3 ms·
I for one do not except every .com to have a public web server running. And I rather not bind TLDs to services.
by zokier 16y ago
I for one do not except every .com to have a public web server running. And I rather not bind TLDs to services.
- derefr 16y agoYou, for one, are not an average user. :) By "expect", I meant something closer to "grandma knows that .net addresses go at the end of emails and usernames, the way .com goes at the end of websites, and since she only visits five sites and has three people she e-mails, she doesn't need to worry about the exceptions" sense, not a hard and fast rule. There wouldn't be a binding any more than TLDs today are bound to the web—the .net TLD would just mean "owned by a social network", just like .name means "owned by by a single person/family" or .org means "owned by an organization." All services that collected users for the explicit purpose of letting them communicate with external services and/or one another—Facebook, Gmail (or rather, Google Accounts), Twitter, Reddit and HN, any forum, Battle.net, etc.—would qualify as .net domains. The fact that they're currently web-based (or custom-protocol based) social networks makes no technical difference. (And alternatively, services like Google Wave and Buzz wouldn't really be separate .net domains—since they're not separate social networks, but rather subsets of the Google network that have a flag in their accounts flipped. The clients for them could live on the website at "google.net", but the services themselves would no longer give you separate, secondary identities.) It's just that, once something like Diaspora got going, social networks would become a distinct kind of site—they'd be the only kind that would bother running Diaspora servers at all (why run one for your company/organization? Everyone's already going to have an externally-bound identity anyway.) So, being able to guess that something is a social network/is running a Diaspora server by seeing the TLD (like grandma is able to guess that something is a website because it ends in .com: a "type it in and see" kind of guess, not one you place bets on) would be a nice convenience.