3 ms·
Getting a PhD in science (or anything else really), has very little to do with being intelligent and everything to do with really really wanting it and being wi
by dagw 16y ago
Getting a PhD in science (or anything else really), has very little to do with being intelligent and everything to do with really really wanting it and being willing to put in the hard work. I know several very intelligent people who failed to get their PhD because they found it more work than they where willing to do, and I know several people with fairly mediocre grades who got PhDs because it was what they really wanted and they where willing to do the work and not give up.
- jamesash 16y agoAgree. As far as the tenure debate, becoming a candidate for being science professor at a top university requires INCREDIBLE single-minded focus, from college through Ph.D. through postdoc. And for that, you get a chance at an academic job, because only a handful are up for grabs in any given year. It's an incredibly high-risk proposition, with a lot of opportunity cost. Your chances are helped immensely if you're not interested in any other activities beyond working in your field. It's a monotonous life in many ways. Not many people would want it to begin with - that's why the Aspbergers types are often the only ones who make it through the filter.
- dagw 16y agoIn fact I wouldn't be surprised if the very highest percentiles of the maths SAT tests is more of test for Aspbergers like single-mindedness and less of test for actually mathematical aptitude. I doubt someone in the 97th percentile is on the whole a significantly dumber or in any way a worse (potential) mathematician than someone in the 99.7th percentile, but they probably don't have the same single-minded zeal.