2 ms·
My understanding is that Continental, United, USAirways, American, Northwest, and Delta (the latter two also having merged) would've all ceased to operate had t
by nostrademons 10y ago
My understanding is that Continental, United, USAirways, American, Northwest, and Delta (the latter two also having merged) would've all ceased to operate had they not been allowed to merge. As of 2005 United, USAirways, Northwest, and Delta were all bankrupt; at that moment in time, 4 out of the top 6 U.S. carriers were operating in Chapter 11 bankruptcy. American entered bankruptcy in 2011, and Continental was reportedly in financial difficulties at the time. Had they not merged and instead entered Chapter 7, we might have gone down to 2-3 active airlines.
And we're already seeing renewed competition in domestic air travel: JetBlue and Alaska are coming up fast and threatening established carriers. JetBlue is my wife's favorite airline to fly on; she's gotten pretty good service on some very low fares.
I don't really see this as a market failure. People expect capitalism to give them great products at low prices all the time; it doesn't work like that. Capitalism just means that when things get too out-of-whack, the market adjusts and fixes it. Airlines were crazily unprofitable in 2008-2010; the market reaction was consolidation & mergers, such that airlines are now crazy profitable and give shitty service. The market reaction to that is that new competitors are springing up, saying "I can do better", and people are flying on them. Vote with your dollars and in another 5-10 years United will be bankrupt again.
- davidf18 10y agoThe legacy carriers had to go bankrupt because their original business models and labor costs were based on regulation and would not work once regulation was removed. Regulation created a huge market failure, a market inefficiency while deregulation made the market more efficient. The wages/benefits of labor were negotiated by unions that made the labor costs non-competitive with airlines that launched after deregulation. There may have been issues of operational inefficiency as well that was supported by the extra profits above an efficient market under regulation. Capitalists generally do not want market efficiency when it comes to providing a product or service but for customers that is the best deal. Firms fight commoditization of their product or service and tried to create "moats" that protect their business from competition. Looking for good investments is often a case of looking for businesses that can't easily be commoditized. Columbia Profs. Bruce Greenwald and (also Nobelist) George Stiglitz sometimes co-teach a course. Greenwald talks about making moats and Stiglitz talks about commoditizing to make products/services more accessible to people with lower incomes.