220/youtube-partner-program-rule-change-monetize-ads-10000-views http://www.theverge.com/2017/4/6/15209220/youtube-partner-pr...
- Pigo 10y agoIf the channels I enjoy were all setup through the same service, whatever it may be, it would be easy for me support new media while tracking my budget better. I can be forgetful, and it feels like some subscriptions are built around attaching themselves to your credit card and staying under your radar. But I need to do a better job of supporting these channels I spend so much time on.
- stcredzero 10y agoThis sounds like a problem worth solving. What about a browser add-on, something like Patreauto? You could budget some amount per month, and it would automatically distribute payments to the top 40 video creators you watch?
- zobzu 10y agoid use that
- rhizome 10y agoYou're describing the Payments feature in the Brave browser: https://blog.brave.com/introducing-brave-payments/ https://blog.brave.com/introducing-brave-payments/
- gresrun 10y agoWhat you're describing is effectively what YouTube Red does. You pay a flat monthly amount and revenue is distributed out to creators based upon the videos you watch. [0] Full disclosure: I work at YouTube but not on Red. [0] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6306276?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6306276?hl=en
- stcredzero 10y agoMy interest in pitching this so often is my desire to play my little part in sticking a stake in the idea that getting advertising money is the default path to monetization. If Google and Facebook are The Internet (and for some large number of people, this is likely more than half true, in an empirical time-measurement sense) then The Internet is driven by advertisement. It's just become Cable TV 2.0. I'd rather move to a world where it's either merely one option among many, or even, dare I dream, a last resort considered vaguely déclassé. This was presaged by Scott McCloud. http://scottmccloud.com/ http://scottmccloud.com/ http://www.scottmccloud.com/3-home/essays/2003-09-micros/micros.html http://www.scottmccloud.com/3-home/essays/2003-09-micros/mic... And it was rejected by the mainstream, led by those with a vested interest in the new status quo. https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2001/06/22 https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2001/06/22
- dkersten 10y agod love to not even have to go through YouTube at all Agreed! I already back many of the people I watch regularly on patreon and am sick of all of the irritating adverts, so I'd much rather just download the videos and watch them directly.
- zobzu 10y agoi just adblock and yes on android too on a rooted device, and patreon everyone that has it setup much much better experience and it doesnt cost much... and yes its unfair to youtube, but hey, they make their own choices that are unfair are well
- Pxtl 10y agoFrom a user's perspective, though, I'm a little annoyed how Patreon has "won" in terms of user-backed content. I don't want to commit to a monthly. I would've preferred if something like Flattr had market dominance for this kind of thing. Although obviously, content producers sided with Patreon because it gives them predictable income, which keeps them from starving.
- jerf 10y ago"I don't want to commit to a monthly." Another part of the reason I tend to support the model is that I've watched micropayments for.... umm... gosh, about 16-18 years now. It isn't going to happen, or if it is, it's going to require something relatively fundamental to shift. I expanded more on that 3 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14117016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14117016 (Also why I decided I need to disclaim being a shill, since these two things came in quick succession.)
- rasz 10y agoTwitch is doing micropayments now https://blog.twitch.tv/introducing-cheering-celebrate-together-da62af41fac6 https://blog.twitch.tv/introducing-cheering-celebrate-togeth..., they call them bits, 1 bit is ~$0.015 First micropayment service that actually is _micro_.
- jamesjansson 10y agoNot really first. I run Tapview, we do micropayments that you can put on your own site, and we go down to 1 cent. Also, I'd say we are definitely not the first.
- HCIdivision17 10y agoThere are other methods, I think. At least one guy I back does it based on a per-comic basis. Granted, the comics are big and usually go longer than a month, but it's pretty good, I think. Takes some of the 'gotta-deliver-constantly' off him, and it only charges what is delivered. Which may just be an open pre-order on my part. Which is sort of the stupidest way to buy anything, I suppose, except for the social trust aspect I have in him.
- ziikutv 10y agoThis is why people are adding Pateron to their channels. Asking for monthly or single pledges from their fans to continue making content. There are many people already doing this. Easter Egg: "Bos in the house" Regards,
- bargl 10y agoDoes Patreon work on a per view basis? I'd love to be charged per view of a video similar to an add, but I can add in value as I want to. It would be nice so that I don't have to pay one person more than I should and others nothing.
- csydas 10y agoNo, Patreon has two options: Monthly and Per Release, which has a monthly cap that patrons can set. I'm not sure that there is enough of a hook into the various platforms to allow a per-view style payment system.
- bargl 10y agoIt would be nice to have something similar to youtube red for watching videos I just don't really want to pay youtube. I'd like content to be spread around a little more.
- RichardHeart 10y agoIf you like a persons content enough to pay them for it, then it might make sense to view the videos some way that isn't youtube. Perhaps, Pateron should team up with someone and offer the video hosting perhaps. I'd like to see competition for youtube. They'd fuck up less if there were a more compelling reason for them to stop fucking up.
- Chattered 10y agoI'd love to see IPFS video (https://ipfstube.erindachtler.me/ https://ipfstube.erindachtler.me/ ) get used for this sort of thing. For static, high-bandwidth content like video, that is created by users and for public domain, it makes more sense to be than a fat centralised pipe that's extremely expensive to maintain.