5 ms·
Not about the game: What was the point of publishing this information in such a non-functional format? Is this an example of minimalism taken too far (not even
by komali2 10y ago
Not about the game:
What was the point of publishing this information in such a non-functional format? Is this an example of minimalism taken too far (not even an anchor tag for the twitter link) or is this some publishing standard I'm not aware of?
I feel like the document could have benefited a great deal from some simple font color styling. I guess in its current format it can easily be copy-pasted somewhere else and still look exactly as it does?
- zellyn 10y agoIt appears to be a direct link to a README in a subversion repository. Are you arguing that all README files should be markdown or something? http://www.clifford.at/svninfo.html http://www.clifford.at/svninfo.html
- komali2 10y agoNot really arguing anything. Just curious if there was a specific reason to do this over maybe throwing together a basic HTML page before submitting to a news aggregator. I'm not making a judgement call, I'm trying to learn.
- forgotpwtomain 10y ago> Just curious if there was a specific reason to do this over maybe throwing together a basic HTML page before submitting to a news aggregator. Articles or links can be submitted by anyone not necessarily content authors. Further I think a lot of people here (myself) included are quite happy with plain-text (it loads fast, it works well with various font/screen sizes) - note also that the README is in fact markdown formatted, so feel free to open it in your reader of choice.
- zellyn 10y agoYeah, looks like the submitter was not the author.
- komali2 10y ago>README is markdown formatted Is it? How do you see that? Or is that a different link? Why doesn't my browser render markdown?
- wruza 10y agoIt is. You have to be familiar with markdown flavors. No, same link. Browsers do not render markdown by design (there is no single standard anyway).
- sgustard 10y agoHere you go, a markdown-formatted version of the article. https://markdownshare.com/view/bc431de6-16e7-44db-ad52-705a2c0618c9 https://markdownshare.com/view/bc431de6-16e7-44db-ad52-705a2...
- lucio 10y agoseeing that, I still prefer the plain text, unprocessed MD
- douche 10y ago> is this some publishing standard I'm not aware of? Remember when the internet was just plain text and ASCII art? Pepperidge Farm remembers.
- komali2 10y agoYes lol, I remember. Even back then you had anchor tags. Or are you talking about the way way back? I wasn't around for that.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoHow can one get any more functional than plain text? It could have been worse, they could have published it some binary format!
- komali2 10y agoBy wrapping links in anchor tags, for starters. Maybe some CSS to font-color the code to make it more readable? I like that in my IDE and I doubt it would cost much. Maybe in-document anchor tags to allow linking to certain sections?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- phil21 10y agoWith you on using anchor tags. Vehemently opposed to your other suggestions. But I'm weird and cranky, and very much miss the days of most of computing being done in plain text. It's really the first and only universal data format/API. The place to make plaintext pretty (if you care) is in the user's editor of choice where they can customize to their hearts content. I do know I'm in the very tiny minority with this opinion though.
- DanBC 10y agoPlain text is fine. It's a shame mobile browsers are so dysfunctional that they struggle to cope with plain text or minimally marked up HTML, but the blame lies with the browsers, not the content.
- H4CK3RM4N 10y agoiOS supports plaintext fine. You can even press Safati's reader view button if you need your text to be beautiful.
- reilly3000 10y agoReally? https://imgur.com/gallery/EuifW https://imgur.com/gallery/EuifW
- DanBC 10y agoI'm not persuaded that Safari is better than the rest. With no zoom the linebeaks are uncomfortable (which is ok, because EOL is difficult) http://imgur.com/9QulRkn http://imgur.com/9QulRkn Zoom shows combination of uncomfortable linebreaks and horizontal scrolling: https://imgur.com/ti7gGMV https://imgur.com/ti7gGMV Reader mode does reflow the lines, but prevents zoom. (Also destroys ASCII diagrams). None of these combinations are good.
- fiddlerwoaroof 10y agoASCII diagrams get broken, but you can change the reader mode font size.
- Sir_Substance 10y agoI just went to time.com and picked a random article. Without javascript turned on, I get the date it was published, the word "search" in the top right, a few drop shadow boxes, a black square, a hamburger menu icon and nothing else. /That's/ a non-functional format. Given the choice of everyone being time.com or everyone being like this website, I'd happily return to the days of amazing ascii art.
- komali2 10y agoThe things I think would improve the functionality of the OP article would require no JS whatsoever, just a CSS file and HTML tags. Really, just HTML tags at minimum. I wasn't suggesting including a JS file.
- Sir_Substance 10y agoYep, I'd totally agree with that, I'm a big fan of HTML-only websites. As a rule of thumb when writing websites (web apps are a different matter), I'd say if your CSS or Javascript is too big to hand-write, you've probably gone too far.
- derefr 10y agoI can see your point, though this particular case might not make it very well. A stronger example of the problem is, I think, some of the text from 4AM documenting their ongoing reverse-engineering efforts, for example: https://ia600509.us.archive.org/6/items/Muppetville4amCrack/Muppetville%20(4am%20crack).txt https://ia600509.us.archive.org/6/items/Muppetville4amCrack/... The 40col text might be "retro", but it also makes lines wrap so soon that my eyes get tired reading it. (And yet—unlike e.g. an RFC file—I can't just plop it into a Markdown parser or what-have-you to get reflowable lines of HTML out, because 1. it's not really in any particular format, and 2. the alternating "prose text", "formatted console interaction", and "formatted ASM listing with long prose comments beside them" sections aren't demarcated or delimited in any particular way.) When your text becomes sufficiently "simple", it can actually become an accessibility problem.
- mst 10y agoYep. Preface: I'm a cranky minimalist who would generally prefer reading plain-text-that-happens-to-be-markdown at a 78 col wrap (syntax highlighting tends to give me a headache, and I'm happy to copy-paste URLs as the price for having a document that's lightweight and comfortable to read). Actual point: Dear gods that 4am crack is awful to read, and I'd actually prefer github angry fruit salad in spite of mostly hating the latter. So, yeah, there are virtues to simplification, but it can still be overdone - and while the article we're commenting on was great to me, it probably overdid it slightly - and the link you provide is an unintentional reductio ad absurdum of the approach. (long comment written because I expected to disagree with you until I clicked and went aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa)
- ShaneWilton 10y agoThat link is a perfect example of how subjective all of this stuff is. I don't have any issues reading that page, though I understand how you might! Here's a blog post I've always found interesting about Markdown, from Joe Armstrong: http://joearms.github.io/2016/03/21/Why-Markdown-Sucks.html http://joearms.github.io/2016/03/21/Why-Markdown-Sucks.html Plain text documents don't solve the problem he's talking about, but they at least mitigate it somewhat -- WYSIWYG is preferable to a changing pseudo-standard mangling an author's intent, in my opinion.
- coldtea 10y ago>What was the point of publishing this information in such a non-functional format? Apart from the links not working, that's as functional as it gets for conveying text-based information. All the rest is fluff and the bytes to information ratio gets very bad, very fast (e.g. several MB to read a 1000 word CNN.com article). Although the question make me fell a little old. How young are you buddy, for this is a plain old textfile -- used to be a very very common way to convey information. Last generation's GitHub readme.md files so to speak. In fact, if one wants to know more about the phenomenon of textfiles, and read some classic stuff along the way: http://www.textfiles.com/directory.html http://www.textfiles.com/directory.html
- komali2 10y agoI certainly agree that auto-play videos and analytics JS takes it too far. But a little CSS to improve readability of code, some markup that allows links to be clickable, etc, seems reasonable to me at no performance cost. 25, so I grew up reading most of my content on wikipedia or forum posts, which is about the level of markup I mean (minus the ridiculously huge banner signatures that people were so fond of on invision forums ;) )
- Tloewald 10y agoI'm an old geezer who grew up with text terminals and I agree with you wholeheartedly. Saving a scarce resource (mental real estate) to save a near free resource (bandwidth / processor cycles) is poor tradeoff.
- dorgo 10y agoActually I like how it looks. I wanted to save the css file as inspiration for some future project, but found none. :-P
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cliffordvienna 10y ago> What was the point of publishing this information in such a non-functional format? You make it sound like this is a big publication I worked weeks on. :) It's not. It's a toy project I wrote Saturday. As far as "publishing" goes: I sent a tweet about it in the hopes someone might find it interesting. And now it's trending on Hacker News! Woohoo! ^_^ The link is just a deep link into my SVN repo, directly to the README file.
- bostand 10y agoI think you are underestimating how interesting your weekend projects are. For the record, my weekend project this Easter was to watch the first season of The Expanse...
- flukus 10y ago> I feel like the document could have benefited a great deal from some simple font color styling. Why is that up to the document and not the user agent? The user agent can be configured so that all documents like nice and uniform.